Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Brooklyn Heights

Italian desserts

Made for those who believe a proper Italian meal is incomplete without a traditional dessert to finish the experience.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Caffe Buon Gusto image 1
Caffe Buon Gusto image 2
Caffe Buon Gusto image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers pleasant interior with a cute bar area and outdoor seating equipped with heat lamps. Atmosphere feels great and inviting, creating a comfortable vibe. Pasta dishes stand out with homemade pasta and rich flavors.

Salted caramel gelato stands out as a dessert option. Coffees and desserts pair well together here.

Rich, homemade pasta stands out in dishes like gnocchi vodka sauce and limoncello burrata ravioli. Some pastas, like the cacio e Pepe, come with a heavy amount of butter that can be overwhelming.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is delicious and high quality."

"The desserts here are heavenly and tasty."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers complimentary chocolate covered strawberries on Valentine's Day.

2

Reservations are recommended for special occasions like Valentine's Day.

3

The ice cream shop has a variety of flavors, but prices are high.

02
Dellarocco's Brick Oven Pizza image 1

Giant wood-burning pizza oven produces authentic Neapolitan pizzas with a smoky, crisp finish. Atmosphere is loud and crowded with a classy vibe and outdoor seating that enhances the experience. Guests enjoy gluten-free and vegan options alongside a selection of wines and spritzes.

Panna Cotta stands out as a very fresh and favorite dessert. Nutella Pizza and Tartufa gelato offer unique sweet options, while tiramisu delivers a classic, satisfying finish.

Cannoli look like works of art. Eggplant parmigiana and vegetable pizzas stand out, with an Arrabbiata pizza featuring an awesome crust and top-notch sauce.

People are saying

"The pizza here is delicious and wood-fired."

"This Italian food has the best thin-crust pizza with a perfect char."

"I considered the pizza to be the best I have ever eaten."

Good to know

1

No reservation is needed at this place.

2

The gluten-free pizza is not valid for celiacs.

3

It is illegal in NYC to add 20% automatic gratuity for parties of less than 6.

03
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 1
Pizza restaurant

Big space with comfortable seating and a mix of counter and table service creates a casual, lively vibe. Atmosphere is warm and friendly but can be very loud and sweltering without strong air conditioning. Popular for thick crust Sicilian pizza and a bustling, nostalgic feel.

Spumoni ice cream stands out with its marzipan flavor and crunch unlike typical versions. Tiramisu also features as a delicious dessert option.

Hearty rigatoni Bolognese and classic spaghetti with meatballs showcase generous portions and perfectly cooked De Cecco pasta. Sicilian pizza, baked clams, and malfade with sausage ragu add variety, while desserts like spumoni ice cream and tiramisu stand out.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, truly the best I've ever tasted."

"The pizza and pasta here are among the best I've ever had."

"The spumoni dessert was phenomenal and delicious."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant charges $3.12 for a small bottle of water.

3

Only one vegetarian option is available on the menu.

04
Henry's End image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant offers a cozy atmosphere with intimate vibe suited for dates or small groups. Seating is tightly packed indoors, while outdoor seating provides a classy outdoor feeling. Signature cocktails and a unique personality add to the relaxed environment.

Mrs. Mud Pie stands out as a recommended dessert. The vanilla and chocolate mousse offers an outstanding finish to the meal. Personalized desserts add a special touch to the experience.

Terrific focaccia comes with great olive oil. Lobster penne and NY Strip with apple chutney stand out as signature dishes. Shrimp with sausage and rabbit tagliatelle add variety to the Italian menu.

People are saying

"The steak au Poivre for dinner was fantastic, rivaling the best."

"The Italian food here was meticulously prepared and delicious."

"The Persian lime pie dessert is perfectly balanced."

Good to know

1

Make sure you book a reservation at least 3-4 days in advance.

2

Single patrons are not allowed; reservations must be for two or more.

3

A service charge is automatically added to your bill.

05
River Deli image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant with vintage decor and a dark, cozy atmosphere creates a romantic and lively vibe. Outdoor seating includes a dog-friendly patio, while indoor space is often loud, making conversation challenging. Cash-only policy applies, with an ATM inside.

Desserts come served in mugs, adding a unique touch. Options are sweet and enjoyable, offering a nice variety.

Authentic carbonara uses raw egg, and the lasagna stands out as flavorful and filling. Pasta dishes like pepperoni oil spaghetti and ravioli are solid, with tiramisu rounding out the Italian offerings.

People are saying

"The homemade pasta here is so fresh and perfectly al dente."

"The homemade pasta here is so fresh and perfectly cooked."

"I loved the awesome dessert options here."

Good to know

1

This restaurant is cash only; an ATM is available on-site.

2

Expect smaller portions; consider ordering 1.5 plates per person.

3

Weekdays are better for dinner to avoid long wait times.

06
Noodle Pudding image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a cozy, unpretentious atmosphere with a lively yet relaxed vibe. The space feels warm and homey, reminiscent of a small European village, and features an excellent bar with unique cocktails. It operates as a cash-only, no-reservations spot that stays busy but maintains a good energy.

Tiramisu and chocolate espresso cake stand out as exceptional desserts here. The sweets are so good they make walking extra miles worth it.

Pasta cooked al dente stands out, with dishes like duck mushroom ragu and cacio e Pepe featuring asparagus and egg yolk. Desserts include tiramisu and panna cotta, alongside savory options like carpaccio and burrata with tomatoes.

People are saying

"I thought this cozy spot served some of the most authentic and comforting Italian food I had ever had."

"The Dinner Spots here had the freshest fish and seafood."

"You have to try the desserts; the tiramisu and chocolate espresso cake are unforgettable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash, so visit the ATM before arriving.

2

Customers must pay in cash, and there is no ATM available on-site.

3

There are no reservations, and the restaurant is cash only.

07
Ingas Bar image 1
Restaurant

Cozy gastropub set in a brownstone with big windows and natural light creates a charming, nostalgic vibe. Loud trance and synth music often raise noise levels, making conversation difficult despite recent soundproofing improvements. Known for craft cocktails and standout dishes like cheeseburgers and chocolate mousse, it draws a lively crowd seeking a trendy atmosphere.

Poached pear dessert stands out with its rich flavor. Other sweets include a marble cake with chocolate mousse and cherries and an olive oil cake.

Focaccia stands out with variations like ricotta topped with pickled fruit and cheese. Burrata pairs well with cold focaccia, and the mortadella sandwich offers a solid Italian option.

People are saying

"The octopus dish was possibly the best I've ever tried."

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is delicious."

"The desserts here are delicious with complex flavors."

Good to know

1

Inga’s takes brunch reservations, which is a game changer.

2

Expect to wait an hour for a table at 7pm on a Tuesday.

3

The menu is somewhat limited with few vegetarian options.

08
Felice Montague image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers spacious indoor dining and heated outdoor pods under a canopy with jazz music playing softly. Atmosphere blends relaxed hospitality with a cozy vibe, suitable for dates or family meals. Circular bar encourages socializing, and authentic Italian theme shines through in decor and menu.

Gelato and sorbet stand out as the most unbelievable desserts here. Cheesecake and tiramisu sometimes come as complimentary treats for regulars, while the lemon tart costs $15.

Pasta dishes come with balanced flavors and are cooked al dente. Options include gluten-free and dairy-free preparations with attentive service customizing dishes.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is phenomenal, with pasta dishes to die for."

"The dinner spots here have amazing, fresh food and a great atmosphere."

"I hope they add the shareable gelato dessert permanently."

Good to know

1

Make reservations as this is a popular neighborhood joint.

2

Drinks are $18 per glass.

3

The 2 courses fixed price for $34 is a bargain.

09
Juliana’s image 1
Pizza restaurant

Open kitchen with a coal-fired oven creates an authentic pizza experience in a small, cozy space. The atmosphere is dark and jazzy, often loud and cramped but lively. Outdoor heaters and riverside seating offer comfort while waiting or dining outside.

Cheesecake stands out as a recommended dessert. Pizzas and desserts both come with delicious flavors.

Fresh mozzarella stands out with its amazing quality and authentic flavor in the sauce. Classic pizzas like prosciutto and Margherita feature very good melted cheese and balanced toppings.

People are saying

"I thought the Margherita Pizza was the best I ever had."

"The Italian food here has a surprisingly delicious, thin crust pizza."

"I found the pizza and desserts to be perfect."

Good to know

1

Reservations are advisable to avoid long wait times, especially on weekends.

2

Expect longer wait times on weekends; arrive 15 minutes before opening.

3

Takeout has a quick 15-minute wait, making it a convenient option.

10
Grimaldi's Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Three-story pizzeria with brick ovens and exposed brick walls creates a spacious, historic setting. Atmosphere feels warm and friendly with Frank Sinatra music adding to the classic vibe. Outdoor picnic tables offer casual seating near a famous bridge location.

Dessert options include New York Style cheesecake and Oreo Cookie cheesecake. The menu offers a tempting variety alongside pizza and sides.

Pizza features arugula and prosciutto along with perfect sauce, pepperonis, Italian sausage, and meatballs. Indoor space smells amazing and feels like a small-town Italian trattoria.

People are saying

"I thought the thin crust pizza was amazing."

"This Italian food is classic coal-fired pizza, a unique experience."

"You have to try their decadent New York style cheesecake for dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times.

2

Expect a 20-30 minute wait during peak hours.

3

You can only order whole pies, not slices.

11
Barbuto Brooklyn image 1

Spacious restaurant with lush garden vibes and spectacular city skyline views including the Brooklyn Bridge. Bright, airy atmosphere feels like a greenhouse with soft sunlight and many live plants. The vibe is warm and inviting, blending modern design with cozy, chill energy suitable for dates or lively gatherings.

Desserts include a pear crostata and pistachio cake that both stand out. Every dessert tried pairs well with the focaccia.

Seafood dishes like lobster pasta and seafood pizza stand out with rich flavors. The vegetarian bolognese offers a light, summery twist on a classic pasta. Other highlights include fennel salad, gnocchi, and rigatoni.

People are saying

"The roast chicken and meatballs were highlights of our dinner spots."

"The Italian food, especially the ragu and meatballs, was divine."

"The budino made her smile, and we're getting another next time."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

The restaurant offers a happy hour from 4-6pm with discounted drinks.

3

Expect a wait of 30-45 minutes during peak dining hours.

12
Bevacco image 1
Italian restaurant

Blonde concrete and exposed brick walls create a modern, intimate setting with low, beautiful lighting that fosters a quiet, romantic atmosphere. The space feels cozy and warm, ideal for conversation and relaxed dining.

Desserts offer a delicious and satisfying end to meals. Options are consistently good and enjoyable.

Pasta dishes like lasagna and spaghetti limoncelo stand out with authentic flavors. The Cacio e Pepe offers al dente spaghetti tossed with black pepper, Parmesan, and pecorino for a comforting taste.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the gnocchi, is perfectly pillowy and comforting."

"I thought the pizza here was spectacular and better than I expected."

"The desserts here were delicious and a nice ending."

Good to know

1

A forced 20% tip is added to all bills.

2

The restaurant is a short walk from the Brooklyn Bridge.

3

Expect high prices for food and drinks.

13
The River Café image 1
New American restaurant

Waterfront setting offers breathtaking Manhattan views and a romantic atmosphere with fairy lights and live piano music. Dress code enforces formal attire, creating an elegant vibe suited for special occasions. Space between tables is tight, emphasizing intimacy amid the scenic backdrop.

Brooklyn Bridge dessert stands out as a very good option here. It pairs well with the overall meal and sometimes comes with on-the-house items.

Gnocchi stands out with a soft, pillowy texture that impresses every time. The mushroom pasta offers a rich, earthy flavor that many find unforgettable.

People are saying

"The view of the Brooklyn Bridge and Manhattan is stunning."

"The service here is warm, attentive, and thoughtful."

"The Italian food here is delicious, and the service is impeccable."

Good to know

1

You need to book in advance to dine at The River Café.

2

The restaurant requires customers to wear a jacket to enter.

3

The menu is a fixed price menu at $180 per person, which includes an appetizer, entree, dessert, and some chef samples.

Discover more

Brooklyn Heights, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...