Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Key lime pie

A slice of key lime pie that hits the right balance of tart and sweet without being masked by excessive whipped cream.

Based on 739 Opinions
+736
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 1
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 2
Juan Dulce Desserts LLC image 3
View all
Dessert restaurant

Cozy space with warm energy feels like home. Chef Juan's fresh key lime pie balances tart and sweet perfectly. Clean, pretty setting invites friendly chats and enjoying high-quality desserts.

Key lime pie here balances tart lime flavor with a sweet topping that does not overpower. Chef Juan makes it fresh alongside other desserts like Flan de Coco and Peach Almond Tart.

People are saying

"I found the desserts here to be the most delicious I ever had."

"The hot chocolate here is rich, smooth, and creamy."

"I've never had a Key Lime Pie this delicious with such a real lime taste."

Good to know

1

Everything is made fresh daily at Juan Dulce Desserts.

2

There are limited vegan dessert options available.

3

They offer catering services for events and parties.

02
La Cañita Beach image 1
Cuban restaurant

Open air patio and authentic Cuban live music create a vibrant vibe. Guests savor phenomenal cocktails and excellent Cuban food. The decadent key lime pie with homemade crust is a standout dessert.

Decadent with an amazing homemade crust, the pie balances lime flavor without being overbearing. It stands out as a delicious dessert often praised for its taste.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, especially the croquettes."

"The live music here adds to the amazing atmosphere."

"The Key Lime Pie here is decadent with an amazing homemade crust."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-7pm on weekdays with great food and drink specials.

2

Live music is featured during happy hour, enhancing the dining experience.

3

Reservations are recommended for dinner service to avoid long wait times.

03
Rustic Pizza Since 1991 image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy spot with handmade thin crust pizzas offers a chill vibe for families and couples. Outdoor seating enhances the relaxed feel. Don't miss the homemade Key Lime Pie with its perfect tart and creamy balance.

A perfect balance of tartness and creaminess defines the Key Lime Pie here. It features a homemade style that stands out for its flavor.

People are saying

"I believed this pizza was the best in Miami."

"I tried their Key Lime Pie; it was to die for."

"I tried the Key Lime Pie; it was one of the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The pizza is handmade with high-quality ingredients.

2

Prices are very affordable compared to pizza chains.

3

The restaurant has an extensive menu beyond just pizza.

04
Novella Wine Bar image 1

Wine bar features a cozy interior and a quiet atmosphere perfect for intimate evenings. Unique European wine selection complements the homemade key lime pie, which offers a fresh tartness and creamy texture.

Homemade slices stand out with a fresh tartness and creamy texture. The pie balances sweetness and acidity well, making it a notable dessert choice.

People are saying

"The wine selection here is so interesting and delicious."

"The outdoor seating here is a beautiful patio."

"I tasted the best homemade key lime pie."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks.

2

The wine bar offers a diverse selection of European wines.

3

Vegetarian and gluten-free options are available on the menu.

05
Blue Claw Seafood Market image 1

Seafood market offers super fresh sushi grade fish like local tuna and sea bass. Homemade key lime pie delivers a fresh, tangy flavor and freezes well. Clean, vibrant atmosphere with a young, friendly staff makes it a great spot for quality seafood and dessert.

Homemade key lime pie stands out with a fresh, tangy flavor. It freezes well, keeping its creamy texture intact.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh and tastes amazing."

"You have to try the homemade Key Lime Pie; it's the best I've ever tasted."

"I think the owner/operator should be nicer to the staff."

Good to know

1

Blue Claw Seafood Market offers a diverse array of super fresh, sushi-grade seafood.

2

The prices at Blue Claw Seafood Market are fair and reasonable for the quality offered.

3

Blue Claw Seafood Market is one of the last two good fish markets on the island.

06
DeFeo's Farm & Garden Market image 1

Roadside market offers fresh produce and homemade bakery items with a clean, welcoming vibe. Key Lime Pie stands out for its tangy flavor and creamy texture, making it a popular treat. Prices stay reasonable, attracting both locals and travelers.

Slices of Key Lime Pie come with a strong, tangy flavor and a creamy texture. Many buy extra because of its amazing taste and satisfying balance.

People are saying

"I thought the apple cider donuts here were delicious."

"I thought the kimchi here was the best I've ever had."

"I thought their Key Lime Pie was amazing."

Good to know

1

The market sells fresh produce, including NJ blueberries in season.

2

Check out their freezer case for frozen donuts at half price.

3

They offer unique finds like kimchi and frozen homemade dumplings.

07
Backbone image 1
New American restaurant

Sleek, modern space with open kitchen sets a cozy, intimate vibe perfect for date nights. Warm lighting and thoughtful touches keep the atmosphere relaxed and inviting. The deconstructed key lime pie offers a fresh, inventive twist on a classic dessert.

A reimagined key lime pie crafted by the pastry chef stands out with its deconstructed presentation and inventive approach. This version offers a fresh take on the classic dessert with pure genius in its execution.

People are saying

"The food here is wonderful, with attention to detail in every bite."

"This key lime pie is the best I've ever had."

"I thought the key lime pie was the best I had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially on weekends.

2

Free street parking is available nearby.

3

The menu features a blend of traditional French cuisine and seasonal California ingredients.

08
Ben The Baker LLC image 1

Small take-out pie shop offers large portions with fresh, real ingredients and gluten-free options. Key lime pie shines with a perfect balance of tart and sweet, making it a special treat. Warm, welcoming atmosphere adds a personal touch.

Key lime pie here stands out for its perfect balance of tart and sweet flavors. It comes as a full pie or slices, consistently described as transcendent and a special treat.

People are saying

"Every pie I tried was fantastic and delicious."

"I dreamed about the lemon curd cheesecake."

"I've never had a Key Lime Pie this good; it was perfection."

Good to know

1

Ben The Baker LLC is a take-out only place with no dine-in options.

2

Pre-orders are recommended to ensure availability of your favorite pies.

3

The bakery offers a variety of sweet and savory pies.

09
Heather’s Pies image 1

Pie shop crafts perfectly balanced flavors with fresh fillings and crunchy crusts that last days. Key lime pie shines with balanced tartness and is a favorite for birthdays. Demand is high, so ordering ahead is wise.

Key lime pie has a perfectly balanced flavor, not too tart or sweet. It looks beautiful and is often chosen for birthdays, praised as the best ever tasted by many.

People are saying

"I thought the key lime pie was the best I'd ever tasted."

"I thought this Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Ordering ahead is recommended for any occasion to ensure availability.

2

Heather opens on Sunday mornings for pickups, despite being normally closed.

3

Heather informs customers on Friday if she is completely booked up.

10
First Slice Pie Cafe image 1

Pie shop offers a cozy atmosphere with both indoor and outdoor seating, though the patio can be noisy. Key lime pie is creamy but soft, standing out among other desserts. Large, affordable pies and a steady local crowd make it a popular spot.

Key lime pie features a creamy texture but can lack firmness compared to typical versions. It stands out among other desserts like blueberry cheesecake and chocolate cream pie.

People are saying

"I loved the flavorful chicken and blue cheese sandwich."

"I found the Latin hip hop salad with chicken amazing."

"I found the Key Lime Pie delicious."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers both indoor and outdoor seating for guests.

2

The bathroom is located next to the back door, through the kitchen.

3

Pies are large for the price, making them a good value.

11
The Net Shed image 1
Restaurant

Waterfront spot shines with spectacular marina views and a lively vibe. Fresh seafood draws families and casual diners to its community feel. Don't miss the bright key lime pie bar with creamy texture and amazing flavor.

Light and refreshing, the key lime pie bar stands out with its bright flavor. The pie in a jar offers a creamy, amazing texture that complements the excellent taste found across all versions.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here are exquisite, hot, flavorful, and crispy."

"I had the best lobster roll of my life here."

"The key lime pie here is amazing."

Good to know

1

You order at the counter and receive a number to bring to your seat.

2

Food is delivered to your table after ordering at the counter.

3

Parking at The Net Shed is easy and accessible.

12
Capt'n Chucky's Crab Cake Co. Ocean City, NJ image 1

Seafood market shines with fresh crab cakes and outstanding shrimp in a clean, simple setting. Key lime pie offers a fantastic flavor that complements seafood perfectly. Clear cooking tips and fair prices make takeaway easy and reliable.

Key lime pie stands out with a fantastic flavor and consistent quality. It pairs well with seafood dishes like crab cakes and jumbo shrimp.

People are saying

"I thought the crab cakes were the best, with no fillers."

"I thought the food was amazing and delicious."

"I found the key lime pie to be fantastic."

Good to know

1

The prices for crab cakes are reasonable and competitive.

2

They offer a variety of fresh seafood options for takeaway.

3

Cooking instructions for prepared seafood are provided with purchases.

13
Cait's Key Lime image 1

Online bakery crafts small-batch key lime pies with a perfect lime taste and balanced cream. Pies are gluten-free and nut-free, focusing on fresh ingredients and lasting quality. Tart and creamy flavors blend without excess sweetness.

Offers a perfect lime taste with well balanced, light, and refreshing cream. The pie is consistently delicious and not too sweet.

People are saying

"I thought this Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever had."

"I thought Cait's key lime pie was the best dessert I ever had."

"I thought the gluten-free key lime pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Cait's Key Lime is an online business; follow their Instagram for updates.

2

The pie comes with a gluten-free crust option and is nut-free.

3

I recommend visiting Cait's website to order some pie.

14
Chowder Bar image 1
Seafood restaurant

Tiny shack on the waterfront offers a cozy, quiet vibe with nautical decor perfect for families. Local seafood shines in a casual, no-frills setting. Key lime pie features a creamy filling and a crispy graham cracker crust that balances tartness and texture.

Creamy filling with a strong lime taste stands out in the key lime pie. The brown and crispy graham cracker crust adds a nice texture contrast.

People are saying

"I thought the New England clam chowder was the best I've ever had."

"I found the place to be cozy and quiet."

"I believed their Key Lime Pie was the best in the world."

Good to know

1

Both Nicky's Clam and Chowder Bars have opening day specials on March 1.

2

Parking in the back is very convenient.

3

Chowder Bar is pet-friendly and has a bowl outside for dogs.

15
Pop's Fish Market image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market shines with exceptionally fresh fish including rare Barrel fish. Gluten-free Key Lime Pie tastes delicious alongside house-made desserts. Clean atmosphere and friendly service make it a top spot for quality seafood and sweet treats.

Gluten-free Key Lime Pie options exist and taste delicious. The pie stands out alongside other house-made desserts like apple pies.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be incredibly fresh."

"You've got to try the fresh local catch here; it's incredible."

"You have to try the Key Lime pie; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

The market offers a wide selection of fresh fish, shellfish, and lobster.

2

Parking is ample and easily accessible for customers.

3

Expect reasonable prices for high-quality seafood and house-made sides.

16
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Arlington image 1

Pie shop buzzes with freshly baked pies and energetic staff. Key lime pie shines with perfect cream topping and balanced tartness. Limited crust adds subtle crunch. No seating, so grab your pie to go or enjoy quick delivery.

The key lime pie features a perfect cream topping and a balanced tartness that is not overwhelming. The crust is present but could be more generous, complementing the delicious, classic flavor.

People are saying

"The pies here are rich, buttery, and perfectly balanced."

"The food here is a dream come true, made from scratch."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was delicious and great."

Good to know

1

The pies are made fresh daily, but limited quantities may sell out quickly.

2

Pies are priced at $6 each, which may be considered pricey for their size.

3

In-house delivery is available, making it easy to enjoy pies at home.

17
Fookem's Fabulous image 1

Small booth with only three seats offers homemade pies known for their silky smooth texture and tropical flavors. Key lime pies shine with unique mini variations priced reasonably at $6.50. Pies sell out fast, showing strong demand and a groovy vibe despite limited space.

Offers an amazing selection of key lime pies including unique mini variations priced at $6.50 each. The pies stand out for their delicious taste and reasonable prices.

People are saying

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I had ever tasted."

"This Local Spot's key lime pie is creamy, citrusy, and has a buttery crust."

"I thought the food here was really good."

Good to know

1

There are only three seats available to eat at Fookem's Fabulous.

2

It is advisable to place an order ahead of time to try different flavors.

3

Fookem's Fabulous accepts both cash and card.

18
Le Cafe In image 1

Cozy cafe offers a serene atmosphere perfect for work or casual visits. Enjoy bright, tangy Key lime pie alongside breakfast favorites like croissants with bacon, egg, and cheese. Pet-friendly seating and beautiful views add to the inviting charm.

Slices of Key lime pie come with a bright, tangy flavor that pairs well with drinks like matcha. It appears alongside breakfast items like croissants with bacon, egg, and cheese.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing, and the staff makes you feel right at home."

"Their truffle egg croissant is one of a kind."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Le Cafe In is dog-friendly, allowing pets in the outdoor seating area.

2

The cafe offers free wifi, making it a good spot for working.

3

Parking can be packed, so arrive early to secure a spot.

19
Garbo's image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small seafood spot shines with top-notch lobster rolls and a maritime vibe that feels cozy despite traffic noise. Rich, tangy key lime pie rivals Florida Keys quality. Casual outdoor seating adds to its intimate dining charm.

Rich, tangy flavor defines the key lime pie here. It holds up well to go and matches the quality found in the Florida Keys.

People are saying

"I craved their satisfying lobster roll; it was the best I've ever had."

"I loved the frozen lemonade here."

"The Key Lime Pie here is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Garbo's features specials like fish and chips on Tuesdays.

2

The lobster rolls are pricey, with the Maine roll costing $30.

3

They have a mini roll flight on Monday, allowing sampling of three different styles.

20
Fishmonger image 1
Seafood restaurant

Small seafood spot shines with a dog friendly patio and a casual vacation vibe. Tart and smooth key lime pie with a crumbly crust ends meals perfectly. Cramped but comfy seating adds to the chill, fun energy.

Tartness and smoothness define the key lime pie here, paired with a crumbly crust that finishes meals well.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh and flavorful."

"The fish here is amazing, especially the spicy hot fish sandwich."

"The Key Lime Pie here is the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Fishmonger does not accept reservations, so arrive early to secure a table.

2

Expect a decent wait during peak mealtime due to limited seating.

3

The restaurant includes an automatic 18% gratuity on all bills.

21
Fat + Flour image 1

Spacious bakery offers a cozy vibe with butter aroma and food art. Key lime pie shines with tangy lime flavor and a golden crust. Pleasant spot to enjoy excellent pies and browse kitchen items.

A slice of sunlight with whipped cream peaks and a tangy lime flavor balanced by a golden crust. The pie stays perfectly balanced, not too tart or too sweet.

People are saying

"You have to try the pies; the crust is exceptionally good."

"The Basque Pistachio Cheesecake was a revelation, truly the best I ever had."

"The Key Lime Pie is perfectly balanced, not too tart nor too sweet."

Good to know

1

Fat + Flour has limited indoor seating.

2

This place does not accept cash due to a recent burglary.

3

There is metered parking available out front.

22
ONE11 Bar & Kitchen image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant buzzes with live music and big screens for sports. Outdoor patio welcomes dogs in a comfy space with a fresh, clean design. Key lime pie shines with a smooth, silky texture and perfect tart-sweet balance.

Smooth and silky texture defines the key lime pie here. It delivers a perfect balance of tart and sweet that rivals authentic versions from Key West.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always on point."

"The cocktails here are creative, unexpected, and delicious."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was amazing."

Good to know

1

Live music and DJ performances happen every Friday and Saturday night.

2

Wine specials are available on Wednesdays.

3

Salsa lessons are offered on Thursdays.

23
Luc’s Seafood & Grill image 1
Seafood restaurant

Cozy bistro offers intimate atmosphere with friendly vibe and outdoor seating. Seafood shines with fresh flavors. Dessert highlights a perfectly tart Key Lime Pie made in-house, balancing sweet and tangy.

Dessert features a perfectly tart Key Lime Pie made in-house. It stands out alongside other delicious sweets like chocolate mousse and bread pudding.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, I had one of the best pastas ever."

"I thought the jambalaya here was amazing."

"The Key Lime Pie had just the right zing and was perfectly tart."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $9 appetizers and discounted drinks on weekdays.

2

New specials are available every week during happy hour.

3

Happy hour appetizers are a good size for sharing.

24
Big Ed's BBQ image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Huge, clean space with a cafeteria-style dining area offers a casual vibe. Homemade Key lime pie shines with silky, decadent texture and great taste. Live jazz and a full bar create a lively atmosphere perfect for relaxing on comfy couches.

Homemade Key lime pie offers a delicious texture and excellent taste with a silky, decadent feel. It rivals well-known versions from Florida and stands out for its appealing appearance.

People are saying

"You have to try the brisket; it's some of the best American food around."

"I loved the key lime pie; it was divine and heavenly."

"The cheddar mashed potatoes were amazing."

Good to know

1

Arrive early to avoid missing out on menu items as they sell out quickly.

2

Free meals are offered on Thanksgiving Day, making it a popular time to visit.

3

Some menu items are only available on specific days, so check ahead.

25
Key West Bistro image 1
Coffee shop

Small space with a Cuban motif creates a warm, cozy vibe perfect for hanging out. Music adds a fun, chill atmosphere like a Florida cafe. Owner-baked Key Lime Pie shines with authentic, balanced flavor loved by all.

Baked on site by the talented owner, the Key Lime Pie offers a perfectly balanced and authentic flavor. It consistently impresses with its fantastic taste and is a hit among family and friends.

People are saying

"I found the Cubano sandwich to be amazing and authentic."

"I found the Cuban coffee here to be authentic and well-made."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was fantastic and perfectly balanced."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and walk-ins are welcome.

2

The cafe offers a limited selection of gluten-free options.

3

Online ordering is available for quick pickups.

26
Andy's Frozen Custard image 1

Outdoor setup with retro Americana style offers a casual, kid-friendly vibe. Drive-thru adds convenience while limited seating keeps it cozy. Frozen custard shines with key lime pie flavor, a scrumptious treat many eagerly await.

The key lime pie concrete offers a scrumptious and consistently reliable flavor. It appears as a limited offer that many look forward to regularly.

People are saying

"It's so kid friendly; my kids loved watching the custard get made."

"The drive-thru line was so long, I walked up instead."

"I was excited to find out their Key Lime Pie concrete was quite scrumptious."

Good to know

1

Expect limited outdoor seating, especially during peak hours.

2

Coupons can be used, and two $5 off coupons are accepted simultaneously.

3

Prices are reasonable, with generous servings for the cost.

27
Gregory's Gourmet Desserts image 1

Small shop buzzes with wall-to-wall sweets and a strong dessert aroma. Key Lime Pie shines with bright, tangy flavor and a crisp crust. Cheesecakes and pies earn praise for consistent quality in a fun, hole-in-the-wall setting.

Bright, tangy flavor and a crisp, well-made crust define the Key Lime Pie here. It delivers a perfect balance of sweet and tart with a smooth, creamy texture.

People are saying

"The cakes here are exceptional, especially the sweet potato."

"The peach cobbler is great, but a little too sweet."

"The Key Lime Pie here is so delicious and tart."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for holiday specials at Gregory's Gourmet Desserts.

2

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

Street parking can be difficult; there's a garage across the street.

28
Southern Chicago image 1

Elegant space offers beautiful décor and a warm vibe with great music. Guests enjoy thoughtfully crafted cocktails alongside high-quality Southern dishes. The Key lime pie is a standout dessert, delivering consistent flavor.

Key lime pie stands out as a delicious dessert option. It consistently delivers on flavor without disappointment.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, fresh, and thoughtfully prepared."

"The desserts here are phenomenal, sealing the deal for me."

"The branzino was tender with an outstanding sauce."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers great prices on food and drinks.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

3

Valet parking is available for guests.

29
Sea Level Restaurant image 1

Outdoor dining offers unbeatable ocean views and a relaxed vibe with live music that stays soft. Guests enjoy the friendly energy near pools and lagoons. The Key lime pie is a divine dessert, often ranked among the best.

Key lime pie stands out as a divine dessert here. It ranks among the best available during a stay.

People are saying

"The ocean views here are unbeatable and mesmerizing."

"The live music here creates a fantastic, chill atmosphere."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was divine."

Good to know

1

Live singing performances occur every weekend, enhancing the dining experience.

2

The restaurant is easily accessible from the pool and beach area.

3

Expect generous portion sizes, making it a good value for families.

30
Water Oak Cafe & Bakery image 1

Bright, airy space with European style design and a vibrant vibe. Guests savor high-quality cocktails like mimosas and sangria while enjoying elegant outdoor seating. The Key lime pie shines with a delightful crust and rich flavor in a pretty box.

Key lime pie features a delightful crust and comes in a pretty box presentation. Every bite offers a rich, exceptionally good flavor that stands out in the area.

People are saying

"The homemade food at brunch was delicious and came out fast."

"The staff at this Lunch Spot are so friendly and attentive."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Using the wait list ahead of your visit can reduce waiting time.

2

Expect a wait during peak brunch hours.

3

The cafe has plenty of seating and parking available.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...