Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Sandwiches and gyros in Milwaukee

Choosing between a sandwich and a gyro is the only decision that matters today.

Based on 653 Opinions
+650
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
MKE Chicken and Gyro image 1
MKE Chicken and Gyro image 2
MKE Chicken and Gyro image 3
View all

Food truck offers New York style halal plates with juicy, perfectly spiced chicken and tender gyros. Atmosphere feels homey and welcoming, with friendly staff and generous portions. Vegetarian options are prepared separately to maintain quality and flavor.

Chicken sandwiches come with grilled chicken and appear as part of combo platters. Gyro sandwiches also feature prominently alongside chicken options.

Gyro meat cooks to perfection without being greasy and comes with generous white sauce or a flavorful spicy sauce. Mixed platters with gyro and chicken over rice offer a tasty combo with fresh vegetables.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and flavorful."

"The gyro here is so good, especially the white sauce."

"I thought the sandwich here was really good."

Good to know

1

The wait time is surprisingly short, around 5-8 minutes, considering everything is made fresh to order.

2

There are no tables to sit at; it's a food truck experience.

3

They provide a portion size that could even feed two people.

02
FiL FiL Mediterranean Grill image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Mediterranean grill with open kitchen where food is made in front of diners. Atmosphere stays quiet and relaxed with bright windows and vibrant walls creating a clean, modern, and welcoming space. It attracts those seeking an authentic, local vibe without constant waiter interruptions.

Gyro and chicken shawarma sandwiches stand out for their rich flavor and generous portions. Options like the Italian Philly and spicy sandwich add variety, all priced under $11.

Meat in the gyro is thinly sliced and perfectly seasoned, melting in your mouth without dryness. Portions are large, with fresh ingredients and great flavor throughout.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was the best I could ask for."

"I found the gyro meat to be the best I've ever had."

"The shawarma sandwiches were flavorful and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open late for late-night dining.

2

The portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

3

The prices are reasonable for the quality of food offered.

03
Pegasus Restaurant image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers a huge interior with cozy booths and colorful decor that feels traditional and classic. Atmosphere stays quiet and pleasant, welcoming locals who come for daily meals and social gatherings. Fish tanks and slot machines add unique touches to the setting.

Open face hot turkey and Monte Cristo sandwiches stand out with rich flavors. French dip comes with baked potato and chicken dumpling soup, while sandwich wraps and onion rings also appear alongside soup. Grilled chicken sandwich is decent but shows signs of oil quality issues.

Gyros come with rich meat and pair well with rice and salad. The platter and combo options offer a delicious meal experience.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious with good portions and reasonable prices."

"I thought the French dip sandwich with chicken dumpling soup was delicious."

"I loved getting the gyro platter here; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and seating is usually available within five minutes.

2

Online orders are only available through DoorDash; other sites are not connected.

3

The restaurant charges a $0.50 fee for containers and bags on takeout orders.

04
27th Steak & Potato image 1

Steak house offers a clean, beautifully remodeled interior with comfortable seating and friendly, welcoming atmosphere. Energy feels homey and relaxed, with great music enhancing the vibe. Small but well-kept space draws people who appreciate top-notch service and a unique dining experience.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with a fried chicken sandwich and a plain chicken option served with honey BBQ sauce. Steak sandwiches, including Italian beef and Philly steak, offer strong seasoning and solid flavor at prices competitive with chain restaurants.

Spicy and fresh gyros come with on point sauce that adds great flavor. Gyro fries topped with cheese sauce offer a unique and tasty twist.

People are saying

"The food here is phenomenal and top-tier."

"The chicken sandwich has two large, juicy fried tenders."

"I found the gyros here to be excellent."

Good to know

1

Everything is halal.

2

Call ahead to confirm if they are serving Zabiha Halal meat.

3

The restaurant is very clean.

05
The Fatty Patty®-92nd St (Food Truck) image 1

Food truck offers old-fashioned style with massive portions and affordable prices. Burgers stand out as best in the city, drawing steady crowds who appreciate fresh, quick service. Atmosphere feels casual and satisfying, focused on delivering great value and quality.

Chicken sandwich features two fried chicken breasts, lettuce, tomato, red onion, American cheese, pickles, and mayo. Burgers and chicken sandwiches stand out as favorites in the city with consistently good quality.

Gyros come in large portions, often as big as a head. The gyro burgers hold up well with consistent quality, sometimes served with an egg. The fries gyro stands out as absolutely delicious.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be always great."

"You get huge portions with this gyro, it's a great deal."

"I thought their chicken sandwich was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The food truck offers large portions at affordable prices.

2

Expect to pay less than a sit-down restaurant for great food.

3

Bring cash as electronic payment may not always work.

06
Sinbad’s Grill image 1
Mediterranean restaurant

Small Mediterranean restaurant with bright, clean atmosphere and counter ordering setup. Offers authentic Middle Eastern dishes like falafel and shawarma with generous portions. Maintains an unusually high level of cleanliness throughout.

Falafel sandwiches stand out with their freshness, taste, and filling quality. Philly Cheese Steak and gyro sandwiches also feature prominently, served with sides like cheese curds and fries.

Gyros come meaty and fresh, served in generous portions on plates or sandwiches. The Mediterranean flavors stand out, with shawarma and falafel also tasting delicious and fresh.

People are saying

"The Greek food here is so meaty and delicious."

"I found the gyros to be meaty and delicious."

"I found the falafel sandwich here to be amazing."

Good to know

1

All food is halal except for the gyros.

2

Expect small portion sizes, especially for salads and sides.

3

Prices are considered high for the portion sizes offered.

07
Oakland Gyros (Oakland Ave) image 1

Old building hosts a laid back and friendly atmosphere with good music and art enhancing the space. Busy late nights mix college students and community, creating a lively yet comfortable vibe. Dining area is clean and well-maintained with many tables and booths for seating.

Gyro sandwiches come with crispy well-done meat and generous portions that can fill multiple pitas. The combo offers a satisfying mix of flavors and plenty of meat for several sandwiches.

Gyros here have a fresh Greek taste and stay consistent over decades. The sandwiches come with authentic flavors and pair well with a fresh Greek salad.

People are saying

"I found the Greek food here to be the best gyros I've ever had."

"I found the gyros here to be the best I had across the country."

"You haven't truly experienced a gyro sandwich until you've had one here."

Good to know

1

Parking at Oakland Gyros can be challenging due to the busy intersection.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is recommended for quick service.

3

Expect larger serving sizes for a reasonable price compared to other places.

08
Shawarma House image 1
Middle Eastern restaurant

Middle Eastern restaurant offers a clean, bright interior with comfortable seating and pleasant lighting. The atmosphere feels welcoming and lively, enhanced by enjoyable background music that creates a warm vibe. The space balances a family-owned warmth with a quaint, fresh design.

Chicken shawarma sandwich stands out with fresh preparation and bold flavors. Other notable options include beef shawarma, chicken Zinger, and kefta kabob sandwiches, often paired with fries and falafel.

Gyros come in wedges, not thin frozen strips, offering a fresh texture. Plates are well-portioned and served hot, with meat that tastes spot on alongside pitas and hummus.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and fresh."

"I loved the spicy chicken sandwich; it was the best in Wisconsin."

"I thought the gyro was delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Today only, they are giving away free chicken and beef sandwiches.

2

There is no parking available near the restaurant.

3

The restaurant was closed when we arrived last minute.

09
Oakland Gyros on Layton image 1

Gyro restaurant with a comfortable hometown feel and quaint Greek music playing overhead creates a light and friendly atmosphere. The space features decorative grapes on the ceiling and a neat, clean dining area with a bit of wear. It stays lively and inviting, often busy with people enjoying generous portions.

Gyro sandwiches come loaded with meat and often need a side of feta cheese since it does not come inside. Chicken shishkebab sandwiches also appear on the menu and get ordered regularly.

Gyros here stand out for their top notch quality and best gyro sauce among local Greek spots. The gyro basket offers a satisfying, flavorful meal that sets a high standard for gyros in the area.

People are saying

"I thought the gyro meat was solid and the best I've ever had."

"This gyro platter is huge, easily enough for two meals."

"This gyro sandwich is loaded with plenty of meat."

Good to know

1

Portions are generous, often enough for leftovers.

2

Prices have increased by about $4 in the past three years.

3

The drive-thru service is convenient, especially in bad weather.

10
Gyro Palace image 1
Greek restaurant

Small fast food spot with a peaceful atmosphere and generous portions of high-quality gyros. Offers consistent, flavorful meat and large servings that stand out in the local scene. Seating area is simple and quiet, suited for quick bites rather than leisurely dining.

Gyro sandwiches come with a large meat portion, yummy peppers and onions, and big chunks of feta. Sandwiches are very big, include extra sauce, and often come with plenty of fries to share.

Gyros come with large portions packed with meat and extra sauce. The gyro supreme sandwich features big chunks of feta, peppers, and onions, making it a hearty choice.

People are saying

"The Greek food here has huge, delicious portions."

"The gyros here are huge, hot, and delicious."

"The sandwiches here are huge and stuffed with meat."

Good to know

1

They are open until midnight.

2

The portion size is huge and offers good value.

3

The prices at Gyro Palace are reasonable.

11
Kings Gyros image 1
Greek restaurant

Greek restaurant offers very clean space with a quiet atmosphere. Gyros receive consistent praise for being excellent and generous in portion. Menu repeats some items and prices tend to be on the higher side.

Gyro sandwich offers solid flavor with generous meat portions. Tomato slices tend to be the end pieces, which can affect texture.

Gyros come with great taste and generous portions. Staff are super friendly, and the food stays fresh and excellent every time.

People are saying

"The Greek food here, especially the gyros, is always fresh and delicious."

"I thought the gyro here was the best I had."

"I found the gyro sandwich I ordered to be really good."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $20 for a gyro combo with fries and a drink.

2

Toppings on burgers cost an extra $3.50.

3

Condiments are available only a la carte.

12
Gyros Stand image 1
Greek restaurant

Old, run-down space with a greasy spoon diner vibe and filthy interior sets a chill atmosphere for casual diners. Food includes generous gyros and notable Italian Beef, though some items show signs of overcooking or low quality. Prices are overpriced compared to the condition and offerings.

The burrito sandwich features seasoned beef, melty cheese, and fresh tomatoes that stand out. It includes fluffy rice, creamy guacamole, zesty salsa, and a warm, pliable tortilla wrapped tight with no leaks.

Gyros come with plenty of meat and hearty portions. The sauce stands out as the best in town, and options include chicken, lamb, and beef, all juicy and flavorful.

People are saying

"This burrito sandwich is basically everything a burrito sandwich should be."

"I thought the gyros here were the best I ever had."

"I thought the gyro here was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Credit card payments are currently unavailable due to a broken machine.

2

The establishment offers a secret menu item that is not widely advertised.

3

The restaurant lacks air conditioning, making it uncomfortable during hot days.

Discover more

Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...