Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Central Harlem

Pie spots

You are looking for a slice that holds its own. These spots treat pie as a serious craft.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
7th Heaven Pizza image 1
7th Heaven Pizza image 2
7th Heaven Pizza image 3
View all

Enjoy classic NY-style pizza with a soft, crunchy crust and flavorful tomato sauce. The margarita pie shines with fresh, authentic taste. Expect a neighborhood vibe and reasonable prices in a clean, welcoming spot with limited parking.

People are saying

"The pizza tastes fresh and delicious every time."

"The prices are fair and delivery is fast."

Good to know

1

The pizzeria is brand new and offers authentic pizza.

2

Pizza prices are very reasonable and affordable.

3

Expect fast delivery service for your orders.

02
Archer & Goat image 1
Archer & Goat image 2
Archer & Goat image 3
View all

American restaurant buzzes with intimate vibe and loud '90s tunes. Outdoor patios offer ample space for a laid-back crowd. Key lime pie shines with bright citrus flavor, paired well with warm date cake's rich sweetness.

Key lime pie stands out with its bright citrus flavor and smooth texture. Warm date cake offers a rich, comforting sweetness that complements the pie well.

People are saying

"The place has a great vibe and unique menu."

"The food and drinks were creative and delicious."

"I thought the key lime pie was my favorite dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to secure a table.

2

There is a one-hour maximum time for service.

3

Unlimited mimosas are available during brunch hours.

03
Sottocasa Pizzeria Harlem image 1
Sottocasa Pizzeria Harlem image 2
Sottocasa Pizzeria Harlem image 3
View all

Cozy basement with Neapolitan-style pizza oven offers warm, family-friendly vibes. Italian pies come whole, made with quality ingredients and staff know regular orders well. Outdoor seating and craft Italian beers create a relaxed, authentic spot for all.

People are saying

"The pizza and desserts here taste just like Italy."

"I love the cozy vibe that makes it easy to relax."

"This place serves the best pizza in town."

Good to know

1

Sottocasa is not suitable for celiacs due to cross-contamination risks.

2

Customers should be aware of the automatic tip charge to avoid an unpleasant surprise on their bill.

3

There is no private parking available.

04
Red Rooster Harlem image 1
Red Rooster Harlem image 2
Red Rooster Harlem image 3
View all

Live jazz fills the air in a space rich with colorful African American decor. The apple pie is perfectly baked and a must-try. A covered terrace offers a lively spot to enjoy music and dessert.

Apple pie stands out as perfectly baked and exceptionally tasty. The Lilโ€™ Apple Pie and Banana Pudding also deliver strong, memorable flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the apple pie was perfectly baked and delicious."

"The apple pie was the best part of my meal."

"The apple pie and other dishes were spot on."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation well in advance, especially for Sunday brunch.

2

Gospel brunch is held every Sunday and features live music.

3

Happy hour runs from noon to 10 p.m. with discounted appetizers and cocktails.

05
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 1
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 2
Lee Lee's Baked Goods image 3
View all

Old-fashioned bakery shines with legendary rugelach and a cozy atmosphere. Sweet potato pie sells out fast, while apple pie is a top favorite. Small space offers outdoor tables for a quick, charming visit.

Sweet potato pie sells out fast and needs early ordering. Apple pie stands out as a favorite. Pastry and fruit pies here are consistently top-notch.

People are saying

"The pies smell amazing and taste great."

"Sweet potato pie is a favorite but often sells out."

"I loved Lee Lee's chocolate rugelach; they were the best I've ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The price of rugelach is $3 for 2 bites.

2

The bakery has minimal seating available.

3

You cannot just buy a coffee and sit outside; a purchase is necessary to sit.

06
Rosa Pizza image 1
Rosa Pizza image 2
Rosa Pizza image 3
View all

Cozy space with two-person booths and a lively vibe suits intimate dining. Grandma Pie offers a filling square slice that's fairly priced and flavorful. Wine selection complements the New York-style pizza perfectly, making it a solid choice for casual nights.

People are saying

"The pizza here tastes fresh and delicious every time."

"The Grandma Pie is my family's favorite."

"I love the chicken Caesar and plain pies."

Good to know

1

The regular cheese slice costs $3, and toppings add $3.50.

2

Gluten-free pizza is cooked on its own foil tray to avoid contamination.

3

The restaurant opens at 11am but may not be ready until 11:45am.

07
Amy Ruth's image 1
Amy Ruth's image 2
Amy Ruth's image 3
View all

Soul food spot shines with family atmosphere and live R&B music that stays low and smooth. Sweet potato pie steals the show with rich flavor. Cozy seating fits groups well, making it perfect for celebrations and lively gatherings.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its rich flavor and incredible taste. Other desserts include peach cobbler, pineapple coconut cake, and double chocolate cake.

People are saying

"The food is flavorful and portions are generous."

"The mac and cheese is cheesy but sometimes dry or salty."

"The sweet potato pie tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times on Sundays due to gospel mass attendance.

2

Wednesday is Grape Kool Aid day, a special event at the restaurant.

3

Get there early if you want to dine in, especially on weekends.

08
Cucina Italian tavern image 1
Cucina Italian tavern image 2
Cucina Italian tavern image 3
View all

Italian tavern offers Sicilian pies with rich flavors and a satisfying crust. Warm, inviting vibe comes from an authentic brick fireplace and tasteful decor. A lively yet cozy spot with a Hip Hop soundtrack and a relaxed bar and patio.

People are saying

"I always enjoy the food and drinks here."

"I can't wait to come back again soon."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour is available with discounted drinks and appetizers.

2

They have a bottomless brunch option for a fixed price.

3

Martini Monday features special pricing on martinis all night.

09
Sylvia's Restaurant image 1
Sylvia's Restaurant image 2
Sylvia's Restaurant image 3
View all

Soul food shines with sweet potato pie and peach cobbler desserts. Classic Harlem vibe pulses with live gospel and jazz music. Walls lined with photos add a museum-like feel that blends history and comfort.

Sweet potato pie stands out with its rich flavor and smooth texture. Peach cobbler also appears as a notable dessert option.

People are saying

"I loved the soul food and lively atmosphere."

"The cornbread here is delicious, straight out of the oven."

"The sweet potato pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are essential to avoid a long wait, especially on weekends.

2

The gospel brunch starts at 1 p.m. on Sundays with live music.

3

Expect a wait time of up to 2.5 hours during peak hours.

10
Make My Cake image 1
Make My Cake image 2
Make My Cake image 3
View all

Small bakery shines with sweet potato pie that tastes homemade and sells out fast. Unique cakes like caramel cake with dual frostings add variety. Quiet atmosphere suits early visits before desserts disappear by late afternoon.

Sweet potato pie sells out fast and has a homemade taste like great grandma's. Other pies include key lime and bean pie, with mixed reviews on the sweet potato variety.

People are saying

"I managed to snag a slice of the sweet potato pie."

"Their sweet potato pies taste great."

"The sweet potato pie tastes just like my great grandmaโ€™s."

Good to know

1

The bakery charges 75 cents extra for light ice, making drinks nearly $10.

2

Call ahead for custom cakes to ensure they have enough time to prepare.

3

The bakery closes at 7 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

Discover more

Central Harlem, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...