Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in New York

Italian food with reservations

You refuse to leave your Italian dinner plans to chance. Securing a reservation is the only way to ensure your evening goes exactly as intended.

Based on 899 Opinions
+896
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Osteria Accademia image 1
Osteria Accademia image 2
Osteria Accademia image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Small Italian restaurant with an interior resembling a library lined with bookcases creates a cozy, intimate atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant option when weather permits. Wine selections are excellent and reasonably priced, complementing the delicious, well-prepared food.

Croquettes, burrata, and wine selection stand out on the menu. Dishes like Caesar Salad, Meatballs, Ravioli, and Paccheri offer a nice variety of Italian flavors. The atmosphere suits both intimate dinners and large group events.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pastas, is handmade fresh and delicious."

"It's a super cozy, welcoming neighborhood spot."

"They helped me set up a Prix Fixe menu and took excellent care of our group."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 4:30-6pm with $9 glasses of Prosecco.

2

The restaurant offers several antipasti specials during happy hour.

3

Reservations are highly recommended due to limited seating.

02
Empire Steak House Times Square image 1

Steakhouse offers cozy, quiet atmosphere with a well-laid-out interior that avoids feeling crowded. Table-side dessert flambรฉ and complimentary port wines add unique touches to the dining experience. The place draws those seeking exceptional steak and wine selections in a warm, welcoming setting.

Lobster ravioli stands out with its tender and tasty texture. Pasta dishes like the ragu and others have a tender bite and rich flavor, while the eggplant parmigiana offers an amazing classic taste.

People are saying

"I've never had a steak cooked so perfectly, it just melted in my mouth."

"The desserts here are impressive, a perfect sweet ending."

"The steak and ravioli here are delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a pre-theater menu only from 4:00 - 7:00 pm.

2

You can have a pre-theatre dinner between 4-7 PM for only DKK 350.

3

The happy hour offers a perfectly crafted burger and a glass of wine.

03
Matsunori Handroll Bar image 1
Sushi restaurant

Open bar seating showcases chefs preparing fresh handrolls with perfect fish to rice ratio. The space feels modern and chic with an intimate, lively atmosphere suited for casual meals or date nights.

People are saying

"The salmon cups are a must-try appetizer."

"The Wagyu with uni was decadent and rich."

"It's a great spot for a romantic date night with amazing sushi."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has only one bathroom, which can lead to long wait times.

2

Expect high prices for the handrolls compared to similar places.

3

The air conditioning is often reported as not functioning properly.

04
Osteria Nonnino image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers tableside pasta preparation and live culinary shows in a cozy, beautifully decorated space with outdoor seating. Atmosphere is lively but can be noisy due to cramped seating and sound reverberation. Guests enjoy a warm, inviting vibe with a mix of contemporary and rustic design elements.

Spicy rigatoni and gnocchi stand out among the pastas served. The tiramisu is noted for its exceptional quality. All dishes come with a consistently high level of flavor and care.

People are saying

"The tableside Cacio e Pepe pasta is phenomenal."

"Our server Luca was outstanding and made our dinner spot fantastic."

"You have to try the desserts; the cannolis and cheesecake are delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times for walk-ins, especially during peak hours.

3

Happy hour runs until 7pm with discounts on drinks and snacks.

05
Cafe Luce - Italian Restaurant & Wine Bar image 1

Cozy Italian trattoria with intimate seating and warm lighting creates a perfect setting for dates and neighborhood gatherings. Live jazz and vintage music add a lively yet relaxed atmosphere. Extensive wine selection complements standout pasta dishes and classic desserts.

Vodka pasta stands out with rich flavors. The Pollo Parmigiana pairs well, offering a hearty Italian classic. Limoncello provides a bright, citrusy finish.

People are saying

"I found the homemade pasta to be fresh and delicious."

"It's a lovely, cozy spot with a nice atmosphere."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour offers $10 wine from 4pm to 7pm on weekdays.

2

Live music starts after 6pm on select days.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for larger groups.

06
La Lanterna di Vittorio image 1
Italian restaurant

Historic brownstone hosts a cozy Italian restaurant with low lighting and an intimate atmosphere. A garden oasis and covered outdoor patio add unique charm. The space feels both spacious and intimate with high ceilings and quiet corners.

Lasagna stands out with rich layers and deep flavors, including a notable vegetarian lasagna flight. The tiramisu offers a classic, creamy finish to the meal.

People are saying

"The lasagna flight was playful and comforting, offering a range of flavors."

"It's a cozy and romantic spot with a magical atmosphere."

"The Italian food, especially the lasagna flight, was playful and fun."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for the garden room seating.

2

The restaurant features live jazz on select nights.

3

Valentineโ€™s Day fixed menu includes a glass of champagne and dessert.

07
Pasta Lovers image 1
Italian restaurant

Large, tastefully decorated Italian restaurant offers both indoor and outdoor seating with an outdoor patio and live music on weekends. Atmosphere balances romantic and family-friendly vibes, creating a pleasant space for conversation. Spacious layout keeps tables uncrowded, enhancing comfort and ambience.

Pasta tossed in a giant cheese wheel happens right at the table, creating a unique dining moment. The lobster ravioli and rigatoni Bolognese stand out as flavorful dishes, with sauces that are fresh and not too spicy.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, flavorful, and served in plentiful portions."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is amazing and flavorful."

"The fried calamari was light and not greasy."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to ensure a table during peak hours.

2

The total cost for two people is around $90 without appetizers or drinks.

3

Happy hour is available daily, offering discounted drinks.

08
Duomo51 image 1
Italian restaurant

Rooftop Italian restaurant offers stunning city views including St. Patrickโ€™s Cathedral and Radio City Music Hall. Ambiance stays quiet and elegant, suitable for special occasions with both indoor and outdoor seating. Cocktails and food receive high praise, featuring standout dishes like truffle ravioli and branzino.

Truffle ravioli stands out as a signature dish. The cacio e Pepe and various pasta dishes deliver authentic Italian flavors. The Duomo salad complements the meal well.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and flavorful."

"The view here is absolutely breathtaking."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, tasted homemade and was cooked perfectly."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted until 9:30 PM.

2

Lunch specials are available on weekdays until 2 PM for $40.

3

Expect a $80 dinner cost per person for a five-star experience.

09
Il Mulino - Downtown (West 3rd) image 1

Small, cramped space with dim lighting and old-fashioned decor creates an intimate yet lively atmosphere. The setting reflects traditional Italian dining with a warm, family vibe despite occasional stuffiness and candle scent. Tables are tightly packed, emphasizing a cozy but bustling environment.

Pasta stands out with its rich flavor and texture. Chicken parmesan comes smashed thin, coated in mozzarella and served with marinara. Bread resembles bruschetta, combining soft and hard textures with salty and spicy notes.

People are saying

"The Italian food here feels like old-school royalty."

"The food here was incredible, truly the best I've had."

"I loved the classic old school vibe and service here."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $300 for a meal for three people.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially for special occasions.

3

They often sing happy birthday and anniversary songs during dinner.

10
Lucciola image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, intimate space filled with over 5,000 wine bottles creates a warm, authentic Italian vibe. Dim lighting and white tablecloths set a cozy, elegant atmosphere where guests enjoy exceptional wine pairings and classic Italian dishes. The setting feels like old New York glamour mixed with genuine Italian charm.

Carbonara special stands out as a signature dish, served consistently across multiple visits. The pasta quality surpasses that found in Chicago, highlighting authentic Italian flavors.

People are saying

"The tasting menu was perfectly balanced and absolutely delicious."

"The dinner spots here are amazing thanks to the attentive and knowledgeable servers."

"The Italian food here is spectacular and amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a 'no menu' tasting menu that is the chef's choice.

2

The tasting menu includes wine pairings selected by the server Eliot.

3

The nine course meal is estimated to be a 3 to 3.5 hour experience.

11
Park Side Restaurant image 1
Italian restaurant

Spacious Italian restaurant with garden views and private rooms upstairs offers a warm atmosphere with spaced-out tables for comfort. Complimentary valet parking adds convenience. The setting suits both large parties and intimate gatherings.

Clam sauce pasta and red sauce shrimp and clams spaghetti stand out with rich flavors. Gluten-free pasta options exist alongside classic dishes like grilled chicken parmesan and a variety of excellent pasta plates.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is masterfully prepared and delicious."

"It's an old school Italian restaurant with an incredible atmosphere."

"You have to try the house wine; they produce it themselves."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is highly recommended to enjoy all the dishes.

2

Valet parking is complimentary, which is helpful because street parking is hard to find.

3

Reservations are strongly suggested, especially for weekends and holidays.

12
Avra Madison image 1
Greek restaurant

Contemporary Greek restaurant offers spacious, sophisticated decor with a vibey, energetic atmosphere. The crowd is lively and upscale, filling the space especially at lunch. Private rooms and a seafood stand add to the distinctive dining experience.

Lobster pasta stands out with rich, flavorful sauce and no need for lobster picking skills. Other dishes include rigatoni in tomato sauce with shrimp and calamari with basil pesto, all delivering delicious Italian flavors.

People are saying

"The seafood here is impeccable, truly upholding the standard of dining."

"The Greek food here is perfectly cooked with top-notch, attentive service."

"The desserts, especially the baklava, were the best I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during busy lunch and dinner hours.

2

The lunch special prix fixe is $38 for a starter, entrรฉe, and dessert.

3

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

13
The Smith image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers a crowded and lively atmosphere with comfortable booths and benches amid close table arrangements. Outdoor seating expands options, while live bands contribute to the energetic vibe. Noise levels can be high, creating a bustling environment.

Vodka pasta stands out with a rich sauce and pairs well with shrimp. Gnocchi and baked eggs alla vodka offer hearty, Italian-style dishes with authentic flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is seasoned and cooked perfectly."

"The brunch food here is so flavorful and delicious."

"The Italian food here is so delicious, I wanted to lick my plate."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long waits.

2

The restaurant offers half-price happy hour items from 3 p.m. to 6 p.m.

3

Brunch is served at 11 a.m. on Saturdays with bottomless options available.

14
Emily image 1
Restaurant

Cozy restaurant with a heated terrace and semi-private downstairs dining featuring a wooden ship vibe. Atmosphere is lively inside yet tucked away on a quiet street, with close tables that create an intimate setting. Outdoor seating offers people watching and a relaxed spot for cocktails.

Marinara sauce stands out with rich flavor. The Vodka and Burrata Detroit style pizza offers a unique twist. Mozzarella sticks come with an incredible sauce that complements them well.

People are saying

"I thought the burger was phenomenal and juicy."

"I tried the pizza, and it was incredibly flavorful."

"The Italian food, especially the pizza, is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations need to be made a day before visiting the restaurant.

2

The kitchen closes at 9:15 PM, be careful.

3

The establishment is always busy, so it's best to get a reservation online.

15
Izakaya MEW image 1
Izakaya restaurant

Basement setting with a small, cramped entrance and closely packed tables creates an intimate but noisy environment. Loud modern hip hop and R&B music energizes the space, making conversation difficult. Crowds gather early, drawn by frozen beer, authentic Japanese food, and a vibrant bar scene.

Tiramisu stands out as a highlight, noted for its exceptional quality. Pasta dishes include shrimp but come with only three pieces, offering a simple seafood touch.

People are saying

"You have to try the kimchi cream udon; it's so creamy."

"It's a lively izakaya vibe with a cozy, intimate feel."

"The Salmon Don is a must-get, packed with savory depth."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended during busy dinner times to avoid long waits.

2

Expect a wait of over an hour during peak hours on weekends.

3

The restaurant charges $20 per person if you can't make your reservation.

16
Theodora image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Open kitchen with wood-fired oven creates a warm, inviting atmosphere filled with rich aromas. Space combines high-design and meticulous detail for a classy, relaxing vibe. Guests often enjoy watching cooking while savoring killer cocktails and fresh, bright flavors.

People are saying

"The fish here is fresh, flavorful, and confidently executed."

"The lemon cream dessert was insane and the best thing."

"The sourdough with whipped ricotta and brown butter is addictive."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required well in advance due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times; arrive early to secure a spot.

3

The location is easily accessible, just steps from the Lafayette Ave subway.

17
Aqua Boil image 1
Seafood restaurant

Interior design mimics a nautical boathouse with dimmed lighting creating a cozy atmosphere. Seafood is served in bags with disposable cutlery and gloves, making dining informal and interactive. Music plays at a lively volume, encouraging a vibrant energy throughout.

Seafood combos like Dungeness crab and crawfish come with sides such as garlic pasta. The menu also features a snow crab legs boil paired with garlic cheese pasta.

People are saying

"I experienced the best seafood boil in the city."

"I loved the large and juicy lobster roll on a perfect bun."

"The seafood boil here is heavenly, especially with the Cajun sauce."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially between 6-8 PM.

2

Happy hour drinks are $6 all day from Monday to Thursday.

3

From Friday to Sunday, happy hour drinks are $6 before 7 PM.

18
Arturo's Coal Oven Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Coal-fired ovens cook pizza in a space with old-school Italian charm and red dim lighting. Live piano music and singing create a lively atmosphere that feels like a cozy New York joint. Separate areas serve families and parties, making it a versatile gathering spot.

Cannoli stand out as a highlight, paired with rich chocolate mousse. The menu features coal oven pizza and a variety of pastas like bolognese and penne with vodka sauce, all noted for strong flavors and generous portions.

People are saying

"The coal-oven pizza is beautifully crisp with a perfectly balanced sauce."

"The live music here makes you feel right at home."

"The Italian food here makes you feel taken care of."

Good to know

1

You need to be available in 20-30 mins after leaving your name.

2

For parties of more than 7 people, there is a mandated pre-set menu price of $60 per person for dinner.

3

You should call or make a reservation to sit in the front of the restaurant.

19
Aunts et Uncles image 1
Vegan restaurant

Interior blends pastels, plants, and wood textures with art deco decor and vintage books, creating a Garden of Eden feel. Music plays throughout, enhancing a cozy, loungy atmosphere with a vinyl and retail area. Diverse art and sunlit spaces attract a vibrant, design-conscious crowd.

Heirloom pasta shines with parmesan chicken that stands out even for those who avoid vegan cheese. Lasagna and garlic bread come together for a solid Italian meal, while vegan pasta and saltfish bake add unique flavors.

People are saying

"I had the most delicious vegan lasagna I've ever tasted."

"The American Food here is delicious, especially the unique mac and cheese."

"The Italian food, especially the lasagna, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended as seating is limited.

2

Be ready to wait for your food as it is prepared when you order.

3

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but monitor your charges.

20
Tabernacle Steakhouse image 1
Kosher restaurant

Kosher steakhouse with elegant decor and cozy wine barrel booths creates a classy, soothing atmosphere. Energetic DJ music and table-side steak carving add lively, engaging touches. Staff offer personalized service including VIP rooms and custom cocktails.

Veal gnocchi and mushroom risotto stand out with rich flavors. The menu also features a flat iron Wagyu steak and Korean short ribs, blending Italian with other influences.

People are saying

"I found the food to be delicious and cooked to perfection."

"The staff made our anniversary dinner so special with thoughtful touches."

"The Italian food here is great, thanks to the attentive and friendly staff."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special occasions like birthdays and Mother's Day.

2

The restaurant offers complimentary flowers and cards for mothers on Mother's Day.

3

Expect high costs; a meal for three can exceed $600.

21
Crown Shy image 1
American restaurant

Open kitchen reveals chefs at work, adding a dynamic visual element to the sleek, art deco dining room. Spacious layout and carefully arranged acoustics keep noise manageable despite lively energy. Hip-hop music with explicit lyrics plays, creating a bold, modern vibe uncommon in similar settings.

Ricotta gnocchi stands out with a rich, soft texture. The bread service features a brioche-style loaf filled with pesto and a pistachio pesto pull-apart bread that is warm and flaky. Sungold pasta offers a bright, acidic flavor.

People are saying

"The desserts here are beautifully detailed and perfectly balanced."

"The cocktails here are creative and beautifully balanced."

"The Italian food here is flavorful and well-executed."

Good to know

1

Reservations are especially required on Fridays to Sundays.

2

The restaurant offers a special pre fixe Mother's Day brunch.

3

Happy hour features a great selection of food and drinks.

22
Jack's Wife Freda image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean restaurant with small, crowded interior and close table spacing creates a lively yet noisy atmosphere that challenges conversation. Outdoor seating with heating and coverage offers a more relaxed vibe amid bustling nights. A large communal table stands out as a distinctive feature.

Chicken meatballs come with spaghetti squash soaking up the tomato sauce, creating a flavorful mix. The dish blends textures well and stands out among pasta options.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and creative."

"The breakfast service here feels like being taken care of by friends."

"The Italian food, especially the spaghetti with chicken meatballs, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed as the restaurant was full during lunch.

2

Make reservations ahead of time to avoid a wait.

3

The brunch time on Saturday is very busy.

23
The Parlour Room image 1

Interior channels a 1920s speakeasy vibe with sexy lighting and gorgeous decor that contrasts an unassuming exterior. Music ranges from live jazz bands to curated background tunes, creating a classy yet relaxed atmosphere. Comfortable booths and a spacious patio support both intimate dates and group gatherings.

Clams pasta and melon burrata salad stand out for their rich flavors. Adding scallops to the risotto creates a creamy, savory dish. Crab dip, oysters, pasta, and Caesar salad also feature on the menu.

People are saying

"This place makes your dinner celebration feel so special and personalized."

"The bartenders here are so knowledgeable about whiskey."

"The Italian food, especially the bolognese and meatballs, is amazing."

Good to know

1

The Saturday JAZZ brunch is from 12-3 PM.

2

Happy hour menu features discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Reservations for events should be made well in advance.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...