Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
SoHo's best

Cozy pizza places

Pizza that offers a quiet corner to sit and eat, not just a frantic counter for grabbing a slice on the go.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated June 2026
01
Francesco SoHo image 1
Francesco SoHo image 2
Francesco SoHo image 3
View all
Restaurant

Simple, light space blends cozy atmosphere with chic design and coffee shop vibes. Friendly staff enhance the warm, pleasant setting. Padellino pizza margot with San Marzano tomatoes shines, best paired with lambrusco natural wine for a refined yet comfy experience.

Warm and pleasant atmosphere combines with friendly, attentive staff who guide through food options. The space feels super comfy and beautiful, making it easy to relax.

Padellino pizza margot features San Marzano tomatoes and stands out as a surprise. Pairing any pizza with a glass of lambrusco natural wine in the evening highlights the experience.

People are saying

"The pastries here are fresh, original, and meticulously crafted."

"I loved the cozy vibe and warm service here."

"I thought the padellino pizza was perfect."

Good to know

1

The cafรฉ offers a variety of organic coffee options, with lattes priced at $7 for regular milk.

2

Baked goods are made fresh daily and are about 20% more expensive than nearby bakeries.

3

The cafรฉ is located on Greene Street, not Broome Street as listed in some places.

02
Odd Sister image 1
American restaurant

Cozy vibes shine with warm smiles and friendly service. Spicy sausage pizza stands out with a perfect kick and crispy crust. Unique cocktails and a large covered backyard bar create a calm, romantic spot in SoHo.

Warm smiles and impeccable service create a welcoming vibe. The atmosphere feels cozy and inviting, with staff that add to the friendly ambiance.

Spicy sausage pizza offers a perfect kick with a crispy crust. Happy hour $6 pizza provides a great deal with excellent quality. Varieties include a memorable white pizza and a classic margherita.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and nicely presented."

"I found the pizza here to be even better than I expected."

"It's a cozy spot with a warm, inviting atmosphere and good music."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation is advisable because the restaurant is busy.

2

Saturdays are busy but fun; expect a lively atmosphere.

3

Happy hour drinks have a great vibe and are popular.

03
Lucia Alimentari image 1

Small, intimate space with only five or six tables creates a cozy, peaceful atmosphere ideal for date nights. Music and ambiance feel sexy and special, enhancing the overall vibe. Unique market and pantry items add a distinctive touch beyond the dining experience.

The atmosphere feels cozy and intimate, making it a great spot for date night.

Pizza stands out for its vodka sauce and sausage toppings. The crust can be soggy on the bottom, but the flavor remains delicious and well-balanced.

People are saying

"I thought Lucia Alimentari had the best pizza in NYC."

"I found the wine list to be amazing and impressive."

"I thought the pizza here was amazing."

Good to know

1

The establishment does not accept cash.

2

They have $2 espresso shots available.

3

Unique market/pantry items are for sale.

04
Emmett's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with cozy vibe and loud music energizes the room. Chicago-style deep dish pizza shines with thick cheese and hearty meats. Outdoor patio offers a heated spot to enjoy a solid beer selection on tap.

Warm and inviting atmosphere sets a cozy vibe with good music playing. Small space feels perfect for casual nights and catching up, supported by excellent service.

Deep dish pizza here features a thick cheese topping and generous meat portions, especially on the meat lover's pie. Flatbread and Chicago-style pizzas come in large sizes that satisfy two people, with flavors that stand out in the city.

People are saying

"This deep dish pizza is saucy, spicy, and has a buttery crust."

"This place has excellent pizza, perfect for date spots."

"I thought the deep dish pizza was excellent and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must if you want to eat inside due to limited seating.

2

They have amazing happy hour deals from 5-6:30.

3

On busy nights, be prepared for a long wait at Emmettโ€™s.

05
Il Corallo Trattoria image 1
Italian restaurant

Small dining space feels cramped with tables close together, creating an intimate setting. Outdoor heated seating offers a relaxing atmosphere with street views and great music enhancing the experience. The vibe is family-oriented and low key, suitable for casual meals and quiet dates.

A small menu and a classic family vibe create a cozy atmosphere. The outdoor seating adds to the intimate feel.

Pizza features an amazingly chewy and soft crust with dough praised for its quality. Varieties include Quatro Formaggi, clams pizza, and Napoletana, noted for fresh taste and impressive quality.

People are saying

"The pasta here is so fresh and delicious."

"The seafood here is perfectly cooked and flavorful."

"I found the wood-fired pizza to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The lunch special is $14 daily until 4pm.

2

Lunch at the restaurant is a great deal at $13.95 for two courses.

3

Most pasta dishes are under $30, and appetizers with meat or seafood are under $15.

06
Old Fashion Cafรฉ image 1
Italian restaurant

Basement setting with retro-vintage furnishings creates a cozy vibe perfect for relaxed brunches. Italian ownership brings authentic touch to the menu, featuring standout pizzas like mortadella and caprese with unique cheese and perfect dough. Warmth and excellent music complete the intimate experience.

Warmth fills the small space with a cozy atmosphere and genuinely kind staff. The ambiance suits a relaxed breakfast or brunch, complemented by excellent music and attentive service.

Mortadella pizza offers a solid choice while the caprese pizza features cheese unlike anything imagined and perfectly textured dough. Pizza prices sit around 18 dollars on the menu.

People are saying

"I loved the spicy and bubble drinks; they were boozy enough."

"The pasta here is delicious and full of flavor."

"The pizza here is great, with quality ingredients and flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; walk-ins are welcome.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Parking is generally easy to find in the area.

07
Mamo image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers an elegant atmosphere with cramped seating and loud noise levels. Decor includes vintage movie posters and a stylish, vibrant vibe. Cocktails and desserts stand out as highlights amid the warm, romantic setting.

Warm hosts and attentive managers create a welcoming atmosphere. The vibe is super aesthetic and suits cozy dinners or snapping cute Instagram pics.

Truffle pizza stands out with a good amount of truffles and a size suitable for sharing. It pairs well with truffle burrata and earns praise for its freshness and rich flavor.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the pasta, is perfectly al dente and flavorful."

"You have to try the truffle pizza; it's amazing."

"It's a cozy spot with an amazing, elevated atmosphere."

Good to know

1

A reservation is required to dine at the restaurant.

2

The cost for two people can reach $420.

3

The black truffle pizza costs $50 at brunch.

08
Gilligan's image 1
Cocktail bar

Open outdoor space with tropical decor and lush plants creates a cozy island tiki bar vibe. Atmosphere feels like a summer beach club oasis with shaded areas and water mists to cool the heat. Popular spot for daytime drinks and evening gatherings, especially busy on weekends.

Tiki bar offers a cozy atmosphere with intimate decor and plenty of plants. Shaded outdoor bars use water mists and cool drinks to keep it comfortable even in heat, while attentive service adds warmth.

Woodfired pizzas stand out with options like pesto and squash blossom. The menu offers a wide variety of choices, all paired well with beers or salads.

People are saying

"The outdoor seating here is super beautiful with tons of plants."

"The pizza here has an awesome, super cute vibe."

"It's so cozy with all the plants and charming decor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

The outdoor setting is ideal for summer visits but can be too hot.

3

The menu is limited, focusing mainly on drinks and a few food items.

09
Sartiano's image 1
Italian restaurant

Spacious interior combines dim lighting with a bar area and a downstairs lounge, creating a chic vibe suited for social and corporate gatherings. Music and crowd contribute to a lively, sometimes noisy atmosphere. Outdoor seating offers a pet-friendly spot to enjoy city views.

The space feels cozy and warm with a comfortable, luxurious interior design. The atmosphere invites relaxation but the vibe can feel less inviting at times.

Calabrese pizza offers a spicy and savory balance on a crispy crust. Other pizzas like nduja, margherita, and pepperoni vary in quality, with some having soggy dough and oily texture.

People are saying

"The food and drinks here are top-notch for Date Spots."

"I found the atmosphere to be warm and cozy."

"The pizza crust here is the best I ever ate."

Good to know

1

Reservations can only be contacted by email, and the office is only open from 10 am to 5 pm.

2

The restaurant closes for brunch at 3pm.

3

The restaurant enforces a strict dress code that prohibits shorts, hats, and open-toed shoes.

10
A Pasta Bar image 1
Italian restaurant

Open kitchen with chef's counter seating creates an engaging and intimate dining experience. Outdoor heated seating and pleasant music contribute to a relaxed atmosphere. Attention to detail shows in customized glassware and modern, simple design elements.

Small patio offers heated outdoor seating that feels warm and comfortable. The atmosphere stays cozy and intimate, with warm, efficient service enhancing the inviting vibe.

Black truffle pizza costs $60 and impresses with its rich flavor. The pata negra jamon pizza stands out as exceptionally tasty. Fried pizza offers a unique texture that many enjoy. Servers sometimes customize pizzas to make them special.

People are saying

"I traveled here monthly for the best pasta I've ever had."

"The atmosphere here is cozy with warm lighting and great music."

"I thought the pata negra pizza was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations should be made at least a few days in advance, especially on weekends.

2

The kitchen closes at 10:30 PM.

3

The restaurant adds 20% gratuity to the bill.

Discover more

SoHo, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...