Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Pizza and desserts in Flatiron

A slice of pizza followed by a treat that feels like a complete night out, not just a quick snack.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Stretch Pizza image 1
Stretch Pizza image 2
Stretch Pizza image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Outdoor dining includes a trolley car-style hut with cozy booths and bar seating inside. Atmosphere blends warmth and thoughtfulness with occasional noise from a slamming door. Cocktails and pizza stand out for quality, offering a unique upscale sit-down experience.

Soft ice cream stands out as a special dessert here. Stretch Pizza offers a bonus surprise brownie with orders, adding a sweet finish to the meal.

Classic crust-sauce-cheese pizza gets a fresh twist with unique and delicious pies. The pepperoni pizza stands out as a clear example of this approach, offering a memorable flavor experience.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was seriously great."

"The house salad was delicious and made with high-quality ingredients."

"The soft serve and cookies are the best examples of what desserts should be."

Good to know

1

The price of a personal pizza pie is $25.

2

Pizzas come in a 12 inch pie, which is plenty for two people to share.

3

The bathroom is several flights down, but there is elevator access.

02
Tappo NYC Thin Crust Pizza image 1

Large space with art deco style and roomy tables creates a modern yet slightly outdated feel. Loud noise levels from stone walls and high-volume reggaeton music make conversation difficult. Outdoor terrace and full bar offer comfortable amenities alongside excellent thin crust pizza.

Chocolate and ice cream desserts stand out with their perfect balance. Tiramisu takes a unique turn with caramel and cake-like texture, while brownies also feature among the dessert options.

Thin crust pizza stands out with its delicate crispness and original toppings like pineapple. Lunch specials often include a slice paired with a house salad, and appetizers such as burrata and bruschetta complement the meal well.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be remarkably thin and delicious."

"I found the gluten-free pizza to be amazing and delicious."

"The desserts here are delicious, especially the chocolate and ice cream."

Good to know

1

The restaurant automatically adds a 20% tip to the bill.

2

During happy hour, you can get a cheese pie with a pitcher of beer or a bottle of wine.

3

The restaurant claims to offer gluten-free options, but they are not actually safe for someone with celiac disease.

03
Mangia 23rd Downtown Italian Food Events & Corporate Catering image 1

Multiple counters offer pizza, sandwiches, hot dishes, and an open buffet sold by weight in a simple, breakfast-suited decor with ample seating including communal tables. Atmosphere feels comfortable and relaxed with a vibrant NYC vibe, though the space is notably cold without heating. Outdoor seating and a juice bar add variety to the dining experience.

Desserts come with reasonable prices and a tempting selection including a notable passion fruit tart. Juices and sweets serve as quick, delicious options with no complaints.

Multiple counters serve pizza by the pound alongside sandwiches, pasta, and a salad bar. The pizza stands out as a favorite choice with options to combine it with other dishes.

People are saying

"Sylvia and Jonathan make the best salads."

"The salad bar staff are so friendly and attentive."

"I found the pizza to be amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant can get very crowded around noon and 2 PM.

2

Mangia offers both to-go and sit down dining options.

3

The prices are very decent for NYC.

04
Zero Otto Nove Manhattan image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers warm lighting and Mediterranean ambiance with spacious seating that supports relaxed conversation. The atmosphere feels inviting and peaceful, suitable for casual dining or date nights. Guests often enjoy watching servers prepare dishes tableside, adding to the engaging experience.

Desserts include a hazelnut spread pizza, Nutella mousse with strawberries, and profiteroles with chocolate. These options offer a mix of rich and fruity flavors.

Wood-fired cooking creates artisanal pizzas with a variety of toppings. The butternut squash pizza stands out for its perfect balance and flavor.

People are saying

"The Italian food here, especially the pasta, is spectacular."

"I thought the pizza here was excellent and well-made."

"The desserts here are delicious, especially the rich vanilla ice cream."

Good to know

1

Happy hour cocktails are $10 from 5-7 pm, Monday to Friday.

2

Reservations are recommended for busy nights, especially weekends.

3

Expect to pay around $100 for two pizzas and two drinks.

05
Bar Milano image 1
Restaurant

Italian restaurant inside a large delicatessen offers a lively, busy atmosphere with close seating and a modern, crisp decor. The space feels European-like but can be noisy, affecting the overall vibe. An extensive wine and cocktail selection complements the energetic setting.

Desserts include tiramisu and chocolate cannoli. The sweets complement the exquisite food and drinks well.

Firewood pizza stands out with its authentic Italian style. The tartufo pizza uses truffle paste but has a bitter taste and comes at a high price point.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the fresh pasta."

"The pizza here is really good, especially the firewood kind."

"The ravioli here are little pillows of heaven."

Good to know

1

Make sure you make a reservation as it is usually packed.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait for your main course during busy hours.

3

The total cost for a solo dinner of an appetizer and a glass of wine is around $60 after tip.

06
Eataly - Flatiron image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Italian market and dining space combines multiple restaurants, specialty counters, and rooftop seating under one roof. Atmosphere ranges from warm and inviting to loud and bustling, with a mix of casual shoppers and diners. Frequent demonstrations and sample bars add an interactive element to the experience.

Gelato and desserts stand out with delicious flavors and variety. The spot includes an ice cream shop and a dessert shop offering classic Italian sweets.

Napolitana style pizza stands out with excellent pasta and pizza options. The ruota di carro Margherita and buffolata pizzas offer fantastic flavors, though slices come at a higher price.

People are saying

"It's an amazing Italian grocery store with high-quality, hard-to-find products."

"I enjoyed the Neapolitan pizza here."

"The tiramisu dessert is creamy, smooth, and has a good coffee flavor."

Good to know

1

Pizza by the slice costs between $7-12.

2

You walk along to pick what you want to eat and drink.

3

The location is tucked away in the back left corner by La Pizza.

07
La Pizza & La Pasta image 1

Italian restaurant inside a bustling food market offers wood-burning oven pizza and imported Italian wine. The space is large and elegant with a vibrant atmosphere that can be loud and crowded. Tables sit close together, creating a lively but sometimes cramped dining experience.

An amazing chocolate and Nutella gelato called coppa con cioccolato & nocciola stands out as a dessert option. Gelato served at the doorway offers a more straightforward choice.

Margherita and Prosciutto pizzas have a perfect crust thickness with balanced sauce and cheese. Gluten-free options are available, including a pesto pizza that pairs well with cannoli.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta and pizza, is delicious and made with love."

"The pizza crust is soft, light, and delicious."

"The tiramisu and gelato desserts were exceptionally sweet and enjoyable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is located inside a mall, which might make it hard to find.

2

The prices of the food are great for the portions.

3

The menu costs $26, offering good value.

08
Aqua Roma | New York image 1
Italian restaurant

Large space features a huge bar and 70-foot sushi bar with nets surrounding the bar adding visual interest. Atmosphere shifts from cozy, dimly lit dining to lively with a late-night DJ creating vibrant energy. Guests enjoy a stylish setting with thoughtful design and private rooms upstairs.

Desserts feature a playful mix of textures with espresso tapioca pearls and Valrhona chocolate mousse in the Sweet Caviar. The Forrest Floor and Pumpkin Sundae stand out as stunning options alongside the Limone dessert.

Funghi pizza stands out with its rich flavor. Sharing pizzas with dishes like lamb and tomahawk steak adds variety to the meal.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and spectacular."

"You have to leave space for the truly unforgettable desserts here."

"The pizza here is amazing, and the staff are incredible hosts."

Good to know

1

Happy Hour offers discounted drinks from 4-6pm on weekdays.

2

Reservations are highly recommended due to limited seating.

3

The 3-course lunch meal deal costs $30, providing good value.

Discover more

Flatiron District, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...