Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Unique thrift stores in New Jersey

You hunt for thrifted items that offer a level of uniqueness you cannot find on a standard retail shelf.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Oddball Vintage image 1
Oddball Vintage image 2
Oddball Vintage image 3
View all
Antique store

Tight space filled with quirky vintage items and Mid-Century Modern pieces creates a nostalgic, eclectic vibe. Hip music plays softly, adding to the relaxed and playful atmosphere. Frequent visitors find a constantly changing selection that offers unique gifts and decor for diverse tastes.

Offers a wide selection of vintage collectibles including decor, clothes, accessories, and local art. Features a unique vault area with deposit boxes holding vintage items, creating a fun and playful shopping experience.

A constantly changing collection of quirky and unique decor fills the shelves. Every visit reveals 100% unique gifts and a fresh batch of vintage items.

People are saying

"I found so many unique vintage clothes and collectibles here."

"I found so many unique vintage collectibles and decor at this thrift store."

"I found so many unique vintage items that reminded me of childhood."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the lot and on the street.

2

Prices are generally affordable for vintage and antique items.

3

The inventory changes often, so there's always something new to see.

02
Edgewood Collective image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers an extensive, well-curated selection of vintage sports, skate, and streetwear with great energy and a nostalgic atmosphere. The space features unique decorations and constantly updated inventory, attracting enthusiasts looking for quality, competitive prices, and rare finds.

Offers a great selection of vintage streetwear with a focus on 90s and 2000s styles. Owner provides curated finds and frequent discounts, making it a go-to spot for vintage clothing and collectibles.

Unique vintage items stand out here, making the store feel different from others. The decorations add a distinct touch that enhances the overall vibe.

People are saying

"The owner Nick is super knowledgeable about the vintage items."

"The owner Nick is super nice and really knows his stuff."

"The owner's super nice and offers great deals."

Good to know

1

The store offers a constantly updated selection of unique vintage items.

2

Online shopping is available with fast shipping options.

3

Discounts and giveaways are frequently offered to customers.

03
West End Garage image 1
Shopping mall

Large space with eclectic booths offers unique antiques and handmade local goods. Atmosphere feels artsy and nostalgic, inviting slow browsing and discovery. Cozy cafe with excellent pastries complements the shopping experience.

A mix of vintage stalls, handcrafted items, and local vendor booths fills the space. Clothing, jewelry, collectibles, and pottery appear alongside new and retro pieces.

Dozens of unique vendors offer a wide variety of hand-made and antique items. Many finds are one-of-a-kind gifts not available elsewhere.

People are saying

"I found so many unique treasures and cool items here."

"I found this vintage shop to be a treasure trove of unique finds."

"I found so many unique vintage finds and cool items at this thrift store."

Good to know

1

All sales are final at West End Garage.

2

Expect a variety of unique items from local artisans and vendors.

3

Bring cash for some vendors as not all accept credit cards.

04
Revive Consignment / Somerville, NJ image 1

Bright, open space with beautifully curated selections creates an inviting, friendly atmosphere. Clean, organized layout features high-quality designer items and affordable prices. Frequent new inventory and comfortable seating make shopping easy and enjoyable.

Unique eclectic jewelry and vintage handbags stand out here. The 50% room features a mix of vintage bags and modern clothing.

Many unique items fit different styles, including eclectic jewelry pieces and vintage handbags. Fashionable tops and unique earrings also stand out.

People are saying

"The staff here are the sweetest people ever when helping with women's clothing."

"I found so many unique vintage bags and jewelry at this thrift store."

"I found this place to be a unique gem."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $10-20 for most jeans and tops.

2

New merchandise is displayed frequently, ensuring variety.

3

All items are posted online for easy browsing and purchasing.

05
Another Man's Treasure image 1
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers a magical, nostalgic atmosphere with velvet lip-shaped couch and a balcony of fancy frocks. The space feels cool and well curated, featuring unique vintage pieces including designer items, leather, denim, and vintage lingerie. It attracts those seeking organized, high-quality vintage fashion with fitting rooms available for try-ons.

Unique, vintage clothing fills the shelves, including designer pieces, sweatshirts, jackets, and lingerie. Open fitting rooms and a curated selection of high-end, early to mid-20th century items make it stand out.

Unique vintage pieces fill the shelves, all in great condition and spanning a wide price range. Many items serve as perfect gifts or special finds for personal use.

People are saying

"I found the vintage clothing and accessories at this thrift store to be really great."

"The vintage staff here is super friendly and helpful."

"I found unique vintage pieces in great condition."

Good to know

1

Fitting rooms are available for trying on clothes.

2

Prices for non-branded items start at $60.

3

The store is well-organized and color-coded for easy browsing.

06
Rebel Supply Co. image 1
Clothing store

Eclectic clothing store blends vintage charm with modern consignment in a carefully curated, easy-to-navigate space. Warm, community-driven atmosphere welcomes diverse shoppers, featuring a plus-size section and unique gifts. Events like local shows and dance parties add lively energy beyond typical retail.

Offers screaming bargains on clothing consignment and fun gifts. Features iconic vintage in great shape, contemporary consignment, and unique novelty items.

Personal interactions create a one-of-a-kind shopping experience. The store offers unique novelty items, consignment pieces, and vintage goods alongside well-curated clothing and gifts.

People are saying

"This consignment shop feels like home with its amazing staff."

"You'll find unique pieces and genuine hospitality here."

"The thrift store staff makes you feel like you're home."

Good to know

1

Rebel Supply Co. offers a wide selection of unique vintage clothing and gifts.

2

The store features a plus-size consignment section, which is rare in thrift shops.

3

Expect a friendly atmosphere with a welcoming owner who knows the community.

07
Back on the Racks image 1
Consignment shop

Large consignment shop with color-coordinated racks and well-organized sections creates an enjoyable browsing experience. Atmosphere feels positive and energetic, supported by lovely dressing rooms and a convenient furniture pickup service. Offers a wide variety of affordable, stylish clothing and home decor items.

An amazing selection of vintage clothing and accessories fills the shelves. Prices match those at discount retail stores, making it a bargain spot despite feeling a bit overpriced for a thrift store.

Expertise guides shoppers to distinctive items with unique pieces that stand out. Teachers often seek and recommend these one-of-a-kind outfits.

People are saying

"The women's clothing staff are so helpful and kind."

"The hosts' professionalism and enthusiasm made shopping here unique and fun."

"The Thrift Store staff, especially Emma, is so helpful and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The clothes are organized by color for easy browsing.

2

Prices are generally excellent, offering good value for quality items.

3

Expect a limited selection of furniture and home decor.

08
Fae & Phantom image 1
Hair salon

Vintage aesthetic blends with a boutique of adorable vintage clothing and unique decor like a mushroom table. The atmosphere feels sensory conscious and LGBTQIA+ friendly, welcoming diverse styles and identities. Live band performances add a lively, creative energy to the intimate space.

The shop offers a unique vintage clothing selection with lots of adorable and beautiful items. It fits a niche for those seeking a cool vintage style alongside trendy haircuts like shag or mullet.

Chiara delivers unique haircuts and vivid colors with clear talent and knowledge. The salon pairs with a vintage shop, creating a cool and distinctive vibe.

People are saying

"Chiara at this hair salon knows exactly what you want."

"Chiara's creativity and talent for unique haircuts and vivid colors are amazing."

"Chiara creates unique haircuts and vivid colors with amazing expertise."

Good to know

1

Fae & Phantom is LGBTQ+ friendly and judgment-free.

2

Chiara offers a wide range of hair services, including cuts and colors.

3

The boutique features a charming selection of vintage clothing.

09
Udelco image 1
Vintage clothing store

Warehouse space filled with chaotic piles of vintage clothing sorted by type and era, not size. Atmosphere is humid and smoky, with a strong old smell and no air conditioning. Shoppers bring cash to dig through extensive collections of unique, reasonably priced items despite the disorganized setup.

Offers a huge collection of vintage clothing with many unique and quirky items. Prices stay reasonable, making it a solid spot for second-hand enthusiasts.

Shelves hold a mix of unique vintage items and quirky finds. Prices stay reasonable, with some standout pieces like an authentic military uniform and a Joe Camel windbreaker for $15.

People are saying

"I found so many unique vintage clothing items at this shop."

"I found great vintage pieces and unique items at this thrift store."

"I found so many unique vintage items at good prices."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash for purchases.

2

Prices are marked on a whiteboard at the entrance; take a photo for reference.

3

Items are mostly in big cardboard boxes, making specific finds challenging.

10
Pearl St. Consignment and Custom Clothes image 1

Small consignment shop with trendy, retro vintage vibe and Barbie pink, emo, artistic style. Offers curated selection of alternative fashion including Punk, Goth, and Lolita styles. Features adorable fitting rooms and easy parking nearby.

Offers a wide range of vintage clothing and accessories with a unique, curated selection. Carries alternative fashion styles like Punk, Emo, Goth, and Lolita in a barbie pink, emo, retro vintage vibe.

Vintage clothing and accessories stand out with a curated selection. The shop offers a personable vibe and carries unique fashion pieces rarely found elsewhere.

People are saying

"I found unique vintage and alternative fashion pieces at this thrift store."

"I found so many unique and fashionable goodies at this consignment shop."

"I found so many unique fashion pieces, especially vintage and alternative styles."

Good to know

1

Parking is easy with several spots available next to the store.

2

Prices on used and custom clothing are affordable and reasonable.

3

Expect a fast turnover of unique items; buy quickly if you see something you like.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...