Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Cool thrift stores in New Jersey

A cool thrift store holds the promise of finding something that no one else has.

Based on 616 Opinions
+613
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Edgewood Collective image 1
Edgewood Collective image 2
Edgewood Collective image 3
View all
Vintage clothing store

Vintage clothing store offers an extensive, well-curated selection of vintage sports, skate, and streetwear with great energy and a nostalgic atmosphere. The space features unique decorations and constantly updated inventory, attracting enthusiasts looking for quality, competitive prices, and rare finds.

Offers a great selection of vintage streetwear with a focus on 90s and 2000s styles. Owner provides curated finds and frequent discounts, making it a go-to spot for vintage clothing and collectibles.

Nostalgia fills the air with cool T-shirts lining the walls. Owners bring a friendly vibe and deep knowledge, making the space feel inviting and relaxed.

People are saying

"The owner Nick is super knowledgeable about the vintage items."

"The owner Nick is super nice and really knows his stuff."

"The owners were super cool and knew their stuff."

Good to know

1

The store offers a constantly updated selection of unique vintage items.

2

Online shopping is available with fast shipping options.

3

Discounts and giveaways are frequently offered to customers.

02
Oddball Vintage image 1
Antique store

Tight space filled with quirky vintage items and Mid-Century Modern pieces creates a nostalgic, eclectic vibe. Hip music plays softly, adding to the relaxed and playful atmosphere. Frequent visitors find a constantly changing selection that offers unique gifts and decor for diverse tastes.

Offers a wide selection of vintage collectibles including decor, clothes, accessories, and local art. Features a unique vault area with deposit boxes holding vintage items, creating a fun and playful shopping experience.

Small downtown area holds a store with a little bit of everything. Shelves fill with knick-knacks, oddities, and cool finds that invite hours of browsing.

People are saying

"I found so many unique vintage clothes and collectibles here."

"I found so many unique vintage collectibles and decor at this thrift store."

"I found so many unique, vintage, and handmade items; it's a cool place."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the lot and on the street.

2

Prices are generally affordable for vintage and antique items.

3

The inventory changes often, so there's always something new to see.

03
Gift To Earth Thrift Store image 1

Small, cozy thrift store with tight aisles and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers a large, well-organized selection of clothes, shoes, accessories, and household goods at affordable prices. Includes a food pantry and donates proceeds to environmental causes.

Quality items stand out with many gems and vases offered at bargain prices. Discounts vary by tag color, making it easy to find good deals on unique finds.

People are saying

"This thrift store has a beautiful mission supporting environmental conservation."

"I found a ton of women's clothing to look through and discovered gems."

"I found the vibes and prices here to be pretty cool."

Good to know

1

The store runs weekly color tag discounts of 75%, 50%, and 25%.

2

They offer a student discount for more affordable shopping.

3

All proceeds go to environmental causes.

04
Unleashed Thrift image 1
Thrift store

Small space with a modern, Brooklyn vibe offers a thoughtfully curated selection of stylish clothes, accessories, and home decor. Atmosphere feels cozy and fun, attracting those seeking unique, higher-end secondhand pieces at reasonable prices.

A very nicely curated thrift store with a cute vibe. Offers a range of vintage clothes and quick outfit options.

Great pieces and great deals make this store stand out. The staff adds to the super cool vibe.

People are saying

"I found stylish women's clothing at affordable prices."

"I found great pieces at this thrift store for affordable prices."

"It's a cool place with great vibes and deals."

Good to know

1

The store has a great selection of higher-end secondhand clothing.

2

The prices at Unleashed Thrift are always reasonable.

3

The store is well-organized and clean, making it easy to browse.

05
West End Garage image 1
Shopping mall

Large space with eclectic booths offers unique antiques and handmade local goods. Atmosphere feels artsy and nostalgic, inviting slow browsing and discovery. Cozy cafe with excellent pastries complements the shopping experience.

A mix of vintage stalls, handcrafted items, and local vendor booths fills the space. Clothing, jewelry, collectibles, and pottery appear alongside new and retro pieces.

Lots of cool and different stuff fills dozens of little shops. The vibe feels super cool and fun with a mix of antiques and unique finds.

People are saying

"I found so many unique treasures and cool items here."

"I found so many unique vintage finds and cool items at this thrift store."

"I found so many cool, unique things among the different shops."

Good to know

1

All sales are final at West End Garage.

2

Expect a variety of unique items from local artisans and vendors.

3

Bring cash for some vendors as not all accept credit cards.

06
conSHINEment image 1
Consignment shop

Consignment shop offers a curated selection of high-quality, vintage and aesthetic clothing with affordable prices. The atmosphere is chill and comforting with loud, good music and friendly management. Fitting rooms are functional but simple, supporting a relaxed shopping experience.

Vintage clothing options stand out with a mix of aesthetic and designer pieces. The store feels clean without the typical thrift smell and often has sales with discounts.

Great vibes come from the cool management and the store manager. The shop offers many cool vintage brands and a variety of interesting items at reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I found a large variety of quality women's clothing in great condition."

"I found so many cool things, it's my new favorite place."

"The Thrift Store staff were super friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Expect a good assortment of items with a nice array of brands and prices.

2

Prices are generally affordable, but some items may be priced high for thrift.

3

There is no fitting room or return policy, so check sizes carefully.

07
Rebel Supply Co. image 1
Clothing store

Eclectic clothing store blends vintage charm with modern consignment in a carefully curated, easy-to-navigate space. Warm, community-driven atmosphere welcomes diverse shoppers, featuring a plus-size section and unique gifts. Events like local shows and dance parties add lively energy beyond typical retail.

Offers screaming bargains on clothing consignment and fun gifts. Features iconic vintage in great shape, contemporary consignment, and unique novelty items.

Space doubles as a community hub with local shows, fundraisers, DJs, and dance parties. The aesthetic blends eclectic charm with an effortlessly cool vibe.

People are saying

"This consignment shop feels like home with its amazing staff."

"The thrift store staff makes you feel like you're home."

"The staff here makes you feel like you're home."

Good to know

1

Rebel Supply Co. offers a wide selection of unique vintage clothing and gifts.

2

The store features a plus-size consignment section, which is rare in thrift shops.

3

Expect a friendly atmosphere with a welcoming owner who knows the community.

08
2nd STREET Westfield image 1
Second hand store

Second hand store offers a huge selection of vintage and designer clothing with fair prices and a clean, trendy layout. The atmosphere stays chill despite some inconsistencies in item condition and pricing. Both men and women find unique pieces ranging from affordable vintage to high-end brands.

Affordable vintage and high-end items mix well here. The store offers vintage leather jackets, embroidered sweaters, and designer bags like Coach and MCM at great prices.

Employees create a cool atmosphere with friendly and engaging conversations. The store offers an upscale thrift shop vibe with a wide range of clothes that appeal to many people.

People are saying

"The staff here are so helpful finding vintage treasures."

"The atmosphere here is really cool and chill."

"The thrift store staff are so helpful and kind."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of vintage and gently used clothing.

2

Expect to find high-quality jeans for under $30 in the women's section.

3

Sundays late afternoon offer free public parking nearby.

09
Udelco image 1
Vintage clothing store

Warehouse space filled with chaotic piles of vintage clothing sorted by type and era, not size. Atmosphere is humid and smoky, with a strong old smell and no air conditioning. Shoppers bring cash to dig through extensive collections of unique, reasonably priced items despite the disorganized setup.

Offers a huge collection of vintage clothing with many unique and quirky items. Prices stay reasonable, making it a solid spot for second-hand enthusiasts.

Offers a hidden gem vibe with a focus on vintage clothing and bargains. Appeals to those who enjoy discovering unique finds.

People are saying

"I found so many unique vintage clothing items at this shop."

"I found great vintage pieces and unique items at this thrift store."

"I found this place to be pretty cool."

Good to know

1

They only accept cash for purchases.

2

Prices are marked on a whiteboard at the entrance; take a photo for reference.

3

Items are mostly in big cardboard boxes, making specific finds challenging.

10
2nd STREET Montclair image 1
Second hand store

Second hand store with a fancy look and a wide selection of designer and vintage clothing. Atmosphere feels uncomfortable with dismissive staff and a slow authentication process. Prices vary widely, with some items marked above retail and others offered at very low resale values.

Wide selection includes vintage, designer clothing, and secondhand items. The store stays well stocked and offers consistent bargains.

Offers a cool second-hand thrift selection that fits all styles, from designer to streetwear.

People are saying

"I found great high-end clothes at pretty fair prices."

"This Thrift Store has a great selection of designer and vintage items."

"I found a cool second-hand item suitable for all styles."

Good to know

1

Expect lowball offers for high-end pieces; they often pay pennies on the dollar.

2

Prices for used clothing can be surprisingly high, sometimes above retail.

3

The store frequently updates its inventory, providing a variety of items.

Discover more

New Jersey

Area guide
Loading Map...