Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Cookie deli spots in New Jersey

You want a deli that stocks a decent cookie. You expect your lunch stop to handle the dessert course just as well as the main event.

Based on 690 Opinions
+687
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
George's Union Subs image 1
George's Union Subs image 2
George's Union Subs image 3
View all
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop with newly renovated interior and modern decor offers a clean, inviting atmosphere that feels like visiting a friend's house. The space includes small dining area and carries the authentic vibe of an old school Jersey sub shop. Friendly energy and fresh meat aromas create a welcoming environment.

Cookies come with large chunks of chocolate and a homemade feel. They pair well with subs and get strong praise for being very enjoyable.

Freshly sliced deli meat and exceptionally flavorful subs stand out here. The deli maintains a clean, updated space and balances meats and bread well for an authentic deli experience.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwich was excellent, with fresh meat and bread."

"This Local Spot's owner, George, makes you feel like you know him."

"This deli's fresh-sliced meats and soft bread make amazing subs."

Good to know

1

Prices are affordable and well-priced for the quality of food.

2

Portions are generous, ensuring a filling meal.

3

The shop maintains a clean and welcoming environment.

02
Oak Street Liquors And Deli image 1

Italian-themed deli combines modern woodwork with colorful outdoor seating for a bright, inviting atmosphere. The space draws a local crowd seeking large, flavorful sandwiches and international grocery staples. It balances a clean, stocked environment with a casual, neighborhood vibe.

Homemade chocolate chip cookies stand out with a rich, fresh taste. Cookie sandwiches also impress with their unique texture and flavor.

Wraps and salads stand out with exceptional quality for a corner deli. Sandwiches come across as great, complementing an overall phenomenal deli selection.

People are saying

"I found a huge and impressive wine selection here."

"I thought the homemade chocolate chip cookies were the best I've had."

"The deli sandwiches here are great."

Good to know

1

The store opens at 9am, making it convenient for early shoppers.

2

Parking can be challenging, so consider arriving early.

3

Delivery is available for orders placed through their website.

03
L&D Sapore Ravioli & Cheese image 1
Italian grocery store

Small Italian grocery store with an old school vibe and atmosphere like Little Italy. Busy during lunch with a friendly, kind energy and a focus on high-quality, authentic sandwiches and fresh mozzarella. Space feels cozy but delivers large, overflowing trays and generous portions.

Cookies come very soft and fresh with options like rainbow cookies available on request. Portions are generous and the owner sometimes offers free samples.

Exceptional quality and service define the deli experience here. Sandwiches stand out with fresh ingredients and authentic Italian flavors, creating a truly spiritual experience for deli lovers.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are so high quality, they could feed a small family."

"I thought the ravioli here was the best I ever had."

"The deli sandwiches here are mystical and truly out of this world."

Good to know

1

Parking at L&D Sapore Ravioli & Cheese can be an issue.

2

They are busy during lunch, so ordering ahead is recommended.

3

There's no seating inside, but a few tables are available outside.

04
Valente's Italian Deli image 1

Italian deli with wide variety of top-quality food and fresh house-made mozzarella creates a friendly, family atmosphere. Sandwiches and breads stand out for their quality and freshness. The place feels well put together and clean.

Cookies by the register come out perfectly baked. They pair well with subs and salads from the deli.

Offers a fresh wide variety of Italian products with a small butcher in the back. Staff craft awesome sandwiches with excellent service in a very clean setting.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal, especially the fresh mozzarella."

"I considered this the best Italian deli around."

"I found the cookies to be absolutely amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in front and on the side of the deli.

2

The kitchen is very clean and well-maintained.

3

Valente's Italian Deli offers a huge choice of top-quality food and beverages.

05
A & G Italian Fine Foods North Brunswick NJ image 1

Italian deli offers authentic ambiance with huge, flavorful sandwiches and creamy fresh mozzarella. The place serves quick service and features a wide selection of deli items, pasta, and specialty sandwiches. It stands out for high-quality Italian food reminiscent of New York City experiences.

Rainbow cookies stand out as phenomenal here. They often include a package of homemade cookies for free, with tri-color cookies regularly ordered alongside other dishes.

Small but great Italian deli with a wide selection of deli items, pasta, sauces, and oils. Known for Chicken Parm and strong catering services that impress.

People are saying

"This lunch spot's food is always fresh and delicious."

"I found it to be the best Italian deli around."

"The rainbow cookies here are phenomenal."

Good to know

1

Catering services are available and can be arranged easily.

2

The family meal deal offers great value for four people.

3

Prices for sandwiches start around $14 for the Italian hoagie.

06
K&S Italian Specialties image 1

Old school Italian deli with wide selection of fresh meats, cheeses, and imported specialties creates a nostalgic atmosphere filled with familiar smells. Busy spot known for large, flavorful sandwiches and authentic Italian products that stand out in quality and portion size.

Italian cookies include Sicilian Cucidati with a rich, traditional flavor. The selection features imported Italian cookies alongside fresh breads and other Italian specialties.

Offers a wide selection of deli, prepared foods, and packaged items. Serves lunch, dinner, and dessert with an amazing deli counter.

People are saying

"You have to try their fresh Italian food, especially the meats and cheeses."

"These sandwiches are huge and stacked with fresh ingredients."

"I found the sandwiches at this deli to be the best in town."

Good to know

1

K&S Italian Specialties offers a wide selection of fresh meats, cheeses, and prepared foods.

2

Sandwiches are large and can easily be shared between two people.

3

Prices are generally better than most other local delis.

07
Chinos Bakery & Cafe image 1

Bright, clean space blends modern tableware with a homey, mom-and-pop vibe and hints of anime artwork. Atmosphere stays welcoming and chill, inviting quick stops or relaxed visits. Known for fresh, delicious sandwiches and a tidy, friendly environment.

Cookies come in generous portions, including a huge chocolate chip cookie and an amazing oatmeal cookie. The shop offers a wide variety of cookies and pastries with accommodating service.

Fresh breads and deli selections stand out with an extensive sandwich menu like small NYC delis. Deli sandwiches come packed with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavor.

People are saying

"This sandwich is delicious and made with fresh ingredients."

"I enjoyed getting their amazing cookies."

"I thought the deli sandwiches were packed with fresh ingredients."

Good to know

1

The menu offers a variety of breakfast and lunch options at affordable prices.

2

Expect low wait times during weekday mornings.

3

The 20oz smoothie costs $8, which is a great price.

08
Flemington Deli image 1

Small deli with cozy seating and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Friendly staff create a thoughtfully curated vibe despite limited space and some humidity. Known for exceptional sandwiches and breakfast items made fresh to order.

Sea salt cookies and matcha almond muffins appear among the pastries. Cookies come with coffee, often served on the house. Staff check before offering cookies to kids while waiting.

Offers more than typical sandwiches with specials and homemade pastries. Serves Cold Deli Sandwiches, Porkette, Brisket, Goodfella, Reuben, and the Deli-Buster Supreme. Provides local delivery without third-party apps.

People are saying

"The breakfast here is served with the friendliest welcome."

"The deli sandwiches here are delicious and expertly constructed."

"They were so welcoming, they even gave us cookies on the house."

Good to know

1

Flemington Deli charges a 4% surcharge for card payments.

2

Parking is limited around Flemington Deli.

3

Menu prices may not reflect actual prices due to recent increases.

09
Aversa's Italian Bakery & Deli image 1

Small bakery offers huge selection of tasty deli items, gorgeous cakes, and fresh bread. Display cases stay immaculate, showcasing hard-to-find cookies and vegetarian options. Atmosphere feels packed with variety and quality, attracting many who take home antipasto and Mediterranean trays.

Selection includes many hard-to-find cookies alongside Italian cookies and chocolate pretzels. Variety ranges from classic to unique options.

Small store offers a huge selection of tasty deli items and prepared foods. Italian deli includes a variety of baked breads and confections.

People are saying

"The cakes and cheesecakes here are fabulous and the best I ever had."

"The deli has a huge selection of tasty cakes and desserts."

"I tasted fabulous cakes, especially the cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Prices at the Brigantine location are generally lower than at Margate.

2

Vegan and vegetarian options are available among the prepared foods.

3

The bakery offers a wide selection of cakes, cookies, and pastries.

10
Giancarlo's Bakery image 1

Old school Italian bakery with crowded interior and outdoor seating offers a variety of baked breads, meat pastries, and entrees. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and no-nonsense, attracting those seeking authentic Italian flavors. The place is known for top-quality pastries and cakes with a neighborhood vibe.

Cookies by the pound stand out for their quality and variety. Butter cookies and other pastries consistently deliver excellent flavor and freshness.

Top quality Italian deli products stand out here. The deli section offers a nice variety alongside pastries and frozen dinners that maintain consistent quality.

People are saying

"I found the cakes here to be delicious and beautifully done."

"I found their cookies to be amazing and delicious."

"I loved their baked goods and pastries; the crumb buns were wonderful."

Good to know

1

Giancarlo's Bakery offers a variety of baked goods, including cakes, pies, and pastries.

2

Most items are baked in-house, ensuring freshness and quality.

3

The bakery has a deli section with sandwiches, wraps, and breakfast options.

11
Millburn Deli image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers quiet atmosphere with clean, sanitary surroundings and a new layout. It draws a crowd with unique sandwich selections praised for quality and taste. Pricing tends to be higher than nearby options, but sandwiches often receive high marks for flavor and bread.

Cookies include chocolate chip that satisfy sweet cravings and other treats like pickle chips and marshmallow treats. Using the app earns rewards toward free delivery, cookies, iced tea, or brownies.

Sandwiches here go beyond the usual deli fare with fresh roasted turkey and Calandra bread standing out. The spot keeps everything clean and sanitary while delivering excellent service.

People are saying

"This sandwich is amazing and fresh, the best I ever had."

"This deli's sandwiches are amazing and generously filled."

"The sandwiches are piled high and generously filled with ingredients."

Good to know

1

Online ordering and pickup process is seamless and user-friendly.

2

Parking is stress-free and readily available near the deli.

3

Expect to pay around $15 for a sandwich, which may not include sides.

12
Taliercio's Ultimate Gourmet image 1

Deli counter and coolers line the space, creating a New York-style Italian deli vibe with casual, family-friendly atmosphere. Employees engage actively, ringing a bell to offer free fried ravioli, adding to the lively, nostalgic energy. Indoor and outdoor seating accommodate a steady flow of enthusiastic regulars and sandwich lovers.

An array of Italian cookies includes powdered raspberry-filled ones. Kids get a cookie while waiting, and extra cookies come along for the ride home.

Offers authentic Italian deli options with top-tier service. Recognized as a leading deli in the region for quality and experience.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were top notch and out of this world."

"The fried ravioli here are amazing."

"The fried ravioli here is exceptional and not greasy at all."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait of about 20 minutes for your food during busy hours.

2

Calling ahead is recommended to avoid long wait times.

3

The deli offers over 100 different sandwiches to choose from.

13
European Homemade Provisions image 1

Old school European deli with authentic Polish and German delicacies creates a genuine European atmosphere. Shelves offer hard-to-find kielbasa, pierogies, and cured meats alongside freshly baked rye bread and pastries. Prices vary, but the focus remains on delivering familiar tastes and homemade provisions.

Cream cheese-based cookies with fillings stand out here. Homemade cookies and Polish rye treats add variety to the selection.

Offers a wonderful selection of cheeses, cured meats, and freshly baked bread. Features an old school European style with fresh, accurately priced items.

People are saying

"The homemade salads here are fresh and amazing."

"The deli has great sandwiches, kielbasa, and pierogis."

"I always bought a fresh steak sandwich type roll with double smoked kielbasy."

Good to know

1

European Homemade Provisions offers a selection of imported Polish and German delicacies.

2

The deli has a wonderful selection of cheeses, cured meats, and freshly baked bread.

3

Prices for items may be higher than expected; check before purchasing.

14
Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace image 1

Marketplace combines old school vibes with a boutique Italian atmosphere featuring live classic music and upstairs serene dining. Displays are colorful and organized, evoking a vintage 1950s grocery feel. Shoppers often enjoy a calm, elegant environment with a touch of Italy throughout.

Pignoli cookies stand out with their rich pine nut flavor. Heated tents offer cookies and coffee while waiting. Gluten-free options made in Italy taste delicious.

Amazing deli choices include a wide range of meats, cheeses, and prepared foods. The counter offers hot bar and ready-made dinners alongside fresh pasta and bakery items.

People are saying

"The fresh seafood here is top-notch and wonderful."

"The deli here has an amazing display of homemade prepared foods."

"I found the pignoli cookies to be delicious and amazing."

Good to know

1

Hot food and some sandwiches are 50% off after 7:30 PM.

2

On Fridays, two pizza pies are available for $22 after 7:30 PM.

3

Live performances occur on weekends from 1 to 4 PM.

15
Pinho's Bakery image 1

Bakery offers a large covered patio and a few indoor tables with sunlit glass roof creating a calming atmosphere. Shelves display fresh-made breads and a wide variety of confectionery and desserts. The vibe feels like a warm, community-focused family joint with a sense of culture and comfort.

Italian leaf cookies and custom cookies for weddings, birthdays, and graduations stand out here. Sugar-free options and a large variety of beautiful, personalized cookies also fill the display.

An inviting atmosphere feels more like a welcoming home than a traditional deli. The deli side offers classic sandwiches and breakfast platters elevated to an art form with great quality deli items and fresh baked goods.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be the best I could go to."

"The peanut butter cookies here are huge and so good."

"You have to try the Natas at this Deli; they're the best."

Good to know

1

They make fresh egg tarts every hour, perfect for a quick treat.

2

Complimentary parking is available, but it is limited.

3

Pinho's Bakery offers a wide selection of baked goods, including pastries and sandwiches.

16
Mulberry Street image 1

Unique Italian deli with high-quality meats and family-owned charm offers a wide variety of pasta and sauces. Clean, organized space features freshly made sausage and a cookie assortment by the pound. Atmosphere feels authentic and focused on delivering traditional Italian specialty foods.

A wide variety of cookies and baked pastries fills the selection. The baccio's cookie stands out with its amaretto flavor, cannoli cream, and chocolate.

Offers a heavy Italian theme with a high-quality meat selection. Prices tend to be a little expensive, and product quality can vary.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and beautifully presented."

"Their food is always delicious and cooked to perfection."

"This Italian deli has a high-quality meat selection."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-30 minute wait for food orders.

2

The deli offers a variety of Italian products and homemade meals.

3

Prices are reasonable for high-quality Italian food.

17
Tony & Vinnies Italian Bakery & Deli image 1

Italian bakery and deli offers fresh pastries, outstanding bread, and top-notch baked goods in a spacious setting. Atmosphere feels quiet and subdued, contrasting with its once lively vibe. Known for excellent sandwiches and desserts, it attracts those seeking classic Italian flavors.

Italian cookies stand out alongside cannolis and pastries. Some baked goods like danishes and turnovers can be stale and lack flavor.

Offers a solid selection of Italian baked goods and deli items. Prices run on the expensive side.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and delicious."

"I thought their cookies and bread were the best."

"I considered this deli the best ever."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $12 for a breakfast sandwich.

2

Credit card payments may incur a 3-4% fee.

3

There is ample seating available for dining.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...