Top 50 Gluten-Free Italian Havens Across Wisconsin

Erika Howle

Excellent food with robust gluten free options and the most adorable back garden patio! A definite must try!

Wade Avinger

If you are looking for an incredible dinner experience this is your place. The food is so good from the starters to dessert they make sure all details are taken care of. The service is amazing. The staff is very knowledgeable and does a great job of working with you to find the perfect dish for your enjoyment. The owners are very active and are fantastic. They are concerned with your dining experience and they engage with their patrons and get to know their customers. The pizza is so good and they use Italian imported 00 flour that those with gluten sensitivity can enjoy with no issues. The gluten free pasta is very good and I’m a huge fan of the carbonara. If you haven’t tried this amazing speakeasy with great music and old movies playing in the background to enhance your dining experience you have to get here - make sure you get a reservation before you come.

Marion Brown

We had our son's rehearsal dinner here on 5/30/25. Fabulous service for Mikayla and Lilly, as well as a side of humor from Jimmy.. The food and service five star. Bride is gluten free and they easily accommodated her dietary restrictions. We can't wait to go back!

Nova Sweeney

Pasta flights GF for parker

Gail Nusekabel

So happy to have several gluten free and vegan dishes to choose from; even a wonderful olive oil cake for dessert! Everything was delicious and fun cocktails!

Miranda Wise

Amazing place!! Gluten free menu at an Italian place is already rare, and for it to be this good and have such a great cocktail menu?! Incredible. And the service was phenomenal. Very attentive and when a mistake was made, it was owned and fixed 100%. Our new Italian go-to spot! Do not hesitate to check it out!

Francesca

Delicious food with great gluten free options.

Josie Jones

BEST gluten free pizza I have ever had. it is authentic Neapolitan pizza, just GF! Would highly recommend. 10/10 experience overall.

Peter Angelos

Great all around Italian-American food. Delicious gluten-free lasagna was a treat for me having Celiac concerns.

LaShay Esther

Gluten free pasta + other options on the menu! So good

Kathleen Konesko

Had lunch with my sister, watress checked to make things that I wanted were gluten-free.

Michael Gustafson

I was impressed with the service and all of the offerings. There were more gluten free options than 90% of the other restaurants I've been to. The food was excellent quality. Will definitely go back.

Mary Stutzman

We had our son's rehearsal dinner at Marty's. The staff there is top notch. The Waitresses did an excellent job of keeping drinks flowing, getting the food set up, and helping us pack up leftovers. The thing I most appreciated was that every time I called with a question, someone answered the phone and was always able to help me and answer my questions right away. I never had to wait for someone to call me back. We had a group of about 45 people and had to use a couple of the big booths for setting up the food. That was maybe a little awkward but we definitely made it work. They also have great gluten-free options which we took advantage of. Finally, my grandkids loved the arcade!! Thanks again for making our rehearsal dinner a huge success!

Leesa Krisak

Food was amazing!!!! Drinks too. The amount of food you get is good. They also have gluten friendly options. They were short staffed so it took a bit to get our food. They did keep checking wirh us

Tracy Heinen

This is our go-to place for pizza (both regular and gluten-free). We have always had great service, everyone there is very friendly. We also had our wedding rehearsal dinner here. Katie was very easy to work with. Our guests loved the food and were amazed by the great service. Keep in mind, this "great service" was on Friday fish fry night! Whenever our family from Texas is in town, we are required to go to Ricardo's.

Cheryl Thomack

Usuall their gluten free pizza is pretty good. I don't know if they changed who they get it from. This time I wasn't very good. Under cooked. And crust seemed thicker.

Olivia Komppa

Went last night and this place was amazing! The bruschetta with gluten free bread was so fresh and delicious. The Frellini spritzer was super tasty and the other spritzes were pretty tasty too. The Chicken Piccata, Chicken Parm, and Vodka Gnocchi dishes were all phenomenal! Then for dessert the Flourless Chocolate Cake, Salted Caramel Gelato, and Tiramisu were all soooo good.

Randi Huntsman

Despite my having told our server that I wanted the gluten-free flatbread, he brought out sandwich bread. He then put the correct order in, but I had to ask him to follow up. When he brought it, it had been baked too long. Also, the menus don't have GS notations to help me know what is safe for me to eat. I had to literally insist that the server check with the kitchen (in response to his "It should be fine" answer when I asked about the entree that I was considering). Not the best experience I've ever had at Cento.

Denise King

Very nice Unos! Reminded me of the one in Chicago I used to go to, just not as dark. Excellent gluten-free pizza. Make this stop a must!

Steph B

Amazing, friendly, attentive waitress named Kate. Best waitress I've had in a long time. Quiet place where you can sit and talk. Even gluten free options.

Laurie Nolan

Our group had three different pizzas including one gluten-free and they were all delicious. We were visiting the town and this place was recommended by a local. We ate the leftovers the next night.

Patricia Jackson

Table 65 Bistro is one of my favorite restaurants in New Richmond. They have a vast menu which can accommodate gluten-free and vegan patrons. I haven't eaten anything there that I haven't loved, and I've been there many times. There have been times where we've had to wait quite a while for the food, but then there have also been times where we were served almost immediately. Everyone is nice and to me, it's worth the wait, if there is one. The menu has a variety of price points and many options to choose from. Everyone should be able to find something they're satisfied with. Check them out!

Natalie Repinski

Service was great. Food, mediocre at best. Having celiac disease brought me to your restaurant for a celebration dinner with 6 others. The other 6 ate family style, I chose the gluten free Alfredo with chicken. The salad and appetizers were enjoyed. Then came my meal. Since all the others were between courses, I ate alone and was so extremely disappointed in the meal. Entirely bland, completely underwhelming. I didn’t eat 75% of my bowl. After I was done and so disappointed, their family style meal was served - again I watched them eat. Reviews were unanimous, Alfredo too bland, the stuffed shells and bolognese was good, lasagna fair. The amount of food served and boxed to take home was at least, if not more, than what was eaten at the table.

Matthew Foster

We went craving pizza, and left more than satisfied. The Chicago Meat Market deep dish pizzas we ordered were delicious, as was the gluten free pizza we also ordered. The waitress was happy, friendly, and efficient. The restaurant and bathrooms were clean as well. Solid pizza experience and would go again!

Katie Henry

Two words: pesto fries!!! Rustique is a huge go to for our family! I love the gluten free smokin pollo but I haven’t tried a pizza from here i haven’t loved yet! You can seriously never go wrong!

Hathaway Terry Pogue

The fantastic customer service and the attention given to folks with dietary restrictions is much appreciated! Bravo on the gluten free pizza crust.

Marie Perry

Fabulous service and great gluten-free options!

Robert Barry

Horrible, disrespectful older man server. Arguing about how drinks are made. Waited 15 min to order food. Only went there to get gluten free fish fry because my wife is a celiac. This experience will make us NEVER go there again.

Heather Puente

Great pizza & greek salad, including gluten free options. We went early around 4p to avoid wait times but the ovens are down for a period of time between lunch & dinner, so longer wait for food, which they did tell us upon arrival.

Bridgette Dolinsky

The hawaii pie o with gluten free crust was amazing! Highly recommend staff is very friendly

Deb Nutting

Had a gluten-free Grinder: delicious! Highly recommend. They also have gf pizza crust.

Tee Pridemore

Delicious gluten free pasta

Olivia Komppa

The website gives off one expectation and then showing up to dine, gives another. Based on the website alone I expected this to be a sophisticated eatery with tasty, unique menu items. In reality, it’s a typical diner/supper club. I did enjoy my burger with a gluten free bun & fries but my friend got the stir fry and the rice was very overcooked and mushy. I had asked for a box and my friend was finished with her stir fry, she only had a few bites due to the rice, and the waitress boxed up the stir fry but tossed my burger and fries… Waitress didn’t seem very attentive to detail or our table.

Rebekah

We ate on the patio on a Sunday evening and it was very nice. The service was excellent with pleasant waitstaff and the food was delicious. We ordered 2 Caesar salads to share, garlic bread, and two large pizzas to share amongst 6 adults. Plenty of food and leftovers! We had the Tomato Pie with added sausage, and the Figgy Piggy, both were great. We also had a person in our group with a gluten free diet. He was able to order and enjoy his own personal pizza as well. The prices are a bit high but really that's our only complaint.

Mari Enwright

WOW!! Healthy, delicious, mouthwatering gluten free, egg free, tomato free pizza! Sounds impossible right? It wasn’t at Valeos. Great variety of choices for the diy pizza. I appreciate how you helped us with our food allergies. Best pizza in town worth the extra money.

Amber Otter-Priem

We frequent the restaurant for carry out regularly but were going to a Brewers game for the shuttle and an appetizer ahead. Place was crowded and we were at a two person table without much room to move but didn’t need much more. World famous garlic bread and a Tomato & mozzarella Caprese salad were perfect before the game. Shuttle service to and from “Miller Park” easy and regular. Also highly recommend pizzas including gluten free!

J C

#glutenfree #gf this restaurant has a family friendly atmosphere and delicious, unique types of pizza. I highly recommend it

chris smolko

Thank you for the amazing service and good. Especially for someone with gluten allergy.

Lynette Rhodes

A busy but efficient pizza pub. We went for gluten free pizza and it was excellent and we didn't wait that long considering how many orders they had. Wish they had gluten free beer or hard cider.

Bob Christian

This is a more casual place but very nice and has great food with lots of gluten-free options. You do order at the bar and then they bring your food to your table, but it doesn't take away much from the experience.

Cherish Kroehnert

Wow! Gluten free options, wine and great atmosphere. Music is appreciated and aligns with my family values. Thank you to owner, staff and wait staff. Cherish K.

James Stanislawski

We had the Chicken Al Pietro which was simply amazing. The perfect amount of cream in the sauce combined with mushrooms cooked to absolute perfection and juicy grilled chicken breast that was bursting with flavor. Not to mention, we had the gluten free mostaccioli which was, in this reviewers humble opinion, even better than their normal mostaccioli. Our children had the spaghetti which they absolutely demolished. That’s Amore is a staple of the community that I hope will be around for many more years to come.

p kosko

Enjoyed the options for those with gluten issues and vegan or vegetarian.

Diane R

This food was so good! I have to be gluten free, and got the Ridotta with added chicken. The portion size was very generous! Good value for the money. The chicken was incredibly moist, tender- very delicious. The gluten free pasta was some of the best I've ever had. Cooked perfectly, the seasonings were flavorful. My mom got a crab salad sandwich and said it was also absolutely delicious. The food came out very promptly and the staff were very friendly and attentive. Dining out with food allergies and intolerances tends to be scary (or just down right impossible) most of the time, so places like this are really amazing!

Alyssa Heiden

I had the pasta and meatballs they have gluten free options as well loved the sauce on my pasta meatballs were fresh and delicious. I get a takeout pizza as well really good and also gluten free. Safe to say I left feeling full!

Kenzie Noel

Literally the best gluten free pizza I’ve ever had!!

Amelia Schuler

Beautiful location with indoor and outdoor dining areas. The food we ordered was very good, from the turbot to the salmon and the ravioli. Portion sizes were appropriate. Our server was amiable and attentive. We would come here again the next time we're in Appleton! Gluten free and vegetarian dishes are offered, though we didn't try any of them. Varied wine and beer menu. Nice dessert offerings—the Ciocolatto Fiorentino was just right.

Samantha Koenig

Love all the gluten free options!!

Pam Conley

I had my first order with them and I'm gluten free and had there glu free pizza OMG best pizza ever since I had the allergy ..I would recommend this to everyone that has the gluten free allergy

Valorie Sangsland

Tried gluten free crust for the first time this week. Pizza was great. Would have liked ability to order size larger than medium, but that was a minor inconvenience. Significantly more expensive, however.