Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Missouri

Unique Italian spots

An Italian meal that feels distinct and memorable rather than following the same tired formula.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Italian restaurant

Elegant Italian restaurant offers a cozy fine dining atmosphere with modern jazz and loud rock music creating a unique, somewhat lively vibe. Guests enjoy authentic pasta and standout dishes like lamb chops and panna cotta, often choosing the tasting menu for a special occasion experience.

Handmade pasta stands out for its authentic Italian quality. Antipasti like Gnocco Fritto and Crudo offer strong traditional flavors.

Every bite offers exciting and unique flavors. Dishes come across as interesting and well-prepared, making the experience stand out.

People are saying

"The service for date spots here is amazing and the servers are so knowledgeable."

"The four-course tasting menu for Italian food is an excellent value."

"The food here is exciting and unique."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required at all times for dining.

2

Parking is limited; street parking or nearby lot options are available.

3

The four-course tasting menu is reasonably priced and offers great value.

02
No Ordinary Rabbit image 1

Cozy dining room with tasteful decor featuring rabbit-themed accents and mustard yellow highlights creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere. The vibe is romantic and creative, suited for intimate dinners and lively gatherings. Hand-crafted cocktails and a varied menu complement the inviting setting.

Gnocchi stands out with a fantastic texture and flavor. Meatballs come in unique varieties like lamb and chorizo with dates, paired with rich sauces and pancetta.

Unique cocktails and distinctive flavor profiles define the menu. Food and drinks offer a creative twist without any pretentiousness.

People are saying

"The food here is creative, bold, and full of flavor."

"I loved the unique flavor profiles and great cocktails."

"This Italian Food's pistachio gooey butter cake is absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

2

The full dinner menu is available starting at 5 PM.

3

Most appetizers and shareables are under $15, with many under $10.

03
Woodson Stonefire image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, cozy pizza shop with an old school vibe featuring a coke machine and arcade game. Atmosphere is chill and inviting, boosted by heavy metal music playing in the kitchen. Primarily a carry-out joint with personalized pizza boxes adding a unique touch.

Original recipes shape the menu, featuring Toasted Ravioli known for its crisp texture. Homemade marinara sauce stands out and is available for purchase to use at home.

Crust and unique toppings stand out with specialty pizzas offering exciting combinations. Boneless BBQ wings add a distinctive twist alongside a vast selection of unique pies and appetizers.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"I found the pizza here to be a delicious change from other places."

"The service here is uniquely friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only offers takeout and delivery, so dining in is not an option.

2

Woodson Stonefire is carry-out only, with no dine-in seating available.

3

The food is typically ready when promised, ensuring quick service.

04
Parker's Table at Oakland & Yale image 1

Loft-like space with a cozy, artisan food vibe offers European goods, unique cheeses, and top-notch wines. Small, relaxing eating area complements a well-curated selection of charcuterie and sandwiches. The atmosphere blends diversity with a hidden gem feel for specialty food and drink.

Offers a wide variety of fresh baguettes, house-made salami, and quality cheeses. Pasta, dips, and sauces add to the Italian selection.

Offers a phenomenal deli and a great inventory of wine and liquors. Features many unique food and drink choices.

People are saying

"I found their wine selection to be incredible and outstanding."

"The staff here are so friendly and knowledgeable about Italian food."

"The staff here are so friendly and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

The store offers a monthly cheese club with three cheeses to sample.

2

They have a wine club for wine enthusiasts with exclusive selections.

3

Weekend tastings are available, showcasing various wines and cheeses.

05
Black Mountain Wine House STL image 1

Rustic mountain-themed space with wood-burning stove, vintage decor, and wood floors creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere. Hidden outdoor patio offers curbside tables with music and flower centerpieces. Warm vibe fills the room with candlelight and sweet wood aromas, attracting a neighborhood crowd.

Pasta Tuesdays feature a different handmade pasta each week with something cool to try. The bruschetta also stands out as a simple pleasure.

Offers a unique assortment of wine with distinct profiles. Decor blends 18th-century vintage French and American style for a standout look.

People are saying

"The wine spot has such a cozy and lovely atmosphere."

"You have to try the handmade pasta on Pasta Tuesday!"

"The decor here is pretty unique, with an 18th-century vintage French and American style."

Good to know

1

Wine tastings are free every Monday night, offering a chance to learn about wines.

2

Pasta Tuesdays feature new handmade pasta dishes each week.

3

Oysters are available on the first Friday of each month.

06
Union Loafers Cafรฉ and Bread Bakery image 1

Bakery combines minimalist design with a casual, approachable vibe that sometimes feels cramped but lively. Loud music fills the space, creating an energetic but noisy atmosphere. Community energy and genuine kindness stand out among visitors and staff.

Fresh to order marinara pizza stands out with a homemade taste. The pancetta and serrano peppers on the pineapple special add a spicy kick. Meatballs come tender and juicy in house marinara with toasted sourdough topped with olive oil and cheese. Prosciutto sandwiches arrive fast and are very filling.

Trout salad sandwich stands out with its unique flavor. Coffee soda offers a distinctive twist. Pizzas are well crafted and unique without being too unusual.

People are saying

"The bread here is baked to perfection and truly excellent."

"Their pizzas have a perfect crust and well-chosen toppings."

"The pizzas here are unique and well-crafted."

Good to know

1

Reservations open at 4:00 p.m. on the day of visit and are required.

2

Expect a 50-minute wait time after placing your order.

3

The cafรฉ serves lunch from 11 AM to 3 PM and dinner from 5 PM to 9:15 PM.

07
Frazer's Restaurant & Lounge image 1
American restaurant

Warm lighting and a cozy outdoor patio create a welcoming and charming atmosphere. Eclectic decor and a lively bar scene bring an interesting and fun vibe. Cocktails stand out as a bold feature, complementing the inviting space and diverse crowd.

Seafood pasta features scallops and a white sauce that balances richness well. Chicken dishes like the Piccata and white chicken pasta special offer tasty options alongside excellent pasta specials.

Cocktails offer an interactive experience with unique flavors like the Flower Power drink. The space feels inviting and complements the distinct drink menu.

People are saying

"The cocktails here are creative and carefully crafted."

"The seafood pasta with white sauce was amazing and not too rich."

"The cocktails here are unique and exciting."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

The restaurant offers a special menu on New Year's Eve.

3

Parking is available nearby, but can fill up quickly during peak times.

08
Edera Italian Eatery image 1
Italian restaurant

Outdoor seating includes a beautiful patio with a garden wall and winter igloos, creating a cozy and festive atmosphere. The vibe suits intimate gatherings and relaxed evenings with drinks. A top-class bar offers a variety of cocktails enjoyed on the patio.

Pasta dishes stand out with variations like pappardelle bolognese that are consistently exceptional. Fried mozzarella and brussel sprouts add tasty starters alongside the well-loved pizza.

The patio offers a unique experience with a super cool chalet setting. Cocktails feature inventive blends, and the Amaretto waffle uses house-made dough with a special mix of ingredients.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is really good, especially the pasta."

"The patio offers a pleasant, shaded experience, even on hot days."

"The Amaretto waffle's unique blend of ingredients was amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for outdoor seating to avoid disappointment.

2

Parking can be challenging during busy hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a Saturday night market with various vendors.

09
Farmhaus Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Storefront space feels cozy and intimate with tables placed very close together, creating a personal but tight setting. Kitchen proximity adds cooking vibes to the atmosphere, which is simple and pleasant but lacks elevated design elements. Diners tend to be happy, and the vibe remains consistent over time.

Pasta dishes stand out with creamy spaghetti and excellent ravioli. Fish dishes also rank among the best in St. Louis.

Menu features rotated dishes with unique ingredients and lovely presentation. Entrees combine flavors in ways that impress taste buds.

People are saying

"The dinner here was a stellar experience with flavorful, tender dishes."

"The Italian food, especially the creamy spaghetti, is so flavorful."

"The dishes here are unique and delicious."

Good to know

1

You need to make a reservation to dine here.

2

The menu is based on seasonal ingredients, so the experience can vary.

3

There was an extra fee for using a credit card on bills over $250.

10
The Gin Room image 1

Bar offers an intimate setting with a garden patio and dazzling array of gin bottles. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, suited for cocktails and quiet conversations. Staff share deep knowledge of gin, enhancing the experience with unique crafted gin drinks.

Fresh burrata salad features basil foam and crispy Parmesan bits. Lasagna and ravioli stand out among the pastas. Desserts include cannoli cheesecake with a caramelized sugar crust and fluffy tiramisu with balanced sweetness.

Crafted gin based drinks stand out with unique craft cocktails and a huge alcohol selection. The venue pairs gins from around the world with mostly in house ingredients for a unique experience.

People are saying

"You have to try their inventive, fun cocktails; they're truly fabulous."

"The Italian food, especially the burrata and meatballs, was insanely good."

"I loved their unique craft cocktails and huge alcohol selection."

Good to know

1

During happy hour, signature cocktails are available for $10 each.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends, to secure a seat.

3

The venue has a policy against one party taking all bar seats.

11
Monte Bello Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Dining takes place in a rustic basement with low ceilings and a 50s throwback vibe. The atmosphere is lively and family-oriented, often becoming quite loud when full. The place is known for outstanding pizza and a homey feel.

Toasted raviolis stand out with a unique, softer texture compared to the usual hard ones, paired with homemade Italian sausage and generous toppings like bacon. Desserts include cream cheese ravioli with strawberry topping and chocolate ravioli with pecans, both offering a sweet twist on Italian classics.

Rustic atmosphere sets this place apart. The toaster ravioli offers a unique flavor not commonly found elsewhere.

People are saying

"You have to try the homemade Italian food, especially the ravioli."

"I loved the homemade beef ravioli; it was so tasty."

"The pizza here is thin, crispy, and totally unique."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait over an hour during peak dinner times; arrive early.

2

Reservations are recommended for evening visits to avoid long waits.

3

Order ahead to reduce wait time for your pizza.

12
Imo's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious and clean pizza house offers a quiet, chill vibe with a warm, comfortable atmosphere. Guests find St. Louis style pizza distinct and often fresh, paired with toasted raviolis unique to the menu. Convenient parking and a peaceful setting make it a calm refuge in the city.

Toasted ravioli stands out with a crispy texture and is a popular choice here. Pizza features a provel and mozzarella mixture that adds a rich, creamy flavor.

Pizza features a unique cheese and a style that stands out as distinctly St Louis. The flavor profile is special and tasty compared to typical pizzas.

People are saying

"I thought their pizza was unique and shockingly good."

"The Italian food's cracker-like crust is a nice change of pace."

"I found the pizza here to be unique and tasty."

Good to know

1

Parking is convenient and available near the restaurant.

2

The lunch deal offers an entree, side, and drink for $12.

3

Delivery is not available to offices, as per the manager's policy.

13
The Hill Food Co image 1

Warehouse-style space with a ghost kitchen setup and food lockers for pickup creates a quiet, no-frills atmosphere focused on convenience. Small lobby and limited parking shape the experience, attracting those seeking late night carryout with minimal interaction.

Cajun Chicken Pasta features super spicy and over seasoned sauce with a lot of penne. The dish has excessive saltiness and a heavy sauce that some find inedible.

Pickup involves a different process than typical takeout. The food hall offers a distinctive atmosphere that stands out from usual spots. Overall, the experience feels unconventional and fresh.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious and super spicy."

"The pickup process here is unique and different."

Good to know

1

The Hill Food Co is a pickup-only restaurant with no dine-in options.

2

Parking is limited and the lot has potholes, making it difficult to navigate.

3

The food is ready for pickup very quickly after ordering.

14
Lemp Mansion image 1
Restaurant

Historic mansion offers a haunting atmosphere with beautiful architecture and a quiet, clean main area. Guests engage with interactive actors and use paranormal investigation equipment during events. The space includes a small museum, bar, and comfortable seating that enhance the immersive experience.

Toasted ravioli stands out with its crispy texture and rich flavor. Steak tips and cajun pasta add bold, savory options to the menu.

Flambรฉed bananas foster and flaming desserts create a unique dining experience. A fixed price offers a parade of distinctive dishes that differ from American cuisine. The space feels beautiful and unique, fitting for medium-sized groups.

People are saying

"You have to do the haunted tour of this historical site; it's an experience of a lifetime."

"The flambรฉed desserts were a fun and unique experience."

"The toasted ravioli here are the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for the Murder Mystery Dinner, especially on weekends.

2

The all-you-can-eat Sunday dinner is popular and offers a large variety of dishes.

3

Murder Mystery Dinners are interactive and require advance booking.

15
Pennydrop Bar + Kitchen image 1

Old bank building offers a stunning environment with interesting architecture and a cozy atmosphere. Live acoustic music often plays, creating a fun and lively vibe. The space balances high-class style without feeling stuffy.

Burrata salad and fried ravioli stand out among the Italian dishes. The marinara sauce with tortellini and the chicken with gnocchi also deliver solid flavors.

Building and site show unique beauty and charm. Wings come with a distinctive flavored sauce that tastes good even if the peach flavor is subtle.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and wonderful."

"The Italian food here is amazing, with attentive service from Maurice and Chef Bailey."

"The building's unique and beautiful design is stunning."

Good to know

1

Many food items are often unavailable by 8:30 am and 9:30 am.

2

Expect high prices that may not match the quality of food served.

3

The drink menu may not be up to date, with several options often out.

Discover more

Missouri

Area guide
Loading Map...