Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Fish spots in New York

A dedicated fish spot is the only place that truly understands how to handle fresh herring.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Schwartz Appetizing image 1
Schwartz Appetizing image 2
Schwartz Appetizing image 3
View all
Gourmet grocery store

Freshly renovated gourmet grocery store offers an old school atmosphere with a huge variety of options. Known for best-in-town herring made on site and generous portions with perfect seasonings. Clean, visually appealing space makes shopping a pleasure despite high prices matching quality.

Herring made on site comes in generous portions with oil, seasonings, and slivered onions. The flavor matches excellent types found in Amsterdam or Antwerp and pairs well with dips for a classic Shabbas table.

Freshness stands out with every bite of the fish. Simple classics like tuna fish, egg salad, and herrings deliver strong, old school flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the herring here was the best in the world."

"The seafood here is so fresh and tastes the best."

"The fish here is always so fresh."

Good to know

1

The store has been a family business for over 48 years.

2

Shopping here is enjoyable after the recent renovation.

3

The store offers a huge variety of food options, including diet foods.

02
Junior's Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small, clean spot with an island vibe and American diner style seating creates an inviting atmosphere. The place draws a local crowd and stays busy, often with long wait times. Outdoor seating is common due to limited parking, adding to its casual, approachable feel.

Locrian herring stands out with its homestyle flavor and perfect preparation. Herring fried rice offers a delicious twist on the classic dish.

Soups feature rich, flavorful broth with fresh fish. The fish dishes offer comforting, well-prepared flavors that stand out.

People are saying

"The food here is fantastic and delicious."

"The seafood soup here is amazing and comforting."

"I found the fish soup to be amazing and flavorful."

Good to know

1

There is never parking available at the time I go.

2

Expect to wait due to high demand during peak hours.

3

The prices at Junior Seafood are extremely family friendly.

03
Immaculee Bakery image 1

Small bakery with warm, inviting aroma and lively chatter creates a cozy atmosphere. Busy spot known for flaky, buttery Haitian patties with flavorful fillings, especially fish and beef. No dine-in space, making it ideal for quick bites in a culturally rich neighborhood.

Herring patties stand out here, served alongside other options like chicken patties. The patties have a distinct flavor and texture that make them memorable.

Fish patties feature a mild, salty flavor and are seasoned to perfection. Haitian baked goods include cod or fish meat inside pastry, with fish patties standing out compared to other Haitian bakeries.

People are saying

"The fish patties were so delicious and flaky."

"The fish patties from this bakery are seasoned to perfection."

"I loved their herring patties; they were hot and flaky."

Good to know

1

There is no space for dining in; takeout is the only option.

2

The price of the patties is very reasonable.

3

Online information states that the business closes at 7 PM, but it may close earlier.

04
Smør image 1
Restaurant

Cozy spot with minimalist European style offers a modern vibe and varied seating. Pickled herring, especially with curry, delivers tangy, savory notes. Smoked and pickled fish shine, and excellent fish and chips make it a top choice for fish lovers.

Pickled herring shines with tangy and savory notes, especially the version with curry. The herring toast stands out as a flavorful choice for a morning sandwich.

Smoked fish and pickled fish stand out with strong flavors. Fish and chips come out excellent, though some smørrebrød lean heavy on mayo, which can mask the fish.

People are saying

"The brunch food here is delicious and fresh."

"The pickled herring with curry is surprisingly to die for."

"The fish and chips here are so crispy outside and tender inside."

Good to know

1

For brunch, you should reserve in advance because the place is small.

2

Outdoor seating is probably the only option on the weekend if you didn't make a reservation.

3

They close at 5pm and discreetly try to point you out for staying too late.

05
Russ & Daughters Cafe image 1
American restaurant

Classic bagel and lox shine in a warm, retro diner with homey atmosphere and classy servers. Spiced pickled herring offers a savory depth that pairs well with homemade bagels and latkes. Fresh smoked fish adds unique flavors to a historic Jewish deli experience.

Pickled herring stands out with its spiced flavor that surprises with depth. It pairs well on classic boards alongside homemade bagels and potato latkes, offering a savory, well-prepared experience.

Smoked fish stands out with freshness and unique flavors like spiced herring. The selection pairs well with bagels and spreads, offering a variety of hot and cold smoked options.

People are saying

"The bagels here are awesome, especially with the smoked salmon."

"The smoked fish here is silky, perfectly sliced, and not overly salty."

"The pickled herring trio was so tasty, my favorite dish."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is necessary to avoid a wait of over an hour.

2

Expect to wait on busy weekend mornings; arrive early to get on the list.

3

No reservations are accepted, so expect long waits on weekends.

06
Russ & Daughters image 1

Small shop with an old school vibe offers classic bagel and lox combos and outdoor benches. Enjoy flavorful herring marinades like curry and mustard dill alongside creamy whitefish salad. Fresh bagels topped with smoked fish varieties such as sturgeon and sable make for a perfect bite.

Variety of herring marinades includes curry and mustard dill, both flavorful. The whitefish salad is creamy and pairs well with the herring selection.

Smoked fish comes in many varieties like sturgeon, sable, and smoked salmon. Cream cheese pairs with the fish on fresh bagels, creating a classic combination with excellent quality fish.

People are saying

"I thought the salmon bagel was the best I ever had."

"The fish here is so fresh and generously sliced."

"The herring here is excellent, with a clean taste."

Good to know

1

You must take a number when you first enter to be served.

2

There is no dine-in option; it's takeout only.

3

Expect long wait times, often over an hour, especially after 10am.

07
IBN Hamido Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Ordering happens by a pond where fresh seafood is selected and cooked on site, surrounded by walls covered with fish tanks. Loud music and crowded seating create a lively, vibrant atmosphere that feels like a bustling fish market. Outdoor heated seating and an open kitchen add to the busy, energetic vibe.

Salad features perfectly salted herring with a tasty, well-balanced flavor. It pairs well as a side, especially alongside a Greek salad.

Fish here is incredibly fresh and flavorful. The specialty branzino stands out, and you can pick your own fish and squid for the meal. Shrimp, calamari, and scallops also come out amazing.

People are saying

"The seafood here is unbelievably fresh and tastes amazing."

"The fish here is insanely fresh and perfectly cooked."

"I'm addicted to the amazing herring salad here."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait on a Saturday night.

2

The lunch special is available until 4pm on weekdays.

3

You have to order before they give you a table.

08
Björk Cafe & Bistro image 1
Scandinavian restaurant

Scandinavian-inspired space features blond wood decor and a soft color palette creating a calming, elegant atmosphere. The setting stays quiet and inviting, suitable for thoughtful conversations or solo moments. Unique dishes and drinks reflect authentic Scandinavian culinary traditions.

Pickled herring appears in several dishes, including a herring plate and an egg salad with chopped pickled herring called the gentleman's delight. Gravlax and the herring platter offer contrasting flavors that stand out.

Fish dishes include a fish soup that stands out and a fish pie featured on the smorgasbord plate. Fish meatballs are available but less recommended compared to other options.

People are saying

"The pickled herring here is delicate, straightforward, and delicious."

"The dinner spots here serve authentic, delicious Scandinavian cuisine with fresh ingredients."

"I loved the fish pie and the arctic char here."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for lunch due to high demand.

2

Happy Hour offers discounts on drinks and appetizers after work.

3

The lunch bill averages around $80 for two people without dessert.

09
DJONDJON image 1
Haitian restaurant

Authentic Caribbean restaurant with Haitian paintings and artistic decor creates a cozy atmosphere. Loud live Haitian music fills the space, making conversation difficult but energizing the environment. Outdoor seating offers a comfortable and pleasant experience.

Starts with herring patties and fried herring as appetizers. Both dishes offer a solid, flavorful introduction to the meal.

Fish dishes come with flavorful and juicy qualities. Options include a green plantain appetizer with fish, black rice paired with fish, and a Pate Kode filled with a fish mixture similar to Guinean Fataya.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and flavorful."

"The grilled fish here is so flavorful and done to perfection."

"Elijah's care and warmth made the day unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with half-price appetizers.

2

Karaoke starts at 10pm on Wednesdays with a two-drink minimum.

3

The bar has a game night on Wednesday.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...