Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the US

Sugar cookies and cake

A bakery that masters the precision of a layered cake while still baking sugar cookies that taste like they came from a home kitchen.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 1
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 2
Vanilla Sugar Bake Shoppe image 3
View all

Small bakery with warm, cozy atmosphere and friendly staff. Fresh cookies and pastries bake throughout the day, filling the air with rich, inviting scents. Known for beautiful, flavorful cookies that combine soft texture with perfect bake.

Cookie cake stands out with a rich, sweet flavor that captivates. A variety of decorated sugar cookies like cinnamon chai and sugar cookie with pumpkin buttercream offer diverse tastes and textures.

Adorable and delicious sugar cookies come personalized and decorated for events like baby and bridal showers. Kids enjoy the decorated sugar cookies and cookie cake, and these treats make popular gifts.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best chocolate chip cookie I've ever had."

"I tried the s'mores heart cake and it stole my heart."

"These sugar cookies are adorable and delicious."

Good to know

1

Vanilla Sugar offers a happy hour deal on cookies.

2

The bakery bakes cookies and pastries in smaller increments throughout the day to keep everything fresh.

3

This practice ensures they donโ€™t run out of popular items shortly after opening.

02
Gather Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an open, sunlit space and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Features a small kids play area that entertains children while adults enjoy fresh pastries and coffee. The environment feels friendly and relaxed, making it easy to linger and chat.

Chocolate eclair cake features crispy layers, cream, and chocolate in perfect balance. Croissants and cinnamon cake also appear alongside fantastic chocolate cake offerings.

Custom sugar cookies come decorated for events and gifts with a hungry caterpillar theme and other designs. Frosted sugar cookies taste just right, not too sweet, and pair well with croissants.

People are saying

"Their cookies are soft, flavorful, and absolutely to die for."

"I ordered custom sugar cookies that were darling and delicious."

"The chocolate eclair cake is insanely delicious."

Good to know

1

Gather Bakery offers cookie decorating events for all ages.

2

The bakery makes their products fresh daily.

3

Gather Bakery has vegan bread options available.

03
Simply Sweet Caroline's image 1

Custom cookies showcase exquisite decoration and detailed designs with vibrant colors and metallic accents. The atmosphere is friendly and professional, with a smooth ordering process and reliable service. Cookies are individually sealed, making them convenient for travel and special occasions.

Cookie cakes stand out with their amazing taste and adorable appearance. Guests often rave about their flavor, especially the sugar cookies and cookie cakes.

Sugar cookies come out delicious and perfect with a taste that stands out. They often become a family favorite and pair well with the cookie cake.

People are saying

"The cookies here are beautiful and delicious."

"These cookies are adorable and delicious, a real hit for kids."

"I thought the sugar cookies looked and tasted amazing."

Good to know

1

The ordering process is easy and smooth for custom cookies.

2

Caroline offers cookie designs that can match your event theme.

3

Cookies are individually sealed for convenient transport.

04
Bake It with Tina - Custom Cookies & Custom Cakes image 1

Custom cookie and cake shop operates from an in-home setup with no seating. Creations feature intricate designs and creative decorations that serve as edible art. The atmosphere centers on personalized, detailed craftsmanship with treats that are both beautiful and delicious.

Cakes feature gorgeous florals and creative custom designs that serve as stunning centerpieces. Flavors like lemon and cannoli taste fantastic and pair well with the beautiful decorations.

Custom sugar cookies come in perfect consistency and sweetness with detailed icing. They look great and suit celebrations like birthdays well.

People are saying

"These custom cookies are gorgeous and delicious!"

"This cake is gorgeous and tasted divine."

"These sugar cookies are works of art and delicious."

Good to know

1

Ordering and delivery from Bake It with Tina is easy and straightforward.

2

Custom cookie orders require at least one week's notice for best results.

3

All cookies are made fresh and can be customized to fit any theme.

05
Cake, Hope, & Love image 1

Quaint bakery with creative decorating and a sparkly, welcoming atmosphere. Offers fun classes and rents space for parties, creating a happy, fun environment. Cakes and pastries are beautifully detailed and flavorful, often featuring unique themes and flavors.

Custom cakes come out perfect with professional detail and taste as amazing as they look. Cakes and cupcakes suit birthdays and weddings, showing consistent quality and care.

Artfully decorated sugar cookies come in small sizes and match themes perfectly. Frosted versions feature buttercream and look tasty and beautiful.

People are saying

"The cakes here are beautiful and taste incredible."

"This bakery has delicious treats and kind, helpful staff."

"I thought the frosted sugar cookies were tasty and beautiful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special events like cupcake decorating parties.

2

The bakery hosts themed days throughout the year, including Star Wars and Ohio State.

3

Cupcake decorating classes are available for birthday parties and group events.

06
Luke's Custom Cakes image 1

Bakery with a nice building and air conditioning offers beautifully decorated cakes and superb quality desserts. Atmosphere lacks indoor seating, which affects comfort during cold weather. Popular for custom cakes that meet specific visions and occasions.

Custom cakes come with moist four layers and icing that is not overly sweet. Designs match inspiration photos closely, including themes like Frozen and Ohio State, with guests often praising the strawberry portion and overall taste.

Fruit topped sugar cookies stand out with their fresh fruit and sweet base. They offer a variety of sugar cookies alongside other desserts like pumpkin roll and lemon brownie.

People are saying

"I found the wedding cake to be gorgeous and delicious."

"I think these cupcakes are the best in the area."

"I've never had a better fruit pizza sugar cookie."

Good to know

1

Luke's Custom Cakes can fill orders within 24 hours for last-minute needs.

2

The bakery is closed on Sundays, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Parking on the street in front of the bakery can be difficult due to heavy traffic.

07
The Blessing Bakery image 1

Small bakery offers fresh breads and organic baked goods with a clean, friendly atmosphere. The space smells phenomenal and serves generous portions at excellent prices. Regulars enjoy French loaves, Italian bread, and Mexican sugar cookies made fresh daily.

Tres Leches Cake stands out with its moist, light texture and sweet flavor. Fresh strawberries accompany the red velvet cake, while the strawberry cake and conchas offer fresh, great-tasting options.

Sugar cookies come with red sprinkles and a Mexican style that stands out for its flavor.

People are saying

"I found the bread here to be the freshest and most delicious."

"I'll definitely be returning for this cake; it's my go-to spot."

"I thought the Mexican sugar cookies were wonderful and to die for."

Good to know

1

The bakery makes fresh baked goods every day.

2

Prices are considered the best in town.

3

French loaves are available fresh daily.

08
Cookie Society-Addison image 1

Freshly baked gourmet cookies fill the air with a rich aroma that sets a luxurious tone. The shop presents a chic, clean interior with stylish displays that highlight the variety of treats. The atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy, inviting visitors to savor some of the best cookies around.

Lemon pound cake stands out with a strong following, while the cookie cake impresses with its decoration and flavor. The creme Brule and King Cake also feature as notable specialties.

Frosted sugar cookies stand out with their soft texture and sweet glaze. Varieties include Mardi Gras King Cake Sugar Cookie and Crรจme Brรปlรฉe, offering unique twists on the classic sugar cookie.

People are saying

"These cookies are the best I've ever had."

"I fell in love with this cookie cake; it's amazing."

"These sugar cookies are hands down the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The cookie selections include a variety of flavors, with seasonal options available.

2

Limited edition flavors may only be available in-store, not online.

3

Expect to pay around $4.25 for a single cookie.

09
Moose & Me Baking Company image 1

Spacious bakery offers a calm, sensory-friendly atmosphere with gluten-free options and innovative cupcakes. Games and books create a welcoming space for children and families. Staff includes people with different abilities, supporting a mission of meaningful employment.

Cakes come soft and moist with great icing and detailed decoration. Delivery is reliable, handling heavy custom cakes for events like weddings and birthdays.

Sugar cookies come with detailed decoration and look beautifully decorated. They taste great and appeal even to those not usually fond of sugar cookies.

People are saying

"The cake was SO SO delicious and beautifully decorated."

"I found the cookies to be amazingly delicious."

"These sugar cookies are so yummy and pretty to look at."

Good to know

1

They offer custom cakes for special occasions with a variety of flavors.

2

Gluten-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The bakery hosts cookie decorating events for groups and parties.

10
CaseBakes Cookies image 1

Bakery offers adorable decor and custom sugar cookies that match any theme. Atmosphere feels personalized and creative, with treats that look as good as they taste. Delivery is reliable, with cute packaging ensuring cookies arrive intact.

Cakes come with beautiful decoration and a great taste. Options include cookie cake slices at a decent price and various treats like cupcakes and brownies.

Custom sugar cookies come in many designs, including themed ones like Astros for birthdays. Options include iced designs and goodie boxes with a variety of treats featuring sugar cookies.

People are saying

"These cookies are so yummy and delicious."

"The cake was beautifully decorated and tasted great."

"You have to try CaseBakes Sugar Cookies!"

Good to know

1

Cookies are shipped on Tuesdays and typically arrive within two days.

2

Consider using expedited shipping during warmer months to prevent melting.

3

Cookies are packaged with bubble wrap and tissue paper for protection.

11
Crumbl image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers a clean and bright environment with a strong fresh cookie smell. The atmosphere feels welcoming and cute, often busy with people. Weekly changing cookie flavors add a unique variety to the experience.

Tres leches cake stands out with its rich, moist texture. Mini cakes and cookies like raspberry butter cake and pumpkin caramel cake offer a sweet, gooey experience with excellent icings.

Pink sugar cookies return weekly with a gooey butter cake vibe in some versions. Sugar cookies sometimes carry a peanut butter flavor twist.

People are saying

"I thought the cookies here were really good and fresh."

"I loved all the cookies; they were delicious."

"I loved the pink sugar cookie."

Good to know

1

Crumbl offers new cookie options every week.

2

Online ordering is fast and easy through their app.

3

Curbside pickup is quick and convenient.

12
My Sweet Obsession Cookies & Cakes - MSO Cookies & Cakes image 1

Custom cookies and cakes stand out for their beautiful decoration and exceptional taste. The bakery maintains a reliable shipping process, delivering delicate items intact over long distances. Pricing remains reasonable, making it a popular choice for special occasions.

Custom cookie cakes and funfetti cake with buttercream icing stand out for their taste and presentation. Cakes consistently turn out delicious and exactly as envisioned, making them popular for special occasions.

Decorated sugar cookies look beautiful but have an overwhelming artificial-alcohol-like flavor. Other sugar cookies taste good and are enjoyed at parties.

People are saying

"These cookies are so delicious and beautifully decorated."

"The cake here is so delicious and beautifully decorated."

"I ordered sugar cookies for my son's birthday party and everyone loved them."

Good to know

1

Custom cookie orders can be placed easily through their website.

2

Pricing for custom cookies is reasonable and worth the quality.

3

The bakery ships cookies nationwide, ensuring they arrive intact.

13
The Bearded Baker image 1

Cookie shop offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere with a quiet ambiance. Customers find the fresh baked cookies and brownies delicious, especially the sugar cookies and oatmeal cream pie. The shop features beautifully detailed cookies with a limited but creative selection.

Chocolate cake stands out as moist, rich, and full of flavor. Tiny cakes offer a neat gift option, while refrigerated cakes rate average in taste.

Soft texture and fresh taste define the sugar cookies here. They come out yummy and excellent, standing out even among other well-known options.

People are saying

"These cookies are beautiful and delicious."

"I thought the cookies were pretty tasty."

"I thought the sugar cookies here were the best."

Good to know

1

Walk-in orders are available, but selection may be limited.

2

Custom orders require at least three months' notice for fulfillment.

3

Prices for cookies are around $20 for a dozen, which some find high.

14
Eileen's Colossal Cookies image 1

Cookie shop offers wide variety of large, soft sugar cookies with decorated seasonal options. Atmosphere suits quick visits for pickup with upfront pricing and reliable timing. Cookies receive consistent praise for balanced sweetness and quality.

Cookie cakes feature full frosting and custom designs. Some orders have color and frosting errors, and taste can vary between batches. Kids often favor the cookie cakes for their delicious cookies.

Large, soft sugar cookies come frosted and decorated with many options. The frosted sugar cookies stand out as affordable and delightful treats.

People are saying

"These cookies are delicious and amazing."

"These frosted sugar cookies are the best I've ever had."

"I loved the cookie cake; it was so good!"

Good to know

1

Eileen's Colossal Cookies offers a wide variety of cookie flavors.

2

Special orders can be placed for events and holidays.

3

Cookies are ready for pickup right on time.

15
Maryโ€™s Mountain Cookies image 1

Shop offers diverse cookie flavors including unique and exotic options with edible cookie dough and frozen treats available. Atmosphere feels welcoming and clean with a vibrant display of cookies. Pricing is fair, especially with promotions like buy four get two free.

Cookie cakes come out exactly as requested, fitting occasions like birthdays and baby showers. They taste delicious and can be made on short notice.

Soft texture and fresh taste define the sugar cookies here. The iced sugar cookie stands out with its smooth icing frosting.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing and worth trying."

"I ordered a personalized cookie cake for a birthday celebration."

"I found the sugar cookies to be very soft and fresh."

Good to know

1

Maryโ€™s Mountain Cookies offers a buy 4 get 2 free promotion on cookies.

2

Cookies cost around $4-5 each, which is reasonable for their size.

3

The shop features a constantly rotating menu of unique cookie flavors.

16
J.Rae's Dallas image 1

Bakery offers freshly baked goods with a wide selection of cookies and cupcakes that impress. Atmosphere feels warm and caring, reflecting passion in every item. Known for rich cheesecakes and top-tier sweets that bring joy to many.

Carrot cake and red velvet stand out as favorite flavors. Cake pops and white chocolate cheesecake offer rich, flavorful options. Cake balls come in assorted flavors that invite tasting and guessing.

Sugar cookies come out thick and doughy with a strong almond extract flavor. They look beautiful and stand out for their rich texture.

People are saying

"I found this bakery to be top tier and amazing."

"I thought the cheesecake was the best I've ever had."

"I thought the sugar cookies were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers a wide selection of cookies and cupcakes.

2

Prices at this bakery are competitive compared to others in the area.

3

There are no ingredient labels on the cookies, so ask staff for details.

17
Memorial Bakery image 1

Spacious bakery with beautiful decorations and a gorgeous display creates an inviting atmosphere. The air carries a mix of freshly baked goods and a cozy, homey scent. Known for delicious cakes and sugar cookies, it attracts those seeking quality desserts for special occasions.

Cakes here come out exactly as pictured and taste even better than they look. They offer custom designs for birthdays and weddings with a balance of sweetness without overwhelming flavors.

Sugar cookies show a mix of qualities here. Some batches have great flavor and appealing appearance, while others turn out stale and dried out.

People are saying

"I thought the cake was the very best I had ever tasted."

"They designed custom cookies that fully executed my vision."

"I thought the sugar cookies here were the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for wedding cakes as dates fill up quickly.

2

Pricing is slightly higher than average due to the bakery's upscale location.

3

The ordering process is simple and quick, ensuring a smooth experience.

18
Sweet Mandy B's Bakery image 1

Cozy bakery with an authentic interior and a relaxed atmosphere that feels like home. Known for famous cupcakes and a varied selection including vegan options, it draws families and casual visitors alike. The space is smaller and less trendy, focusing on simple, honest baked goods.

Cakes here are moist and flavorful, especially the devilโ€™s food and chocolate varieties. Custom cakes like birthday and wedding cakes come out visually appealing and delicious, often creating lasting memories.

Confetti and sugar cookies come out soft and sweet, with the confetti ones standing out as divine. The iced sugar cookie offers a different take, but it does not taste like a traditional sugar cookie.

People are saying

"I thought the devil's food cake was the best cake I ever had."

"It's a calm, comforting place that feels like home."

"I enjoyed their divine sugar cookies."

Good to know

1

The bakery offers vegan options for those with dietary restrictions.

2

Prices for baked goods are not clearly marked, so ask before ordering.

3

The bakery is open seven days a week for your convenience.

19
Blondie's Cookies image 1

Cookie shop offers fresh, delicious cookies with a welcoming atmosphere and great energy. The space feels cute and lively, drawing a steady flow of customers who appreciate the quality and variety. Staff bring consistent enthusiasm, enhancing the overall vibe.

Cookie cakes come out quickly and are decorated nicely. Staff like Marcus and Teesha handle last-minute orders with ease, making cakes that look amazing and taste delicious.

Sugar cookies come with icing and sugar sprinkles that add texture and sweetness. Some cookies may be undercooked, but the icing helps balance the flavor and texture.

People are saying

"The cookies here are soft and baked fresh every morning."

"The staff at this Mall are always so friendly."

"I loved the sugar cookies with icing and sugar sprinkles."

Good to know

1

Prices for cookies are not clearly displayed, which may lead to unexpected costs.

2

The store offers a promotion: buy 6 cookies and get 1 free.

3

Customer service experiences may vary; some report better treatment than others.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...