Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in SoHo

American and Italian food

Made for those who refuse to be pinned down to a single culinary tradition and want the best of both domestic and Mediterranean influences.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Odd Sister image 1
Odd Sister image 2
Odd Sister image 3
View all
American restaurant

Cozy and stylish interior with unique cocktails and a large covered backyard bar creates a calm, romantic atmosphere. Music stays phenomenal throughout, supporting intimate conversations and lively gatherings. Space fills up, so reservations help secure a spot in this iconic SoHo setting.

Steak bites and fried chicken sandwich become weekly staples here. The steak and eggs come cooked to perfection with flavorful eggs, and the fried chicken sandwich pairs well with a pineapple drink.

Gnocchi stands out as especially amazing and tasty. The crab pasta and truffle fries also get finished quickly, showing their appeal. Pizza tends to have a bit too much mozzarella.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and nicely presented."

"The fried chicken sandwich is so delicious and juicy."

"The crab pasta here is so tasty, I considered it heaven."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is advisable because the restaurant is busy.

2

Saturdays are busy but fun; expect a lively atmosphere.

3

Happy hour drinks have a great vibe and are popular.

02
Il Mulino Prime image 1
Fine dining restaurant

Small space with brick walls and cement ceiling creates an elegant yet tight seating environment. Loud music and external noise raise the sound level, making conversation difficult. Italian vibe blends with upscale, chic atmosphere and perfect cocktails.

Porterhouse steak and prime rib stand out with rich seasoning and perfect cooking. Dishes like truffle ravioli and burrata add variety beyond classic American fare.

Homemade pasta stands out with perfect cooking and rich flavors. Dishes like mushroom ravioli, veal with risotto, and chicken Parmesan showcase classic Italian tastes with quality ingredients.

People are saying

"The steak here is fantastic, I plan to try medium next time."

"I plan to try the steak again."

"The American Food here, especially the steak, is cooked to perfection."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for special occasions.

2

Happy hour offers lite bites at discounted prices.

3

Expect high prices; a dinner for four can exceed $500.

03
Emmett's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with vintage elements and intimate seating creates a cozy vibe. Loud music energizes the atmosphere, while outdoor patio offers a heated option. Known for Chicago-style deep dish pizza and a solid beer selection on tap.

Chicago deep dish pizza stands out with its authentic style and rich flavor. Chicago hot dogs come exactly as expected, light and delicious, alongside mozzarella sticks that are super light.

Mozzarella sticks come out perfectly cooked with cheese melding well with the breading and a sauce that complements them. Fresh, well-flavored seafood pasta and deep dish pizza also stand out as specialties.

People are saying

"This deep dish pizza is saucy, spicy, and has a buttery crust."

"I found the Chicago deep dish pizza here to be the best in NYC."

"The deep dish pizza here is rich, decadent, and full of cheese."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must if you want to eat inside due to limited seating.

2

They have amazing happy hour deals from 5-6:30.

3

On busy nights, be prepared for a long wait at Emmettโ€™s.

04
Balthazar image 1
French restaurant

Stunning interior design evokes a Parisian feel with tiny, closely spaced tables that create a noisy, crowded atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pleasant alternative, and solo diners receive a complimentary glass of champagne. The bar serves excellent cocktails and wine selections.

Eggs Benedict stands out with perfect hollandaise sauce and consistent quality. Steaks like the New York strip come with a good balance of fat and meat cooked well. Classic dishes include onion soup, mac and cheese, hamburgers, and creme brulee.

Lobster pasta stands out with a solid flavor, while the seafood tower offers a variety of fresh options. Staff accommodate sharing by splitting dishes like risotto without fuss.

People are saying

"The French bistro staples here are comforting and perfectly executed."

"The Italian food here, especially the lobster spaghetti, is delicious."

"This American food feels timeless and effortlessly elegant."

Good to know

1

Getting a reservation is advisable because the diner gets crowded.

2

Single diners receive a free glass of champagne.

3

There is a $60 no-show fee for reservations.

05
The Dutch image 1
American restaurant

Restaurant combines indoor and outdoor seating with a bar wrapping around the center and sidewalk tables under a covered structure. Atmosphere feels loud and lively, with a historic Soho vibe that adds charm. Space includes well-shaded outdoor areas and a private dining room downstairs.

Fried chicken stands out with moist meat and well-seasoned skin. Baked goods like key lime donut and chipotle cornbread offer unique flavors. The duck meatloaf delivers rich, bold taste.

Menu offers an extensive range from pasta to steak. Smoked ricotta ravioli with moon drop grapes and spring pea ravioli with ricotta stand out. Winter burrata with butternut squash and hot fried chicken also feature.

People are saying

"You have to try the fried chicken; it's gorgeous and delicious."

"You have to try the deviled eggs stuffed with crabmeat."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the pasta."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed for brunch to ensure a table.

2

Brunch time is a popular time to visit, expect crowds.

3

The price of a glass of white wine is $19.

06
The Otter image 1
Seafood restaurant

Nautical 50s style space with lacquered navy walls, white wood-paneled ceilings, and curved banquettes creates a sexy, cozy atmosphere perfect for conversation. Outdoor dining area offers a quiet, comfortable patio setting. Signature cocktails like the Otter Dirty Martini complement the vibe.

Lobster roll stands out with a generous filling and a side of green beans. Some find it overly sauced, which can mask the lobster flavor.

Seafood platter and agnolotti pasta stand out on the menu. Desserts like pistachio tiramisu and rice pudding also catch attention.

People are saying

"The seafood here is delicious, especially the fresh oysters."

"The Italian food here is amazing and incredible."

"The American Food lobster roll was divine and filling."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Expect a $100 tab for four cocktails, including tip.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of seafood dishes and options for non-seafood lovers.

07
Lure Fishbar image 1
Restaurant

Interior resembles inside of a yacht with porthole-inspired windows and a semi-subterranean dining room. Atmosphere is lively and loud, requiring raised voices for conversation. Patrons enjoy fresh seafood and creative cocktails in a space that balances charm with a fun, ship-style vibe.

Seafood shines with lobster rolls, crab cakes, and clam chowder. Breakfast includes omelettes alongside sushi and lobster dishes. The menu also features tempura shrimp, branzino, and lobster mac and cheese.

Uni bucatini pasta stands out with its hot and slightly spicy flavor. The menu includes crab pasta and vegetarian ravioli options, all served fresh and delicious.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and perfectly cooked."

"The staff here really took care of us during our visit."

"The Italian Food here, especially the seafood pasta, is amazing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers half-off oysters until 7pm.

2

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

3

Expect a minimum spend of $870 for a party of six.

08
Charlie Bird image 1
Italian restaurant

Indoor space feels cramped with loud hip hop music that makes conversation difficult. Outdoor seating offers a warm, inviting atmosphere with stylish decor. The vibe is lively and energetic, attracting a crowd that enjoys a bustling dining experience.

Tuscan fried chicken stands out as a flavorful and juicy appetizer. Other favorites include rigatoni cacio de pepe pasta and focaccia with burrata starters, which often outshine the main dishes.

Cacio e Pepe stands out as a signature pasta dish here. The menu also features a variety of pastas like tortellini, gnocchi, and pappardelle with lamb ragu, alongside appetizers such as tuna and crudos.

People are saying

"I thought the wine list was exceptional and top-notch."

"The Italian food's focaccia is so delicious and fluffy."

"The fried chicken here is a must-try American Food."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features house Negronis for $10 per glass.

2

Expect to wait 30-45 minutes after your reservation time.

3

Portion sizes are small, especially for the price.

Discover more

SoHo, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...