Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to New York

Cookies and cream treats

You have a high bar for cookies and cream. It needs to be a perfect ratio of crunchy cookie bits to smooth, high-quality base.

Based on 813 Opinions
+810
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Little Maven image 1
Little Maven image 2
Little Maven image 3
View all
Restaurant

Restaurant offers an elegant, 80s-inspired decor with meticulously maximal design and carefully curated lighting. Atmosphere balances a lively yet not too loud vibe with great music, including DJ sets. Guests find a thoughtful bar program featuring well-crafted cocktails and knowledgeable sommelier recommendations.

Food features carefully crafted cocktails and a not your average bar program. The sommelier offers great food pairing recommendations, especially for the Tuna Cannoli.

Four homemade chocolate chip cookies come with house-made soft-serve vanilla in the cookies and cream dessert. It stands out as an outstanding and frequently highlighted choice.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and wonderful."

"The staff's attentiveness made our Date Spots feel so special."

"I thought the Cookies And Cream was excellent."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant offers a $55 special three-course prix fixe menu.

3

Happy hour deals include discounted drinks and appetizers.

02
Burger Queens image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Small space with hand-painted mural and minimalist seating creates a cozy, bright environment. Music playlist adds a nostalgic, fun vibe that complements the old-school diner feel. Crowd enjoys fast, flavorful smash burgers and extra thin, crispy fries in a clean, simple setting.

Food stands out for its delicious taste and good quality. Presentation scores high with great variety and beats typical fast food options.

Rich in sweetness without being overbearing, the cookies and cream shake offers a delicious and satisfying flavor. The chocolate cookies and cream mix stands out for its smooth, enjoyable taste.

People are saying

"I thought the smash burgers were awesome."

"The burgers here are amazing, juicy, and cooked just right."

"I really enjoyed the Cookies and Cream shake the most."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is conveniently located just 5 minutes from the airport terminals.

2

You can either dine in or take out your food.

3

Seating is limited with a few bar stools and one table available.

03
Sam's Fried Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Small, cozy ice cream shop with an old-fashioned, no-frills look and limited seating. Atmosphere is quiet and casual, with only one group allowed inside at a time, sometimes causing a line. Known for fried ice cream with exotic flavors and vegan options, it offers a unique, fresh dessert experience despite higher prices.

Food impresses with amazing flavors and quick service. Staff answers menu questions and works hard to ensure a great dining experience.

Cookies and cream appears in several forms like Oreo crunch, chocolate drizzle, and sprinkles. It mixes with other flavors such as birthday cake and fruity pebbles, and sometimes comes with toppings like condensed milk or bread crumbs.

People are saying

"I thought the fried ice cream here was the best I ever had."

"You have to try the fried ice cream; the crispy batter is amazing."

"The fried ice cream here is amazing and perfectly crispy."

Good to know

1

The shop is only open on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday.

2

This place opens at 3 PM on operating days.

3

Limited seating means only one group is allowed inside at a time.

04
Cookies and Cream Pastry Shop image 1

Small pastry shop offers a cozy atmosphere with cute outdoor seating and a warm vibe. Pastries are high quality and reasonably priced, with standout items like rich muffins and custom cakes. The space feels inviting for casual visits with friends or family.

Food tastes delicious but service feels abrupt with no greetings or thanks during delivery.

Cookies and cream and carrot cake cookies stand out among several treats. Small local spot offers a friendly vibe and a variety of items beyond just mini cakes.

People are saying

"Their pastries are fresh, delicious, and have great flavor profiles."

"The food here is delicious and tasty."

"I loved the cookies and cream cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations for custom cakes require at least two weeks' notice.

2

Pricing for cakes, cupcakes, and cookies is very reasonable.

3

Customer service can vary; visiting early may improve your experience.

05
Buttercup BakeShop image 1
Cupcake shop

Small cupcake shop with classic, old school design and pink, cute interior creates a warm, inviting atmosphere. Soft jazz music plays while two small tables offer seating for quick treats. Known for outstanding cupcakes and unique flavors like banana cream pie and red velvet cheesecake.

Food here tastes even better than it smells, with consistently excellent and super yummy flavors. The overall experience pairs great food with a welcoming atmosphere and attentive service.

Cookies and cream cupcake stands out for being moist and sweet. It ranks as a favorite flavor among several options tried.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are amazing and delicious."

"I found the food here to be delicious and amazing."

"The Cookies and Cream cupcake is light, soft, and tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers gluten-free options, ensuring a variety for dietary needs.

2

Prices for baked goods are clearly posted outside the shop.

3

There is usually no long wait at this cupcake shop.

06
Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - 35th St image 1

Hamburger restaurant with nostalgic 90โ€™s wall art and a roof terrace bar overlooking a city landmark. Loud music and multiple TVs create a busy, energetic atmosphere that can make conversation difficult. Offers heated outdoor seating and a lively bar area popular for cocktails.

Food here is consistently amazing and delectable with a strong focus on quality. Service complements the food well, creating a solid overall dining experience.

Shakes here feature a Cookies and Cream CrazyShake known for its rich flavor and creamy texture. The Cookies 'n Cream Supreme milkshake stands out as a signature choice, often paired with other popular shakes like strawberry shortcake.

People are saying

"You have to try the milkshakes; they're the biggest and best I've ever had."

"The food here is really tasty and top tier."

"I enjoyed the Cookies and Cream shake; it was delicious and worth the hype."

Good to know

1

Happy hour menu features discounted items, perfect for budget-friendly dining.

2

Customers must seat themselves and order via their phone from the table.

3

Reservations are not accepted; expect a wait during peak hours.

07
Insomnia Cookies image 1
Dessert shop

Warm, welcoming space fills with the aroma of freshly baked cookies late into the night. Soft, freshly served cookies draw a crowd despite higher prices and limited availability near closing. Open until 2am, it caters to those seeking a sweet late-night treat.

Food here features excellent quality and the staff offers helpful guidance when choosing items.

Cookies and cream stands out with a rich flavor and a creamy texture. It pairs well with other varieties like double chocolate chip and vegan chocolate chip.

People are saying

"These cookies are warm, fresh, and absolutely amazing."

"The staff made my daughter and I feel welcome and enhanced our visit."

"I thought the cookies and cream cookie was the best."

Good to know

1

The establishment is open until 2am.

2

The prices at Insomnia Cookies are a little on the higher side.

3

There were barely any cookies left.

08
Skinny Louie image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Small hamburger restaurant offers 1950s diner vibe with retro-future theme and open mirror screen showing burger preparation. Atmosphere stays laid-back but lively, featuring outdoor seating and fun music. Burgers stand out as best smashed burgers with balanced, crispy flavors.

Food stands out for its amazing smashed burgers served in a refined fast food style. Quality consistently beats other spots, with a friendly and efficient service adding to the experience.

Milkshakes stand out with a cookies and cream flavor served in a great portion size cup. The shake pairs well with meals but is generally just okay in taste.

People are saying

"I thought their burgers were the best I've ever had."

"I thought the food, especially the burgers, was amazing."

"I thought the cookies and cream milkshake was really good."

Good to know

1

Skinny Louie does not accept cash payments.

2

Skinny Louie is open late, making it a good option after a Broadway show.

3

Skinny Louie does not have a restroom available for customers.

09
Shake Shack Theater District image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Burger restaurant offers best burgers with craft beer and canned wine options. Space is small and crowded, with limited seating and some outdoor tables. Atmosphere is noisy and lively, especially during busy times.

Food here is consistently amazing and excellent with fast service. The menu offers some of the best fast food options available.

Milkshakes highlight cookies and cream with a rich, malted texture. The Shake Shake Milk Chocolate Cookies and Cream Shake stands out for its smooth blend and strong cookie flavor.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be juicy and perfectly seasoned."

"I found the food here to be delicious and excellent."

"The Cookies and Cream shake is thick and yummy."

Good to know

1

Get your brunch here in the morning if you donโ€™t want to wait in long lines.

2

Shake Shack gets crowded, so go during off-peak times to find a seat.

3

The average cost for two people is $30 to $35.

10
Grounds Donut House image 1

Small donut shop offers a cozy, trendy vibe with fun, modern artwork on the walls. Outdoor seating includes pink tables and chairs, and the atmosphere feels lively and welcoming with top-notch music. Specialty donuts stand out as unique and delicious treats in a charming, upbeat setting.

Food offers flavorful options with a focus on donut varieties. Quality exceeds expectations, adding variety to the Bronx food scene.

Cookies and cream appears as a standout flavor in the donut selection. It pairs well with other unique options like cinnamon toast crunch and fruity pebbles donuts.

People are saying

"These donuts are amazing, super soft, and rich."

"These handmade donuts are some of the best I've ever had."

"I also enjoyed the cookies and cream donut."

Good to know

1

The shop closes at 6 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Expect to pay around $20 for three donuts and a small iced coffee.

3

They offer a variety of specialty donuts including maple bacon and s'mores.

11
BKLYN MACS image 1
Dessert shop

Dessert shop offers largest flavor selection of macarons with unique edible photo printing on treats. Space feels cozy and creative with stylish interior and small seating area. Atmosphere stays friendly and welcoming throughout visits.

Food offers true fruit flavors in macarons with just food coloring. Coffee and other items taste consistently incredible and very good.

Cookies and cream treats include a macaron ice cream sandwich with plain white shells rolled in crushed cookies. The ice cream macaroon offers a unique flavor and aroma that stands out.

People are saying

"I considered these the best macarons I have tasted."

"The food here is really good and incredibly tasty."

"The cookies and cream ice cream macaroon was unbelievable."

Good to know

1

Almost everything is gluten-free, catering to dietary restrictions.

2

The macarons are made in-house with premium ingredients.

3

Expect a constantly rotating selection of unique flavors.

12
Sweets & Things image 1
Dessert shop

Beautifully designed dessert shop with cozy atmosphere and aesthetic decor featuring an iconic wall of grecas. The vibe includes a carefully curated R&B playlist and a backyard space for relaxation. Known for exceptional tres leches cakes and freshly roasted Dominican coffee, it offers a unique, inviting experience.

Guava tres leche stands out as a delicious highlight. Food consistently tastes amazing in a cozy, clean setting.

Cookies and cream tres leches offers a moist, flavorful experience that is not too sweet. The 4Leches cookies and cream cake stands out for its irresistible texture and taste.

People are saying

"You have to try the tres leches cake; it's amazing."

"I found the Cookies and Cream cake to be great and delicious."

"The tres leches food here is so soft, creamy, and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required but recommended during peak hours.

2

The dessert menu features a variety of tres leches options.

3

Coconut desserts are available and highly praised by visitors.

13
Avrilililly's Creamery LLC image 1

Ice cream shop showcases vibrant colors and a poetic Harlem theme with original murals and wall poetry. Comfortable indoor and outdoor seating supports a family- and vegan-friendly atmosphere with good music and WiFi. The space balances a sophisticated yet playful vibe that invites work and socializing.

Yummy food options come with coffee in a warm, inviting atmosphere. The place feels a bit messy but offers a solid food experience.

Cookies and cream comes in both gelato and ice cream forms. Gelato is airy and flavorful, while ice cream tends to be extremely sweet but sometimes lacks noticeable flavor.

People are saying

"The owner's warm greetings make the ice cream experience special."

"I found the food here to be excellent and the atmosphere fantastic."

"I loved the Cookies and Cream gelato; it was so airy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10% discount for students, teachers, and first responders.

2

To get the college student discount, you need to print your ID card.

3

Gelatos from the day before are discounted.

14
Funny Face Bakery image 1

Small shop with cute decor and an aesthetic design creates a fun and friendly atmosphere. The smell inside is divine, enhancing the welcoming vibe. Cookies feature meme and pop culture themes, adding a unique touch.

Food here is consistently safe and delicious, with great taste and reasonable prices.

Cookies and cream cookie stands out with a rich, memorable flavor that sticks with you days later. Minis in this flavor offer a delectable bite without Oreos, despite what the counter says.

People are saying

"I found their chocolate chip cookies to be among the best I've ever had."

"I can't stop thinking about the cookies and cream cookie."

"I thought the food, especially the cookie, was delicious."

Good to know

1

Cookies cost $6-$7 each, with decorated cookies priced higher.

2

The shop only accepts cash and Venmo for payment.

3

Expect a limited selection as many cookies may be sold out.

15
Caffรจ Panna image 1
Ice cream shop

Outdoor setup with limited standing space creates an intimate, warm vibe that highlights top-tier gelato craftsmanship. Lines can be long, but heated areas and self-serve water add comfort. The atmosphere stays soft and inviting, making it a popular spot for casual outings and dates.

Dessert options attract many, making it a popular stop. Extra staff handle orders efficiently, so waits stay short and food arrives quickly.

Cookies and cream panna blends smooth panna with chocolate fudge and Oreo pieces. Traditional flavors come through extremely well, making it enjoyable even for those who usually avoid cookies and cream.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and some of the best I've ever tasted."

"The ice cream flavors here are so creative and unique."

"I thought the Cookies and Cream ice cream was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Caffรจ Panna opens at 1:30 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Expect wait times of 30 to 45 minutes for ice cream after 7 PM.

3

There is no seating available at Caffรจ Panna; it's takeout only.

16
Bear Donut image 1
Donut shop

Small shop offers colorful mochi donuts and Asian-inspired soft serve in a clean, trendy space with limited seating mostly for quick visits. Atmosphere feels cute and upbeat with a warm, homemade vibe. Facade is understated, blending into a small-town style setting.

Donuts stand out with amazing flavor and high production quality despite their 'dirty' food style. The food overall is delicious but the small interior limits dining space for large groups.

Chewy texture and rich flavor define the cookies and cream mochi donut. It tastes like a chewy Oreo and delivers a satisfying blend of flavor and texture.

People are saying

"These donuts are so tasty and chewy, I had no regrets."

"These donuts are fluffy, chewy, and unlike anything else."

"The Cookies and Cream was my favorite, packed with flavor."

Good to know

1

The breakfast waffle donut is only available between 8AM - 2PM.

2

Mochi donuts cost $3.75 and larger donuts cost $5.

3

Bear Donut does not have seating inside.

17
Schmackary's image 1

Small, clean bakery with freshly baked cookie aroma filling the air. Cozy, fun-spirited vibe with limited seating and heated outdoor tables. Offers unique cookie flavors and ice cream treats in a charming, compact space.

Food here is consistently good with some items described as completely delicious. Coffee pairs well with the food, though some other bakeries offer better options near closing time.

Cookies and cream stands out with its rich, creamy texture and crunchy cookie bits. The cookies and cream cookie also offers a yummy twist on the classic flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"I'm obsessed with their cookies, especially The Hummingbird."

"The Cookies and Cream flavor was a standout."

Good to know

1

The ice cream shop has a 2 for 1 cookie sale.

2

New flavors come out regularly, check for updates.

3

Cookies may be given away at a discount right before closing.

18
Creamline image 1
American restaurant

Small shop inside an old factory with tight seating and loud music creates a noisy, energetic atmosphere. Crowds gather here, especially later, adding to the busy vibe. The space feels cramped but lively, with a mix of high stools and tables.

Food here is consistently awesome and enjoyable. Both dishes and flavors satisfy across visits.

Milkshakes feature a rich cookies and cream flavor that stands out. The texture blends smooth creaminess with crunchy cookie bits.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers here were the best I'd ever eaten."

"I thought I'd had the best burgers, but these were exceptional."

"The Cookies and Cream milkshake is rich, thick, and creamy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant hosts pumpkin carving events during the fall season.

2

75% of the menu items are often unavailable.

3

A cheeseburger and a can of Coke costs around $17.

19
Hershey's Chocolate World image 1

Chocolate shop offers an immersive sensory experience with an overwhelming smell of sugar and chocolate. Colorful, fun decor and interactive displays create a lively, crowded atmosphere. Unique features include custom candy bar wrappers and a stuff your own cup-Reese's bar.

Delicious treats come from various food stations, including a MIX&MATCH corner for tasting different types. A wide variety of Hershey's brand products like chocolates, sauces, and cookies are available.

Cookies and cream shake stands out with a rich, creamy texture and balanced sweetness. The Sโ€™mores with cookies & cream bar combines classic flavors with a smooth, chocolatey finish.

People are saying

"I found a really varied selection of Hershey's Chocolate here."

"You have to try their milkshake; it's so nice and worth it."

"You have to try the Cookies and Cream milkshake; it's so good."

Good to know

1

Hershey's central location in Times Square makes it easily accessible.

2

The establishment only accepts plastic payments.

3

There are no restrooms available for anyone, including paying customers.

20
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 1

Small bakery with limited seating and a busy, cramped atmosphere. Customers often stand at a counter or bar area to enjoy cheesecakes, which are widely regarded as high-quality and flavorful. The space feels cozy but not suited for lingering or groups.

Cheesecake here is known for being really delicious and a highlight on food tours. A friendly waitress helps with ordering, and the place has been recommended by a Korean TV food show host.

Cookies and cream cheesecake stands out as a best seller with a delicious flavor profile. It appears consistently among popular choices alongside salted caramel.

People are saying

"I found the cheesecake here to be divine and melt-in-your-mouth delicious."

"The cheesecakes are handmade daily, with strawberry and lemon being refreshing favorites."

"The Cookies and Cream cheesecake is so creamy and delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop is small and has no seating, so you will probably have to take your order to go.

2

Each cheesecake is freshly homemade on-site.

3

The prices are very expensive for non-New Yorkers in relation to the size.

21
Doughnuttery image 1
Donut shop

Mini donuts pop out fresh every minute from a cute machine in a clean, tidy setting inside a beautiful building. The atmosphere feels stressful and uncomfortable due to the busy market environment. Donuts come in unique flavors and small sizes, allowing for variety despite a higher price point.

Food here is fun and innovative with bite size donuts perfect for snacking while trying other dishes. The flavors often prompt people to line up for a taste.

Cookies and cream stands out as a favorite flavor alongside s'mores and apple. It appears consistently among the preferred choices with other flavors like cinnamon sugar and chai.

People are saying

"I loved watching the fresh mini donuts being made right in front of me."

"The mini donuts at this Market have so many delicious flavors."

"The Cookies and Cream is amazing, a definite favorite."

Good to know

1

You must order a minimum of 6 mini-donuts, which can be divided into groups of 3 for flavors.

2

The price for 6 bite-sized doughnuts is $6.52.

3

The shop has several unique flavors to choose from.

22
Spirals image 1
Bakery

Tiny bakery with adorable decor and warm, inviting atmosphere. Offers unique rotating flavors of cinnamon rolls, including sweet and savory options. Friendly staff create a cozy, welcoming vibe despite the small space.

Pesto burrata cinnamon roll stands out as a unique and flavorful dish. Food here consistently delivers elite quality and delicious variety.

Cookies and cream rolls come with a gooey texture and a sweet, rich flavor. Spirals offers these alongside other rolls, making it a notable choice for this flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the cinnamon rolls were the best I'd ever had."

"I thought the food here was elite and delicious."

"The Cookies and Cream flavor is gooey and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line on Saturday mornings, but it clears up by noon.

2

Cinnamon rolls are priced around $10 each, which some find excessive.

3

The bakery offers both sweet and savory rolls, including unique monthly flavors.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...