Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the West Village

Cake shops

A slice of cake that stands on its own merit rather than relying on a fancy presentation.

Based on 838 Opinions
+835
User
User
User
Updated
01
Hungry Llama image 1
Hungry Llama image 2
Hungry Llama image 3
View all

Open, airy space with floor-to-ceiling windows offers a bright, relaxed vibe. Remote workers enjoy dedicated work areas and reliable WiFi. Olive oil cake is a must-try, especially the chocolate olive oil cake paired with cappuccino.

Olive oil cake stands out with its unique flavor and rich texture. Chocolate olive oil cake and cappuccino pair well, and sometimes extra cakes come as a bonus.

People are saying

"I found the olive oil cake to be from another world."

"The olive oil cake tastes amazing"

"I loved having the olive oil cake here"

Good to know

1

Breakfast and egg dishes are available until 2:30 PM on weekdays and 3:30 PM on weekends.

2

There are only three 2-seat tables inside, making seating scarce during busy times.

3

The cafe offers options for gluten-free (GF) and vegan (V) diets.

02
Sho Tse image 1
Sho Tse image 2
Sho Tse image 3
View all

Tiny space with covered outdoor seating offers a cozy vibe filled with local Ukrainian art and loud music. Authentic traditional Ukrainian dishes shine alongside best Medovik honey cake in NYC. Casual dining and takeout make it easy to enjoy the warm spirit of NYC on the patio.

Honey cake stands out with its exceptional flavor and is often called the best Medovik in NYC. Waffle cake and Napoleon cake also appear as notable sweet options.

People are saying

"The Ukrainian dishes here taste truly authentic and delicious."

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty food here."

"I found the honey cake to be exceptional and memorable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers traditional Ukrainian cuisine with a focus on homemade dishes.

2

Delivery is available through GrubHub for convenient ordering.

3

There is no seating available to enjoy the food inside; takeout is recommended.

03
Leitao image 1
Leitao image 2
Leitao image 3
View all

Authentic Portuguese restaurant offers a calm atmosphere with warm decor and heated outdoor seating. Signature cocktails and complimentary tawny port enhance the experience. Portuguese sponge cake shines with custard flavor, while nata cakes and croquettes add tasty variety.

Portuguese sponge cake offers a custard flavor with berries and a light sweetness. Nata cakes and croquettes also stand out as notable options.

People are saying

"The sponge cake was soft and just sweet enough."

"The Portuguese egg tart's shell is hot and crispy."

"I loved trying the light cake and tasty dishes."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at least two weeks in advance due to high demand.

2

Fado nights occur occasionally, offering live traditional music experiences.

3

The suckling pig dinner must be ordered at least a week ahead.

04
The Mary Lane image 1
The Mary Lane image 2
The Mary Lane image 3
View all

Outdoor seating with a large covered area suits any weather, while indoor spaces boast dark wood and perfect lighting. Olive oil cakes with candied rhubarb offer a delicate finish. A private event space downstairs fits larger groups or meetings.

Olive oil cakes stand out here, especially the versions with candied rhubarb and almond. These cakes offer a delicate finish that complements the meal well.

People are saying

"The olive oil almond cake was a surprising and perfect ending."

"I enjoyed the salads, scallops, and cakes a lot."

"The olive oil cake is my favorite dessert."

Good to know

1

Make reservations because the restaurant gets busy.

2

Expect to pay about $70 per person if you have some wine, appetizers, and entrees.

3

The kitchen at the Mary Lane closes between 9:30 PM and 10:30 PM.

05
4 Charles Prime Rib image 1
4 Charles Prime Rib image 2
4 Charles Prime Rib image 3
View all

Steak house charms with an intimate interior and a snug patio for air-conditioned outdoor dining. Coconut cake offers an unreal flavor, while chocolate cake delights with rich ganache. Perfect for quiet talks and special nights.

Coconut cake stands out with its unreal flavor and texture. The chocolate cake topped with whipped cream and ganache also draws attention as a rich dessert option.

People are saying

"The coconut cake was an absolute standout and so good."

"I love the rich chocolate cake and sundaes here."

"The crab cakes and prime rib stand out as favorites."

Good to know

1

Reservations need to be booked 30 days in advance.

2

Reservations open on their website 7 days ahead and refresh at 9am ET daily.

3

The market price for the porterhouse was $350.

06
Roey's image 1
Roey's image 2
Roey's image 3
View all

Woodfire oven and open kitchen create a gorgeous interior with cozy seating. Olive oil cake is spongy and juicy, served with ice cream for a sweet finish. Outdoor space offers lovely summer seating perfect for people watching and drinks.

Olive oil cake stands out with its spongy, juicy texture and melts in the mouth. It comes with complimentary ice cream and serves as a delicious end to the meal.

People are saying

"I thought the olive oil cake melted in my mouth."

"The olive oil cake melted in my mouth."

"The pizza was incredible and the olive oil cake a must-have."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

2

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 6 PM on weekdays.

3

The happy hour offers $6 Margherita pizzas and $5 spritz’s.

07
Saint Theo's image 1
Saint Theo's image 2
Saint Theo's image 3
View all

Cozy booths and gorgeous decor create a warm setting. Evening brings a lively atmosphere with skilled bartenders mixing exceptional cocktails. Desserts shine with warm chocolate lava cake and tasty olive oil cake.

Warm, rich chocolate lava cake features velvety chocolate oozing from the center. Olive oil cake offers a great, delicious dessert option alongside tiramisu.

People are saying

"The vibe is cool and the food tastes great."

"I’d totally recommend this place for a fun night."

"I'd recommend the olive oil cake for dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed, especially for dinner service.

2

The restaurant only has tables available at 5:30 PM or 10 PM.

3

The bar scene is packed on Friday nights.

08
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 1
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 2
L’industrie Pizzeria West Village image 3
View all

Small space with limited seating creates a lively, crowded vibe where most stand or eat fast. Long lines show its popularity among pizza lovers, with a fun slice assembly display. Unique desserts like pistachio tres leches and olive oil cake offer rich, sweet finishes.

Pistachio tres leches and olive oil cake stand out with rich, unique flavors. The carrot cake and ice cream offer a satisfying, sweet finish.

People are saying

"The pizza slices are always hot and tasty."

"The olive oil cake really stole the show."

"The olive oil cake is addictive and not too sweet."

Good to know

1

Expect a line, especially during peak hours.

2

To avoid long waits, visit on weekdays from 2-4 pm.

3

Seating is very limited, making it unsuitable for large groups.

09
Bangkok Supper Club image 1
Bangkok Supper Club image 2
Bangkok Supper Club image 3
View all

Elegant Thai restaurant features an open kitchen and chef's table for a cozy, stylish vibe. Desserts shine with pandan chiffon cake served in a coconut shell, highlighting mild sweetness and rich flavors. Unique, top-tier cocktails add a sophisticated touch to the experience.

Desserts highlight a pandan chiffon cake served inside a coconut shell with coconut cream. The cake offers a mild sweetness that lets the pandan and coconut flavors stand out.

People are saying

"The vibe is stylish and the food tastes great, but some think it's pricey."

"The pandan coconut cake is a highlight here."

"The rice cake had a great chewy texture and subtle flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations are needed at least 3-4 weeks in advance to secure a table.

2

Expect a wait time of over 2 hours for seating during peak hours.

3

Bar seating is available without a reservation, first come, first served.

10
Cecchi's image 1
Cecchi's image 2
Cecchi's image 3
View all

Stylish bistro shines with art deco interior and custom murals creating a vibrant vibe. Chocolate cake offers a traditional style that feels like a time capsule. Expertly crafted martinis and cocktails fuel lively conversations at the bar.

Chocolate cake stands out with a traditional style and a time capsule feel. Other options include NY Cheesecake and banana cream pie, both well made.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and great food."

"The chocolate cake is deep, rich, and heavenly."

"The chocolate cake is rich and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Drinks are served in under 10 minutes, appetizers in 15 minutes.

3

Parking next door is convenient and inexpensive with prepay.

11
Osteria Nonnino image 1
Osteria Nonnino image 2
Osteria Nonnino image 3
View all

Italian restaurant shines with tableside pasta and pistachio lava cake. Cozy space blends rustic and contemporary styles with lively, sometimes noisy, atmosphere. Outdoor seating adds charm to the warm, inviting vibe.

Pistachio lava cake stands out as a dessert highlight. The tiramisu is prepared tableside, adding a fresh touch to the dessert options.

People are saying

"You have to try the pistachio lava cake; it's insane."

"The pistachio lava cake stole the show."

"The starters and pistachio lava cake hit the spot."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times for walk-ins, especially during peak hours.

3

Happy hour runs until 7pm with discounts on drinks and snacks.

12
Milk Bar image 1
Milk Bar image 2
Milk Bar image 3
View all

Minimalistic layout with a neon sign creates a stylish vibe. Known for birthday cake with colorful slices and cake truffles, it also offers a unique menu featuring cereal milk soft serve and cornflake crunch. Friendly staff and fun atmosphere complete the experience.

Birthday cake stands out for its delicious, colorful slices that helped make the brand famous. Cakes come in small portions priced around $7 and include cake truffles alongside other tasty options.

People are saying

"The birthday cake is really sweet but delicious."

"The birthday cake slices here are iconic and delicious."

"The cakes seem a bit pricey for their size."

Good to know

1

Prices are generally high for everything in NYC.

2

Two small soft serve cups cost 20 dollars.

3

Milk Bar does not accept cash payments.

13
L'Artusi image 1
L'Artusi image 2
L'Artusi image 3
View all

Stylish Italian spot boasts a skylit upper level and a wine cellar private room for groups. Loud, crowded vibe with tight tables makes chatting tough. Don't miss the olive oil cake and salted chocolate cake for a rich, unique dessert experience.

Olive oil cake stands out with its rich flavor and is a consistent favorite. Salted chocolate cake offers a balanced texture combining cake, popcorn, and gelato.

People are saying

"You have to try the olive oil cake; it's wonderful."

"The olive oil cake is a unique and delicious treat."

"I loved the pasta, mushrooms, and olive oil cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended and should be made at least two weeks in advance.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

A minimum 20% tip is expected for service.

14
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 1
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 2
Realmuto: Italian Pastry & Gelato image 3
View all

Elegant coffee shop offers hazelnut chocolate sponge cake and a variety of Italian pastries crafted by a master baker. Spacious, stylish interior with live jazz music creates a lively, inviting atmosphere. Enjoy authentic Italian vibes and homemade pasta for a genuine dining experience.

Hazelnut chocolate sponge cake stands out with its perfectly balanced flavors and moderate sweetness. Italian master baker crafts a variety of beautiful pastries and cakes displayed in large cases, all priced reasonably for celebrations.

People are saying

"I love the authentic Italian food and vibe here."

"The chocolate sponge cake with hazelnut mousse is superb."

"I can't wait to come back and eat here again."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required for lunch or dinner service.

2

Expect a casual atmosphere suitable for both quick visits and formal dining.

3

Desserts are highly recommended, especially the gelato.

15
AnnTremet Cake image 1
AnnTremet Cake image 2
AnnTremet Cake image 3
View all

Small bakery offers a cozy atmosphere with minimalist decor and a few tables. Cakes are intricately designed and flavorful, featuring mirror glazed and mousse options. Delivery service adds convenience for enjoying these artful desserts.

Cakes here are aesthetically pleasing and flavorful, not too sweet but delicious. Options include mirror glazed and mousse cakes with a variety of flavors, and they offer delivery services.

People are saying

"The cakes are moist, light, and beautifully designed."

"The cakes taste great and aren't too sweet."

"Annabelle was so helpful and patient with my cake questions."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly advised due to limited seating.

2

The Halloween Afternoon Tea costs $52 per person and features eerie treats.

3

Christmas tea time slots fill up quickly, so book early.

16
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 1
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 2
Sant Ambroeus West Village image 3
View all

Italian cafe offers a cozy, romantic vibe with close tables and quiet outdoor seating. Princess cake steals the show with its exceptional taste, perfect for surprise birthdays with fresh berries. Atmosphere stays relaxed despite occasional unruly guests.

Princess cake stands out as a highly praised dessert, described as exceptional and the best cake ever had. Surprise birthday cakes come with berries and add a special touch to celebrations.

People are saying

"The food was fresh but the vibe was hit or miss."

"I love the cozy vibe and great food here."

"The Princess cake is the best cake I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended at the restaurant to secure a table.

2

The restaurant is often full, making walk-ins difficult.

3

Prices are on the higher side, so budget accordingly.

17
Do Not Feed Alligators image 1
Do Not Feed Alligators image 2
Do Not Feed Alligators image 3
View all

Narrow space with modern design feels welcoming. Heated backyard patio offers a quiet, cozy spot. Rich and fudgy chocolate brownie cake impresses, while flan cake tastes very delicious. Crowds gather on weekends, adding lively energy.

Rich and fudgy chocolate brownie cake stands out with its dense texture. Orange cake varies from crumbly to just okay, while flan cake tastes very delicious.

People are saying

"The coffee and vibe were sometimes good, sometimes not."

"I loved the coffee and chill vibe here."

"The orange cake was good, delicious, and okay."

Good to know

1

Laptops are not allowed in the coffee shop.

2

It is hard to get a seat in the cafe.

3

The prices are too expensive for what the offerings are.

18
Little Ruby's West Village image 1
Little Ruby's West Village image 2
Little Ruby's West Village image 3
View all

Two-level layout with dynamic vibe and loud music creates an energetic spot. Cocktails like Yuzu Jalapeño Margarita shine at the bars. Chocolate cake is a gluten-free delight, while hot cakes offer a satisfying dessert choice.

Chocolate cake stands out with its gluten-free recipe and rich flavor. Hot cakes also deliver a satisfying, well-executed option for dessert.

People are saying

"I love how the food hits the spot with some favorites."

"You have to try the chocolate cake; it's amazing."

"The chocolate cake is absolutely amazing."

Good to know

1

Having a reservation is recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Breakfast is served until 4pm at this Ruby's location.

3

Dinner only starts at 5 PM.

19
Rosemary's image 1
Rosemary's image 2
Rosemary's image 3
View all

Spacious Italian spot boasts a rustic atmosphere and a rooftop garden with pet-friendly seating. Noise can rise, making chat tough. Olive oil cake is a distinctive treat and staff cut your own cake for birthdays.

Olive oil cake stands out with its distinct flavor and often sells out. Staff offer a cake cutting service when you bring your own birthday cake.

People are saying

"I always crave the olive oil cake for dessert."

"I was only there for the olive oil cake."

"I loved trying the pasta, salad, and olive oil cake together."

Good to know

1

Reservations are a must on weekends due to high demand.

2

Happy hour runs from 4 PM to 6 PM with $9 cocktails.

3

Bottomless mimosas are available for one hour during brunch.

20
OLIO E PIÙ image 1
OLIO E PIÙ image 2
OLIO E PIÙ image 3
View all

Italian restaurant buzzes with lively atmosphere and close tables. Outdoor patio offers a cozy setting with plants and heating. Olive oil cake shines as a signature dessert, served with care and generosity.

Olive oil cake stands out as a frequent dessert choice, often served with complimentary generosity. Other sweet options include flourless chocolate cake and panna cotta, all prepared with care by the staff.

People are saying

"The chocolate cake was a great end to the meal."

"The pasta and olive oil cake taste amazing."

"I always go for the olive oil cake here."

Good to know

1

Happy hour starts at 3 PM and offers great deals.

2

Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

3

Olio offers a three-course dinner during New York restaurant week.

21
Wild image 1
Wild image 2
Wild image 3
View all

Cozy spot offers heated outdoor seating and a flourless chocolate cake perfect for gluten-free diners. Tables are tight but the relaxed vibe shines. Birthday guests enjoy a free slice of cake, adding a sweet touch to visits.

Flourless chocolate cake stands out and is available on the menu alongside pizza. Gluten-free options include a small cake gifted by the staff. Birthday visits come with a free slice of cake.

People are saying

"I love how tasty and varied the gluten-free menu is."

"The flourless chocolate cake is the best dessert."

"You have to get the chocolate cake; it's perfect."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is fully gluten-free, which is a key aspect.

2

The restaurant does not honor reservations.

3

Happy hours are from Monday to Friday, 12-7 pm, with $5 off any drink.

22
Claude Bakery (NYC) image 1
Claude Bakery (NYC) image 2
Claude Bakery (NYC) image 3
View all

Cozy bakery offers a warm atmosphere with soft lighting and jazz music. Chocolate cakes shine, especially the Manhattan Blackout Cake and black forest cake with cherries. Minimalist design and well-curated pastry display make it a calm, classic spot.

Chocolate cakes stand out here, especially the Manhattan Blackout Cake and the black forest cake with cherries. The chocolate cake is rich and often described as excellent and satisfying.

People are saying

"The Manhattan blackout cake is rich, decadent, and worth the hype."

"The chocolate cake is moist, rich, and delicious."

"The blackout cake gets mixed reviews but some love it."

Good to know

1

The croissants are baked daily to ensure they’re at their best.

2

Expect the croissants to be sold out by 4 PM.

3

The large cakes need to be ordered in advance.

23
Felice on Hudson image 1
Felice on Hudson image 2
Felice on Hudson image 3
View all

Italian restaurant offers understated sophistication in a cozy, dimly lit space with beautiful interior design. Pistachio cake shines with rich flavor, paired perfectly with pistachio gelato. Atmosphere feels romantic and casual, drawing locals for relaxed dining.

Pistachio cake stands out with its rich flavor and pairs well with pistachio ice cream or gelato. Desserts here include a notable tiramisu as well.

People are saying

"I loved the delicious food and cozy vibe here."

"I highly recommend this place to everyone."

"The pistachio cake here is among the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended in advance to secure a table.

2

Happy hour offers a variety of drinks and snacks at reduced prices.

3

The happy hour menu is available until 8pm, so arrive early.

24
Barbuto image 1
Barbuto image 2
Barbuto image 3
View all

Spacious dining with riverviews and an open kitchen sets a cozy mood for mature crowds. Pistachio nut cake offers a rich flavor that pairs well with pistachio gelato. Coconut and chocolate hazelnut cakes provide divine taste and a light finish.

Pistachio nut cake stands out with rich flavor and pairs well with pistachio gelato. Coconut cake offers a divine taste, while chocolate hazelnut cake feels light and finishes the meal smoothly.

People are saying

"Most dishes were good, and some really stood out."

"Jonathan Waxman's cooking always impresses and inspires."

"The pistachio cake here is amazing."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for parties of three or more due to high demand.

2

The restaurant keeps a few seats open for walk-ins.

3

The restaurant does not provide a menu before 5:00 PM.

25
I Sodi image 1
I Sodi image 2
I Sodi image 3
View all

Courtyard seating and candlelight create a cozy ambiance perfect for quiet nights. Negronis shine as Italian cocktails crafted with care. Flourless chocolate cake offers a rich dessert that completes the elegant dining experience.

Flourless chocolate cake offers the right thickness and richness. It stands out as a superb dessert option.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"The flourless chocolate cake is rich and delicious."

"You have to try the flourless chocolate cake; it's a must-try."

Good to know

1

Reservations are competitive as they open at midnight and are only available for 2 weeks in advance.

2

You need to put your name on the list upon arrival.

3

Expect a 3-hour wait for a table during peak times.

26
Paquita image 1
Paquita image 2
Paquita image 3
View all

Tiny tea house offers a quiet, elegant atmosphere with cozy indoor and heated outdoor seating. Baby Cakes come in Royal Vanilla and Triple Chocolate Brownie flavors, perfectly paired with fine teas. Space feels like a calm, nostalgic oasis from city life.

A variety of Baby Cakes come in flavors like Royal Vanilla, Triple Chocolate Brownie, and Lemon. Each cake is uniquely layered and pairs well with the selection of teas, balancing elegance and indulgence.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious tea and cake selection."

"Their cakes go great with tea or coffee."

"The cake set looks nice but tastes too sweet."

Good to know

1

There is a 1-hour seating time limit.

2

Reservations are necessary as you get kicked out after a certain time due to back-to-back bookings.

3

On weekends, a reservation is highly recommended due to limited seating.

27
The Walkers Espresso image 1
The Walkers Espresso image 2
The Walkers Espresso image 3
View all

Small coffee shop offers homemade pistachio cake and vegan treats. Artistic decor and nostalgic memorabilia create a warm family atmosphere. Cozy seating and calming music make it a community hub for locals.

Homemade cakes include a delicious pistachio cake and some vegan options. Cakes pair well with coffee and sandwiches.

People are saying

"I love the cozy vibe and tasty coffee and pastries."

"The owners are friendly and the art is amazing."

"I believe this place has one of the best flat whites in the city."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop has lots of gluten-free options available.

2

You can’t get the Turkish coffee to go, so plan on drinking it there.

3

The café offers great value for money and has a good selection.

28
Dante West Village image 1
Dante West Village image 2
Dante West Village image 3
View all

Bar features candlelit booths and live piano music for a cozy vibe. Outdoor seating offers a relaxed atmosphere away from street noise. Bartenders craft cocktails visibly, adding engaging energy. Flourless chocolate cake is slightly bitter, pairing well with drinks, while carrot cake is notably good.

Flourless chocolate cake offers a slightly bitter, not too sweet flavor and pairs well with cocktails. The carrot cake stands out as notably good, while tiramisu also appears on the menu.

People are saying

"I love the classic vibe and great drinks here."

"The cocktails were amazing and the atmosphere vibrant."

"I think the carrot cake is the best I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Making a reservation for Friday Martini Hour is highly recommended.

2

Martini hour is from 3 PM to 5 PM with $10 martinis.

3

Expect to wait for a seat if you don’t have a reservation.

29
Matchaful image 1
Matchaful image 2
Matchaful image 3
View all

Small space with zen interior creates a cozy vibe for matcha lovers. Unique cardamom rose cake offers floral flavor, while rich dark chocolate raspberry cake pairs well with lattes. Drinks use house-made plant milks and unrefined sweeteners for quality.

Cardamom rose cake offers a unique floral flavor. The Dark Chocolate Raspberry Heart Cake is rich and pairs well with a latte.

People are saying

"I can't get enough of their matcha drinks."

"I love the cozy vibe here."

"The matcha cake here is delicate and not bitter."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers house-made plant-based milk options like almond and coconut.

2

The total price for the iced Strawberry Omakase is $30.

3

The total price for the Vanilla Zen iced matcha and matcha donut is $18.

30
Tea & Sympathy image 1
Tea & Sympathy image 2
Tea & Sympathy image 3
View all

Cozy space with authentic British ambiance offers moist cakes and scones, including a spiced ginger cake with warm custard. Vintage decor adds charm while a greenhouse patio provides a quiet spot. Atmosphere feels both intimate and lively, perfect for a quaint tea experience.

Spiced ginger cake offers a warm, perfect spice level that fades with warm custard. Cakes, scones, and cupcakes come in a gorgeous array and taste moist and delicious.

People are saying

"The cakes and scones are moist and delicious."

"I still crave the sponge cake from here."

"I still crave their sponge cake."

Good to know

1

Reservations are definitely recommended due to limited seating.

2

The cost for an afternoon tea set is $60 per person.

3

Credit cards have an upcharge of 2%+, so use cash or debit.

Discover more

West Village, New York

Area guide