Tiny space with cozy atmosphere feels like a classic New York pizza shop. Pizza boasts thin crust and foldable slices with a homemade sauce that sells out fast. Simple toppings keep each bite cheesy and authentic.
Slices offer a classic thin crust with a foldable structure true to New York style. Toppings stay simple and balanced, delivering a cheesy, savory bite that matches the original city's flavor.
"I thought La Pizza served the best New York style pizza in town."
"I enjoyed the pizza and salad here."
"This place has a real old-school vibe and feels authentic."
Good to know
Call ahead to order, especially on weekends, to avoid selling out.
Expect a 40-minute wait if you don't order in advance.
Limited seating means arriving early is recommended to secure a spot.
Small spot in a strip mall serves authentic Neapolitan style with fresh mozzarella and herbs. Thin crust and classic toppings deliver true New York style flavor. Friendly chef chats with guests, making the vibe warm and inviting.
Thin crust and classic toppings define the New York style pizza here. The slices hold up well and deliver a very good taste true to the style.
Good to know
Expect a 25-minute wait during peak hours, but drinks are offered for free while waiting.
Prices for pizzas are flat rate regardless of toppings, making it easy to order.
The restaurant only offers one pizza size, a 14-inch, which may be small for some.
Small Italian pizzeria offers outstanding toppings on its New York style pizza. Cozy vibe with stained glass windows and classic neon lighting creates a relaxed, local feel. Casual crowd enjoys the comfortable space with TVs and a banquet room.
Outstanding quality toppings define the New York style pizza here. It stands out as one of the best New York style pizzas found west of the Mississippi.
Good to know
Medium pizza costs $20, with each topping an additional $2.
A'mis Pizza offers St. Louis, Chicago, and New York style pizzas.
Lunch specials are available at reasonable prices.
Small space buzzes with funky murals and loud music, creating a lively bar vibe. Large, thin slices deliver classic New York style pizza with a crispy crust and balanced sauce. Outdoor seating offers a spacious communal area perfect for socializing.
Slices come large and thin, capturing the classic New York style. The pizza offers a crispy crust with a balanced sauce and cheese blend that stands out in the local scene.
Good to know
The pizza making class is a fun way to learn about pizza.
Local vendors showcase their creations during special event nights.
Reservations are recommended for the pizza making class due to limited spots.
Enjoy authentic New York style pizza with a thin, cracker crust and classic toppings. Expect a loud, chaotic atmosphere where kids run freely and owners chat with customers. Decor feels worn and dated, adding to the casual, unpolished vibe.
Authentic New York style pizza stands out with a thin, cracker crust and classic toppings. It offers a close-to-New York experience in a region dominated by different pizza styles.
Good to know
You can buy pizza by the slice at Racanelli's.
The pizza is prepared fairly quickly.
Expect higher prices compared to other local pizza shops.
Wood-burning ovens create a lively vibe with music and hockey on TV. Enjoy authentic New York style pizza featuring thin, foldable crusts and balanced toppings. Outdoor seating offers a relaxed spot despite a worn patio.
Slices show authentic New York style with a thin, foldable crust and balanced toppings. Pizza arrives on time and tastes close to what you'd find in New York itself.
Good to know
The lunch special includes a slice of pizza, a salad, and a drink for $10.
Expect to wait an hour for takeout food during busy hours.
The dinner for two special includes a 14-inch pizza, salad, drinks, and ice cream for about $35-$40.
Minimalist interior and family-friendly setting create a cozy vibe. Pizza shines with authentic New York style featuring thin, foldable crust and classic toppings. Relaxing space pairs well with fantastic music for a great local experience.
Offers authentic New York style pizza with a thin, foldable crust and classic toppings. Recognized for capturing the East Coast flavor closely in the area.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended on Friday and Saturday nights due to high demand.
Parking can be challenging; consider arriving early to secure a spot.
Pizza by the slice is available, catering to different tastes.
Spacious interior offers a warm atmosphere despite some maintenance issues. Long wait times reflect popularity of authentic New York style pizza with a no-frills crust and minimal toppings. Comfortable but dated environment keeps the focus on classic flavors.
Authentic New York style pizza shines here with a quality that stands out in the area. The pizza captures the true taste and texture of New York, making it a go-to spot for that classic slice.
Good to know
Expect long wait times of up to two hours for food orders.
The restaurant has no air conditioning, making it very warm inside.
Online ordering is unavailable after 7 pm.