Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pie spots in New York

A slice of pie that feels like it was made with a specific point of view rather than mass-produced.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Nettie's Country Bakery image 1
Nettie's Country Bakery image 2
Nettie's Country Bakery image 3
View all

Bakery charms with a beautiful patio under apple trees, perfect for families. Blueberry pie shines as a signature dessert among a wide variety of baked goods. Soft, mellow music adds to the friendly vibe making every visit comforting.

Blueberry pie stands out as a signature dessert here. Peach cobbler and apple strudels join a lineup of delicious pastries and pies alongside a great selection of breads and rolls.

People are saying

"I found the crumb cake here to be outstanding."

"This is the best local bakery for sweets."

"I thought the blueberry pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Nettie's Country Bakery offers a wide variety of cookies, cakes, and pastries.

2

There is both indoor and outdoor seating available for customers.

3

Prices for baked goods can vary, so check before purchasing.

02
Casita of Brooklyn image 1

Small coffee shop offers homemade spinach pies with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cozy indoor seating and a spacious patio with fast Wi-Fi create a laidback vibe. Dog-friendly space with treats and live music makes it a personal retreat for comfort seekers.

Homemade spinach pies come straight from Greek tradition with flaky phyllo and fresh ingredients. Cheese pie and bougatsa also stand out as tasty pastries alongside strong coffee options.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be delicious every single time."

"It's a cozy spot with comfy seats inside."

"I had their homemade spinach pie, it was out-of-this-world."

Good to know

1

Casita fills up fast, so plan accordingly if you want to work there.

2

There are only 3 tables available.

3

The small latte is $5.19, and a 32oz nitro cold brew is $7.

03
Balkan Grind image 1
Coffee shop

Unique Turkish cafรฉ offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with reliable Wi-Fi and puppy-friendly space. Albanian cheese pie delivers an indulgent, rich flavor while chicken pot pie burek is flaky and perfectly seasoned. Ideal for solo work or socializing.

Albanian cheese pie stands out with its indulgent, rich flavor that really hits the spot. The chicken pot pie burek offers a flaky, perfectly seasoned experience unlike anything else.

People are saying

"The pastries here are light, crisp, and not overly sweet."

"The Turkish Coffee here is served by super warm and welcoming people."

"You have to try the Albanian cheese pie; it's the best pastry."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but arriving early is recommended to avoid long lines.

2

The cafe offers a unique selection of Turkish food and sweets.

3

Expect a crowded atmosphere on weekends, especially during peak hours.

04
Al Reef Bakery and Restaurant image 1

Halal restaurant offers warm atmosphere and affordable prices with fresh, authentic bread and delicious falafel. Cheese pie is soft and squishy, best enjoyed fresh in the morning. Friendly people add to the calm, welcoming vibe.

Cheese pie stands out with its soft and squishy texture and delicious flavor. Morning visits offer a chance to try these tasty pies fresh.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, full of flavor and perfectly seasoned."

"The Mediterranean food, especially the shawarma and falafel, is amazing."

"The cheese pie here is delicious and really good."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers breakfast, lunch, dinner, pastries, and bread for takeout.

2

Prices are very fair and affordable for all menu items.

3

The bakery is known for its friendly and kind staff.

05
NoFo Pot Pies Country Market image 1

Cozy market offers a fresh farm food vibe with spotless shelves and a unique selection of prepared meals. Pot pies stand out with tender meat and a perfect crust, while mini versions provide quick, delicious comfort food. Quiet and charming, it feels like a hidden gem.

Pot pies feature tender meat and poultry, fresh vegetables, and a perfect crust. Mini pot pies offer a quick and easy option, with every variety tasting consistently delicious.

People are saying

"I loved their pot pies; the chicken pot pie was delicious."

"The spinach, feta, and tomato quiche was consistently good and fresh."

"I couldn't stop eating the incredible Coconut Cream Pie."

Good to know

1

The market offers a variety of prepared foods, including pot pies, salads, and desserts.

2

Prices for prepared meals are reasonable, making it a good option for takeout.

3

The store has a points program that rewards customers with discounts on future purchases.

06
Gibneys NYC image 1
Irish pub

Irish pub buzzes with live Irish music and big screens, creating a warm vibe. Chicken pot pie shines as a rich, comforting dish, rivaled by hearty shepherd's pie. Rooftop bar adds a lively atmosphere perfect for post-theater drinks.

Chicken pot pie stands out as rich and comforting, often described as the best ever tasted. Shepherd's pie also offers a hearty, delicious option among the pies available.

People are saying

"This pub has a warm, lively, and comfortable atmosphere."

"The food here, especially the shrimp tacos, is delicious."

"I found the chicken pot pie to be the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great deals on drinks and food.

2

Drinks and food are reasonably priced for the area.

3

Last call is taken 20 minutes before closing time.

07
Elysian Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with high ceilings and an olive tree inside. Fresh pies like spinach and feta delight the taste buds. Plenty of outlets and free WiFi make it perfect for work or relaxing.

Fresh pies come in spinach, olive and feta, and cheese varieties. The selection includes Bougatsa and all are very tasty.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be the best in New York."

"This cafe has such a nice, cozy vibe."

"I thought the coffees here were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The cafe is located just outside the Astoria Blvd metro station.

2

The cafe provides free wifi for customers.

3

Elysian Cafe only uses high quality coffee in their beverages.

08
GRAMI CAFFร‰ image 1
Coffee shop

Cozy coffee shop offers family-friendly atmosphere with clean European design and shaded outdoor seating. Pies shine with spinach and feta filling, especially when air-fried for decadence. Warm vibe and low noise make it perfect for focus and relaxation.

Pies here have spinach and feta versions with more filling than dough. Mini pies like spinach and cheese come in small sizes. Heating the spinach pie in an air fryer makes it decadent.

People are saying

"I had one of the best lattes here."

"It's a charming and cozy neighborhood spot."

"The spinach pie is jam-packed with filling and has great flavor."

Good to know

1

The cafe is conveniently located next to the LIRR station.

2

They offer mini options for trying various items.

3

Prices at the cafe are reasonable for the quality offered.

09
Tris Pies image 1
Bakery

Bakery shines with sweet potato pie that melts like butter and sparks childhood memories. Mini pies are individually wrapped for easy sharing and freshness. Quick service and a professional setup make it perfect for special occasions.

Sweet Potato Pie stands out as a masterpiece that melts in your mouth like butter and evokes strong childhood memories. Mini pies come individually wrapped, making them easy to share and preserve, and they deliver the same delicious taste as the full-sized versions.

People are saying

"I thought the pies here were the best I ever had."

"The mini pies here are chef's kiss, especially the vegan ones."

"The Vegan Friendly pies were chef's kiss, especially the mini ones."

Good to know

1

Ordering pies is great for special occasions and dessert tables.

2

Mini pies can be individually wrapped for easy preservation.

3

Some proceeds support Hurricane Melissa relief efforts.

10
Cait's Key Lime image 1

Online bakery offers small-batch key lime pies that are both gluten-free and nut-free. Pies balance tart and creamy flavors without excess sweetness, staying fresh for days. Fresh ingredients and careful craftsmanship make each pie a standout.

Key lime pie stands out for its well balanced, light, and refreshing flavor without being overly sweet. Mini pies also work well for events and the pie consistently delivers a fresh, natural taste.

People are saying

"I thought this Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever had."

"I thought Cait's key lime pie was the best dessert I ever had."

"I considered this the best key lime pie I ever had."

Good to know

1

Cait's Key Lime is an online business; follow their Instagram for updates.

2

The pie comes with a gluten-free crust option and is nut-free.

3

I recommend visiting Cait's website to order some pie.

11
Dukan SYKO Marketplace image 1

Market offers made-from-scratch Syrian pies with rich, authentic flavors. It blends Middle Eastern and Korean groceries for unique finds. Warm, family-like atmosphere invites exploring spicy hummus and other fresh foods.

Made-from-scratch Syrian pies burst with genuine Syrian flavors. Fresh Middle Eastern hand pies and pastries offer perfect seasoning and rich taste.

People are saying

"The Korean food here is amazing, and the staff are so kind."

"I found the fresh Syrian pies bursting with genuine flavors."

"I loved the homemade lentil soup; it was fantastic."

Good to know

1

The marketplace offers a fantastic selection of prepacked traditional items from Syria and Korea.

2

Expect reasonable prices for high-quality products throughout the store.

3

This place has a perfectly curated selection of Korean and Syrian groceries and prepared foods.

12
Langan's image 1
Restaurant

Cocktail bar offers 1920s elegance and Irish charm in a lively setting. Shepherd's pie shines with generous portions and a perfect potato-to-stew ratio. Drinks like Irish Coffee pair well with standout burgers and fries.

Shepherd's pie features a great ratio of potatoes to stew with generous portions. It stands out as a meat and potatoes entrรฉe that many find satisfying.

People are saying

"The food here is really great and delicious."

"It's a great spot for a pre-theater dinner."

"I thought the Shepherd's Pie was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended during busy happy hour periods.

3

Free drinks are offered with a Broadway ticket.

13
MEAMA Georgian Fusion | Wine Bar image 1

Georgian restaurant offers authentic cuisine with a meat pie baked in a brick oven and a cheese pie option. Stylish interior and live jazz create a warm, inviting atmosphere perfect for dining and dancing.

Meat pie comes out perfectly baked in a brick oven. Cheese pie also features on the menu alongside other dishes.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and perfectly balanced."

"The Georgian food here is flavorful and truly authentic."

"The lamb khinkali was excellent with plenty of soup."

Good to know

1

Happy hour wine is available for $7.

2

Live music occurs from 6 to 11 PM.

3

Events are held in the back of the restaurant.

14
Brooklyn Baklava image 1

Bakery offers fresh pies like lamb and spinach/feta with a savory twist. Friendly staff serve homemade Lebanese American dishes in a family-run setting. Don't miss the exceptional pistachio baklava made with traditional ingredients.

Pies come fresh and delicious with standout options like lamb, chicken, and cheese pies made on site. The Spinach/Feta Pie offers a savory twist alongside other treats like pistachios and baklava.

People are saying

"I thought the baklava tasted like heaven."

"I found the Lebanese Kunafa here to be very delicious."

"These Middle Eastern pastries are the best in the neighborhood."

Good to know

1

You should pre-order the knafeh to ensure availability.

2

The prices for the pastries are very reasonable given their high quality.

3

They charge a credit card fee for transactions.

15
Kalye image 1
Filipino restaurant

Four-sided cube with capiz shutters offers a unique Filipino vibe. Enjoy coconut pie and buko pie paired with halo halo. Live jazz and karaoke bring energy after 9pm, while Manila Martinis and Pale Pilsen beer keep the cozy mood for large groups.

Coconut pie and buko pie stand out as sweet treats here. They pair well with ice cream and halo halo for a satisfying finish.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and delicious."

"The food here is packed with bold, comforting Filipino flavors."

"You have to try the buko pie, it's so good."

Good to know

1

They host a live band night on Thursdays.

2

They host a DJ night on Fridays and Saturdays.

3

The venue is suitable for a birthday event.

16
Souk Al Shater image 1
Lebanese restaurant

Cozy spot with a family-owned vibe offers authentic Lebanese fast food and a grocery with imported goods. Meat pies cost just $1 and include vegetarian options like spinach and potato. Affordable prices and strong catering make it a neighborhood favorite.

Meat pies cost just $1 and come in vegetarian options like potato and spinach. Cheese pie stands out as a fantastic choice, and spinach pies get special mention for their flavor.

People are saying

"I found the falafel here to be awesome and crispy."

"I thought the chicken shawarma was the best I had in the city."

"I loved the spinach and cheese pies; they were so delicious."

Good to know

1

Shawarma sandwiches cost $7 and meat pies are $1.

2

The lunch menu changes daily, offering fresh options.

3

There is no seating available; takeout only.

17
La Cheesecake Bake Shop image 1

Small bakery shines with apple pie and cheesecake that draw steady crowds. Cozy space features humorous stickers on walls, adding charm. Prices stay reasonable, making it easy to enjoy homemade desserts like rainbow cookies and key lime pies.

Apple pie stands out with its frequent enjoyment and strong appeal. Pecan pie and cream puffs offer rich flavors, while key lime pies bring a tangy twist.

People are saying

"Their cheesecake is rich, creamy, and full of flavor."

"I considered their rainbow cookies amazing."

"I found the pies to be rich, creamy, and full of flavor."

Good to know

1

This place is cash only.

2

During holiday rush orders, expect 1 to 2 hour waits if the line is out the door.

3

Get there early as there will certainly be a line and people can wait for an hour.

18
Herb&Olive image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers a calm, cozy vibe with soaring ceilings and a mini marketplace. Guests savor fresh ingredients and authentic wines while enjoying live band music. The Greek Milk Custard Pie shines with rich, creamy texture and sweet cinnamon spice.

Greek Milk Custard Pie stands out with a rich, creamy texture. The custard cinnamon pie offers a sweet, spiced flavor that pairs well with savory dishes.

People are saying

"The Greek food here, especially the tender pork and flavorful falafel, is amazing."

"This lunch spot's food is fresh, flavorful, and delicious."

"You have to try the custard cinnamon pie; it's delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant can get busy.

2

The prices are on the expensive side, so plan your budget accordingly.

3

Credit card payments incur a convenience fee unless paid in cash.

19
Cronin and Phelan's image 1

Old-school bar offers a vintage decor and over 15 TVs for live sports fans. Shepherd's pie shines with perfect spice and big portions, while rhubarb pie blends strawberries for a unique taste. Friendly vibe includes card tricks and a large party room for groups.

Shepherd's pie stands out with its perfect spice and generous portions. Rhubarb pie includes strawberries, which can mask the rhubarb flavor.

People are saying

"I tried the bangers and mash; they're delicious Irish sausages with fresh mashed potatoes."

"I thought the food here was exceptional and very tasty."

"The shepherd's pie is perfectly spiced and delicious."

Good to know

1

Daily specials are available, offering great value for meals.

2

Portion sizes are generous, often enough to share.

3

Reservations are not needed; most guests go straight to the bar.

20
Zaros Cafe image 1
Greek restaurant

Family-owned Greek spot offers a cozy vibe with white privacy curtains and a community feel. Gyros are authentic and salads fresh, perfect for dine-in or takeout. Spinach pie shines with its flaky crust, making it a top pick over other pies.

Spinach pie comes right out of the oven with the flakiest coating. It stands out as an unbeatable choice compared to other falafel or spinach pies.

People are saying

"I thought the gyros here were the best I've ever had."

"The salmon with rice and tzatziki is outstanding Greek food."

"I believed this place offered some of the best Greek food I ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer 2 Gyro sandwiches for the price of one on Wednesday and Thursday.

2

Zaros Cafe is mainly a takeout place with some tables for dine-in.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is recommended for quick takeout.

21
Somedays Bakery - LIC image 1

Small bakery offers a warm, airy space with Parisian design and friendly staff. Apple pie is a popular flavor that draws many questions. Savory options like shepherds pie and ricotta spinach pie balance the menu well.

Apple pie stands out with its popular flavor and often draws questions about its source. Shepherds pie and ricotta spinach pie offer savory options alongside the sweet apple pie.

People are saying

"I thought the croissants here were the best I've ever had."

"The pistachio lattice is heavenly and my favorite dessert."

"Everyone asked me where I got this apple pie."

Good to know

1

Somedays Bakery offers an evening menu from 5-9 pm on select nights.

2

The bakery has limited indoor and outdoor seating options.

3

Expect fresh baked goods made daily at Somedays Bakery.

22
Prospect Bar and Grill image 1

Rustic decor and a big bar create a welcoming space with garden patio for outdoor seating. Chicken pot pie shines with its savory filling and flaky crust, perfect alongside mac and cheese. Soft 90's music sets a casual vibe for a local hang-out.

Chicken pot pie stands out with its savory, hearty filling and flaky crust. It pairs well with sides like mac and cheese or prospect eggs.

People are saying

"The food at this bar is way better than it needs to be."

"I enjoyed the awesome beer list and great beers on tap."

"I thought the chicken pot pie was heavenly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are easy to make for large group parties.

2

The venue is family-friendly and suitable for casual gatherings.

3

Happy hour offers decent deals on drinks and appetizers.

23
ME Mediterranean Eatery image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean spot shines with freshly baked bread and a cozy atmosphere that invites relaxation. Blueberry and apple pies are standout treats alongside challah and donuts. Casual vibe and clean space make it a true local community hub.

Blueberry and apple pies stand out among the baked goods. The pies come alongside other treats like challah and donuts. New additions include multigrain bread and baguettes.

People are saying

"I found the falafel here to be the best I ever had."

"The staff here makes you feel like family."

"Their pies were very delicious."

Good to know

1

The place is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

2

A good lunch could cost around $20 for a drink, bowl, and bread.

3

You should get the bread earlier because they have been selling out lately.

24
MOTW Coffee and Pastries image 1

Coffee shop blends modern decor with a warm vibe, perfect for families or lively groups. Chicken pot pie shines with a crispy empanada shell offering hearty flavor. Board games add fun for casual hangouts or study breaks.

Chicken pot pie comes in a crispy empanada shell, delivering a fresh, hearty, and flavorful taste. Empanadas like the Argentinian chicken and BEC are delicious and filling options.

People are saying

"I found the empanadas to be amazing and full of flavor."

"I found the coffee here to be the best I had."

"The chicken pot pie is hearty, flavorful, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect long lines during peak hours, with waits up to 45-50 minutes.

2

The smallest size of matcha costs $9, which may feel steep for some.

3

An extra $1 charge applies for almond milk in drinks.

25
Cascon Cheesecake image 1

Small bakery shines with old world cheesecake and fresh fruit pies like cherry and blueberry. Busy spot offers custom celebration cakes perfect for weddings. Easy access with simple free parking makes visits smooth despite early closing.

Fruit pies come in sectioned cherry, blueberry, and peach varieties with a butter crust and balanced sweetness. Pumpkin pie and Danish ring also stand out, all made fresh alongside cheesecakes and Italian pastries.

People are saying

"I found their cheesecake to be rich and delicious."

"I found their cheesecakes to be rich, delicious, and the best."

"I've always gotten their delicious cheesecake."

Good to know

1

Cascon Bakery takes orders for cakes and special occasions, including wedding cakes.

2

They are closing at 5 PM.

3

On holidays, it is recommended to preorder your cake.

26
The Pastry Box image 1

Small bakery offers bite-sized mini pies with rich flavors like pear and blueberry. Cozy seating and cute decor create a cheerful vibe. Natural light and soft music make it a charming atmosphere for enjoying world-class pastries.

Mini pies come in bite-sized portions and pack a lot of flavor. Pear and blueberry pies show a beautiful presentation and taste. Apple pies and chocolate chip cookies are well-made and flavorful.

People are saying

"I thought the chocolate chip cookie was amazing."

"I thought the brownies were the best I've ever had."

"The team here is amazing and welcoming."

Good to know

1

The store often sells out of items 20 minutes before closing.

2

Everything is baked in house using top quality ingredients.

3

Cookies are priced at $5 each, making them affordable.

27
Cakes by Nerwan image 1

Cake shop shines with custom designs and fresh, stunning desserts like kunafsicles. Lebanese spinach pies offer great value with fresh filling and bold flavor. Pricing is high, matching the chic atmosphere that feels stylish but not cozy.

Lebanese spinach pies offer a delicious taste with a great value deal of five for ten dollars. These pies stand out for their fresh spinach filling and satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cake to be beautiful and delicious."

"Their Dubai chocolate version was designed like an ice bar."

"I tried their Lebanese spinach pies and they tasted great."

Good to know

1

Cakes by Nerwan allows customers to select the design, flavor, filling, and color of the cake.

2

The best way to order cupcakes is through their website.

3

The cake was ready under a 24-hour timeline.

28
Traif image 1
American restaurant

Open kitchen fills the air with frying oil aroma, creating a raw, urban feel. Back patio offers a garden-like oasis with cozy lighting, perfect for romantic nights. Key lime pie with a five-spice twist adds a playful, nostalgic touch to desserts.

Key lime pie stands out with its five-spice twist. Desserts like bacon donuts and this pie offer a sweet, nostalgic, playful vibe.

People are saying

"The tasting menu here is a steal for the price."

"The ribs are fall-off-the-bone tender and perfectly glazed."

"The key lime pie was sharp, sweet, and one of the best I had."

Good to know

1

The tasting menu is $56 per person and includes ten courses.

2

Reservations are recommended as the restaurant gets packed quickly.

3

The restaurant automatically adds a 20% gratuity to the bill.

29
Partybus Bakeshop image 1

Small bakery shines with hand-painted wallpaper and an open kitchen where fresh goods like croissants and baguettes are made daily. Pie classes teach crusts and fillings, featuring pecan and miso caramel custard pies that taste great and look stunning. Atmosphere stays upbeat with bright decor and good music.

Pie making classes teach how to make crusts and fillings. Pies like pecan, ginger, chess, and miso caramel custard taste very good and look beautiful.

People are saying

"I learned so much in the fun baking class at this bakery."

"I learned helpful pie-making techniques in a warm, inviting class."

"I found the best baguette with a crusty outside and chewy inside."

Good to know

1

The baguette baking class lasts for 2 hours and includes hands-on experience.

2

Participants go home with fresh baguettes and their own dough to bake.

3

The class is led by the owner and one of her colleagues.

30
Eli's Cafe & Creperie image 1

Tiny cafe offers a warm, cozy atmosphere with bright yellow decor and cabin vibes. Cheese pie shines with rich flavor alongside crepes and chocolate koulouri. Occasional train noise contrasts with the calm, family-friendly energy where people enjoy quality coffee and treats.

Cheese pie stands out with its rich flavor and satisfying texture. Pies come alongside crepes and chocolate koulouri, all prepared with care and quality ingredients.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be some of the most delicious I ever had."

"I thought the crepes here were perfect and amazing."

"I found the cheese pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted; cash is also welcome.

2

The cafe is open late on Fridays and Saturdays until 11pm.

3

Happy hour specials on drinks are available from 4-6pm on weekdays.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...