Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Wisconsin's best

Cookie shops

A cookie that is baked to perfection, not just a mass-produced circle of dough that tastes like every other grocery store treat.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Discourse Coffee | Downtown image 1
Discourse Coffee | Downtown image 2
Discourse Coffee | Downtown image 3
View all

Mid-century modern decor creates a cozy spot with window nooks perfect for quiet chats or study. Miso butter and chocolate chip cookies shine alongside a zesty orange latte. Warm lighting and an inclusive vibe make it a welcoming place despite varying music volume.

Miso butter and chocolate chip cookies stand out here. The orange latte pairs well with the cookies, making a solid combo.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was the best I've ever had."

"It's a cozy spot with a funky vibe and great decor."

"I loved the miso butter cookie."

Good to know

1

Discourse Coffee offers freshly roasted coffee beans for purchase.

2

The coffee menu features unique flavors and innovative combinations.

3

WiFi is unreliable, so consider using your mobile hotspot.

02
Edible Impressions image 1

Custom cookies boast intricate designs and a perfect sugar-to-butter ratio for great taste. Icing dries with a shiny finish, making treats both beautiful and delicious. Orders complete quickly, often on short notice, with easy decorating kits available.

Custom cookies arrive beautifully designed and impeccably packaged with a delicious taste. They add a branded touch to events and never arrive stale.

People are saying

"Annette and her team made the cookie decorating workshop so easy."

Good to know

1

The cookie decorating kits include icing, sprinkles, and eight cookies for decorating.

2

Orders typically ship within three days, ensuring timely delivery.

3

The decorating supplies are well-organized and easy to use.

03
Simply Cinnamon Bakery image 1

Warm aroma of freshly baked goods fills a small space with no indoor seating, perfect for quick visits. Cinnamon rolls and holiday cookies offer balanced sweetness and rich flavors. Rustic decor adds a cozy touch despite limited dining options.

Selection features cinnamon rolls, holiday cookies, and pumpkin spice treats. Cookies, bars, and flatbreads all taste delicious.

People are saying

"These cinnamon rolls have amazing frosting and aren't too dense."

"The hot ham and rolls were the best I've ever had."

"The cookies and treats here are delicious."

Good to know

1

To enjoy the Sunday ham, arrive early to avoid it selling out before noon.

2

Customers need to grab and go since there is no indoor seating available.

3

The cinnamon rolls are prepackaged and priced very reasonably.

04
Safadi Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Space blends traditional Palestinian decor with curated photography that highlights resilience. Cookies arrive fresh and warm, featuring macadamia nuts and chocolate chips for a rich taste. Calm atmosphere with sunlight and good music invites lingering and reflection.

Cookies come fresh and warm with macadamia nuts and chocolate chips standing out. They taste decadent and show no shortcuts in preparation.

People are saying

"The coffee shop's atmosphere is beautiful, cozy, and calming."

"Their specialty drinks are so unique, I wanted to try them all."

"The cookies here are warm, gooey, and amazing."

Good to know

1

Safadi Coffee closes at 9pm.

2

The menu features unique Palestinian-themed items.

3

The establishment is family-friendly and accommodating to children.

05
Avenue Coffeehouse image 1

Small coffee shop offers cozy seating and a charming patio for a peaceful vibe. Cookies are crispy-soft with some having sprinkled sugar. Unique touches like an axolotl fish tank and games add to the welcoming feel.

Cookies balance crispiness and softness well, making them enjoyable alongside coffee. Some have sprinkled sugar, which may not suit all tastes.

People are saying

"I thought their latte was the best I ever tried."

"This cafe's staff is super friendly and welcoming."

"I always got a cookie and they were perfect."

Good to know

1

They offer delightful drink specials and delicious toasts at the end of the week.

2

They now have a punch card program for free coffee or pastries.

3

There are lots of parking options available nearby.

06
Discourse Coffee | Radio Milwaukee image 1

Old industrial building with big windows fills space with natural light and a modern vibe. Brown butter miso cookie offers a sweet and savory twist, while music plays constantly, creating a creative, relaxed energy perfect for hanging out or working.

Brown butter miso cookie blends sweet and savory in a fun way, rated 4.5 out of 5. Bunny's bite chocolate lavender cookie offers a unique flavor, alongside almond croissant and bacon scone options.

People are saying

"The coffee drinks here are like delicious, innovative cocktails."

"The space and atmosphere here are really cool."

"The brown butter miso cookie's sweet and savory mix is so fun."

Good to know

1

Discourse Coffee offers an innovative menu of coffee cocktails worth trying.

2

Parking can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

3

They host community events and art showcases regularly.

07
Bread House | Mediterranean Bakery & More image 1

Rustic decor and cozy atmosphere invite casual dining with authentic Middle Eastern vibes. Warm, flavorful date and walnut cookies pair perfectly with fresh mint tea. Spacious seating adds comfort to this welcoming spot.

Cookies come warm and delicious with dates and walnuts flavors standing out. They hold up well for dipping into hot tea without falling apart and pair nicely with mint tea.

People are saying

"You have to try the honeycomb bread; it's phenomenal."

"The falafel with hummus and fluffy bread tasted amazing."

"I found the dessert and tea cookies to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Prices are very reasonable, making it a great value for money.

2

The bakery offers a large variety of vegetarian options, including falafel and eggplant.

3

Expect a family-friendly atmosphere, perfect for dining with kids.

08
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cozy shop offers top quality cookies with a delicious aroma. Pink kitchen adds a unique touch visible to customers. Clean space invites you to enjoy exceptional taste in every bite.

Cookies here stand out for their exceptional taste and consistent quality. Every cookie tried ranks among the best ever tasted, with no misses.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were delicious and fresh."

"It's so Kid Friendly; my kids loved the cookies."

"The takeout staff were very friendly and accommodating."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during special events like the birthday celebration.

2

Crumbl's cheesecake may not be properly refrigerated; check before ordering.

3

Ordering through the app is quick and convenient for pickup.

09
Wioletta's Polish Market image 1

Small grocery store offers authentic Polish deli and fresh bakery with pistachio pirouette cookies. Bright, clean, and quiet atmosphere feels like an old Polish neighborhood. Friendly environment highlights traditional foods and assorted kolache cookies.

Packaged pistachio pirouette wafer cookies stand out here. Assorted kolache cookies also come in good variety and quality.

People are saying

"This grocery store has authentic Eastern European foods and delicious kielbasa."

"I picked up fresh Polish sausage for holiday traditions."

"I was so excited they sell packaged pistachio pirouette wafer cookies."

Good to know

1

The store offers fresh bread on Wednesdays and Fridays.

2

Parking is limited, especially during peak hours.

3

The deli counter has a variety of authentic Polish meats.

10
North Shore Boulangerie image 1

Medium-sized bakery offers a cozy, Parisian cafe vibe with natural light and quiet seating. Ginger cookie shines with bold spice, matching the quality of amazing pastries. The space feels like a European spot with inviting energy and soft music.

Ginger cookie stands out with a strong, spicy flavor. Other cookies are delicious and match the quality of the amazing pastries.

People are saying

"I loved their French toast with raspberry spread for brunch."

"The bread here is out of this world, especially the sourdough."

"I thought the ginger cookie was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for brunch on weekends due to high demand.

2

The online menu may not accurately reflect current offerings or prices.

3

Parking can be challenging, so consider arriving early.

11
Holiday Inn Express & Suites Milwaukee - Brookfield by IHG image 1

Building features modern design with quiet rooms that have darkening shades for sleep. Guests enjoy fresh cookies in the lobby and a large breakfast area. Amenities include a pool, outdoor seating, and coffee in the lounge.

A cookie jar in the lobby stays filled with warm, fresh cookies including decadent double chocolate varieties offered free at check-in.

People are saying

"The hotel staff were so kind and accommodating during my stay."

"I found the breakfast here to be worth it and amazing."

"You can get warm, fresh cookies at check-in."

Good to know

1

The hotel is close to many attractions and restaurants.

2

Parking is safe and secure on the premises.

3

Rooms include a mini fridge, coffee K-cups, and a microwave.

12
Greige Pรขtisserie image 1

Bakery offers a quiet, European cafe vibe perfect for work or calls. Pastries shine with unique flavors and beautiful presentation. The oatmeal creme cookie stands out for its rich taste and texture.

Oatmeal creme cookie stands out with its captivating flavor and irresistible texture. Other pastries and cookies also offer delicious variety.

People are saying

"The wedding cake was perfect, with amazing flavors and beautiful presentation."

"The croissants here are so flaky and buttery."

"I was captivated by the oatmeal creme cookie; I couldn't stop eating it."

Good to know

1

Street parking is readily available on weekdays.

2

The closest bus stop is a 6-minute walk away for routes 15, green, and 18.

3

High tea costs $55 per person, which may not be worth it.

13
Poppy Bakery image 1

Open kitchen with viewing windows creates a cozy vibe. Cookies offer a crisp outside and chewy inside with caramelized sugar and vanilla. Seating is tight, adding to the lively, communal atmosphere.

Cookies have a delightfully crisp outside and a perfectly chewy inside. Flavors of caramelized sugar and vanilla come through, topped with flaky salt for extra texture.

People are saying

"The pastries and breads at this bakery are to die for."

"I thought their banana bread and cinnamon rolls were the best in the city."

"I thought their cookies were the best in the city."

Good to know

1

Expect a line, but it moves quickly and is worth the wait.

2

They sell out of popular items quickly, so arrive early.

3

The bakery closes at 2 pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

14
Kelly's Greens image 1
Cannabis store

Bright space offers gourmet cookies like red velvet and gluten-free CBD monster. Cozy seating and natural light create a welcoming atmosphere. Female-owned spot features a cannabis-infused drink bar for a unique, relaxing experience.

Cookies come in gourmet THC and CBD varieties, including a gluten-free CBD monster cookie. Flavors like red velvet, cornbread with orange frosting, and pecan pie stand out for their taste.

People are saying

"I loved the cookies; they were phenomenal and delicious."

"The High Tea was a fun and informative time with friends."

"It's a welcoming, cozy atmosphere with lots of natural light."

Good to know

1

Kelly's Greens offers a wide selection of cannabis products for all experience levels.

2

They host BYO ART nights for a creative and inclusive experience.

3

High Tea events are popular for socializing with friends; reservations are recommended.

15
Crave Cookies image 1
Cookie shop

Freshly baked cookies offer a gooey inside and crispy outside with real chocolate and butter. Cozy atmosphere invites dessert lovers to enjoy high-quality treats in a clean space. Elegant black and gold packaging adds a classy touch to every purchase.

Cookies come out moist and flavorful with a crispy outside and gooey inside texture. Ingredients taste fresh and high-quality, featuring real chocolate and butter in every bite.

People are saying

"I found the cookies to be fresh and crazy good."

"The cookies here are oversized compared to Crumbl."

"The bakery cookies are perfectly baked, gooey and delicious."

Good to know

1

The menu at Crave Cookies changes weekly, offering rotating flavors.

2

Every Friday, a new flavor of the week is introduced.

3

They offered free chocolate chip cookies for their grand opening.

16
Grebe's Bakery image 1

Small bakery with a classic American donut vibe and cozy feel. Known for Smile cookies with a long history and fresh, highly praised donuts. Family-owned since 1923, it offers quick-selling ham and rolls in a deli-style setup.

Smile cookies stand out with a long history of popularity. Other notable treats include Sentry cookies and hard rolls, all consistently enjoyable.

People are saying

"I thought the donuts here were amazing."

"The sandwiches here are super yummy and not greasy."

"I enjoyed their amazing smile cookies."

Good to know

1

Grebe's Bakery closes at 3:00 PM every day.

2

The bakery is usually busy, with a line forming by 7 AM.

3

Arrive early to get the best items, as they sell out quickly.

17
Lake Effect Coffee Company image 1

Coffee shop shines with fresh cookies like vegan and chocolate chunk. Calm, cozy vibe suits work or chats with fast Wi-Fi and a conference room. Bright space in an old theater offers natural light and quiet corners for reading or meetings.

Cookies come fresh from the bakery with options like vegan and chocolate chunk varieties. The chocolate chip and M&M cookies stand out for their rich flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was quite good."

"It's a great spot to get work done and catch up with friends."

"I found their chocolate chip cookie to be fantastic."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the street near the coffee shop.

2

The coffee shop closes at 2pm and is closed on Tuesdays.

3

Expect a lighter staff presence on Sundays due to church services.

18
Black Twig Bakery image 1

Bakery shines with flourless dark chocolate walnut cookies and light airy macarons made from fresh, high-quality ingredients. Casual, inviting atmosphere suits group treats, though orders need minimum quantities. Packaging highlights presentation, perfect for events.

Flourless dark chocolate walnut and chocolate chunk cookies stand out with rich flavors. Small plain butter cookies and frosted sandwich cookies add variety, while prices reach nearly $20 for four cookies.

People are saying

"This bakery's cookies and desserts are so delicious and tempting."

"These blondies are amazing, rich, and thick with chocolate chunks."

"I found the chocolate chunk and flourless dark chocolate walnut cookies amazing."

Good to know

1

The bakery requires a minimum order of two dozen for items not on the catering menu.

2

Parking can be tricky, but there are street spots available nearby.

3

GPS directions may be inaccurate; the bakery is located north of Harmonee.

19
Subway image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop shines with fresh baked cookies and soft, fresh bread. Spotless cleanliness and friendly, attentive service create a welcoming vibe. Outdoor seating with small tables adds a relaxed touch perfect for casual meals.

Fresh baked cookies come out consistently delicious and spot-on every time.

People are saying

"The staff here is so friendly and welcoming, it makes the sandwich experience great."

"The staff here is so friendly, they even knew my cookie order."

"The bread here is always so fresh and soft."

Good to know

1

The Subway location is known for its cleanliness and friendly service.

2

Expect a welcoming atmosphere with attentive staff.

3

The seating area is consistently clean and well-maintained.

20
DoubleTree by Hilton Milwaukee - Brookfield image 1

Hotel offers a quiet atmosphere with cozy beds and soft cotton linens. Guests enjoy warm pecan walnut cookies at check-in and check-out. The small indoor pool and hot tub are clean, and the gym has new workout machines in a tidy space.

Warm, fresh cookies greet guests at check-in and check-out. The pecan walnut chocolate chip cookie stands out as a yummy treat consistently offered by the front desk staff.

People are saying

"The hotel staff are fantastic and super nice."

"The beds here are so comfortable, you'll get a restful night's sleep."

"I loved the warm cookies they gave us at check-in."

Good to know

1

Breakfast costs $15 per person, which some guests find overpriced.

2

The hotel is clean and comfortable, with good pillows and mattresses.

3

Road construction may complicate access, but it's not a long-term issue.

21
Beach Bum Bakery image 1

Bakery blends beachy decor with custom cookie designs that delight both eyes and taste buds. Families enjoy the kid-friendly space and stunning lake views while savoring soft, flavorful cookies like salted caramel and p.b. cup.

Cookies come in custom designs that match specific visions and occasions. Varieties like kitchen sink, p.b. cup, and salted caramel are soft, tasty, and receive many compliments.

People are saying

"The bakery items, especially the donuts and cupcakes, are so delicious."

"The hot ham and rolls are a delicious Sunday bonus."

"I found the cookies delightful and they tasted great."

Good to know

1

Hot ham and fresh rolls are served on Sundays.

2

It's best to schedule orders ahead of time through the DoorDash app due to high demand.

3

Doughnuts are only available on Saturdays and Sundays.

22
Delicious Bites image 1

Cozy cafe offers Orange Dreamsicle cookies that kids love and can decorate in classes. It has a family-run feel supporting community and small businesses. Enjoy a quiet, peaceful atmosphere with street view seating and wifi, plus healthy, dairy-free options.

Cookies include Orange Dreamsicle and chocolate chip and pecan varieties. Kids enjoy the cookies and even participate in cookie decorating classes.

People are saying

"The staff here is so sweet and welcoming."

"The jerk salmon salad was so fresh and tasty."

"I loved the cheesecake jars, especially the Biscoff flavor."

Good to know

1

Delicious Bites offers catering services for events of various sizes.

2

The bakery provides dairy-free and vegan options for diverse dietary needs.

3

Expect beautifully packaged deliveries that arrive on time.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...