Old firehouse with brick walls offers a friendly, inviting vibe for all ages. Upstairs suits family events, while downstairs bar adds cozy charm. Cracker-thin crust pizza tastes amazing with great texture, making it a standout choice.
Cracker-thin crust stands out with a very good texture and taste. The pizza consistently comes across as tasty and amazing across multiple visits.
"The food here makes you feel like family."
"The bar staff remembers your name and drink like magic."
"I thought the thin crust pizza was amazing and excellent."
Good to know
Karaoke happens every Saturday night, creating a lively atmosphere.
The restaurant is family-friendly, making it suitable for all ages.
Parking can be challenging, so arrive early to secure a spot.
Simple pizza shop shines with New York style thin crust that's perfectly crisp. Space stays impeccably clean and prices are affordable. Warm, friendly atmosphere welcomes both sit-down and takeout guests.
Offers New York style thin crust pizza with a perfectly crisp base. The pizza consistently delivers an outstanding thin crust experience.
Good to know
McHugh's offers free delivery for orders over a certain amount.
The large pizza costs $16, making it an affordable option.
Expect your pizza and calzone to be ready in about 10 minutes.
Bar and grill offers crispy thin crust pizza and a nostalgic atmosphere with album cover decor. Sports fans enjoy games in a relaxed setting inside, while the outdoor area stays quiet. Friendly energy makes it a cozy spot for food and fun.
Thin crust pizza here stands out with its crispy texture and light bite. The crust offers a distinctly different experience compared to thicker styles.
Good to know
Outdoor dining is not available at this time.
The location offers a waterfront view, enhancing the dining experience.
Prices are considered very fair for the quality of food and service.
Cozy spot offers thin crust pizza with a vodka slice that's a must-try. Casual, family-run vibe makes dining warm and inviting. Efficient pickup and delivery keep service smooth and steady.
Thin crust pizza stays classic and light with a crust that holds up well and doesn't sag. The delicious texture makes it stand out as a solid choice for thin crust lovers.
Good to know
Delivery and pickup are well organized for convenience.
Only soft drinks are available; no alcohol served.
The pizza is affordable, with slices starting at $2.
Cozy dining room offers a family-owned vibe with friendly service. Thin crust pizza shines with a perfect crunch and standout Tomato Pie. Locals love the affordable prices and consistent quality.
Thin crust pizza here has a perfect crunch and stays consistently good. The Tomato Pie stands out with its super good thin crust.
Good to know
The restaurant's hours are 11 AM to 9 PM on weekdays and Sundays, and until 10 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Prices for plain cheese pies are $13.99 all day, every day.
Free delivery is offered, and both cash and card payments are accepted.
Enjoy perfect thin crust pizza with crisp edges and balanced toppings. Homemade soups add a cozy touch in a setting with cloth tablecloths for an upscale feel. Friendly service and a welcoming, casual atmosphere make it a favorite for locals and travelers alike.
Pizza features a perfect thin crust that stays crisp. Bar pies highlight the insanely good thin crust style. The crust balances well with the toppings for a delicious bite.
Good to know
Reservations are not required for dining at this family-owned pizzeria.
Expect a wait time of about 20-30 minutes during peak dinner hours.
The restaurant offers takeout and in-house dining options.
Old school pizzeria offers thin, crispy pizza with a crisp crust that holds well. Vintage 1930s decor and an authentic brick oven create a classic tavern vibe. Friendly, neighborhood dive energy fills the original bar space.
Thin crust pizza here has a crisp crust that is not greasy. Slices hold together well and offer a well-rounded flavor.
Good to know
Reservations are required during busier times.
The restaurant is cash only.
Parking can be tough if I don't go early.
Enjoy crispy thin crust pizza with a unique grandma square style in a lively, family-friendly spot. Savor Italian classics like calamari and garlic knots amid a welcoming buzz. Benefit from fast delivery and community-focused catering services.
Thin crust pizzas feature a perfectly crisp base with a great sauce that balances flavors well. A grandma square style thin crust pizza is also available, offering a unique shape and texture.
Good to know
They have a Monday pasta special available for dine-in and takeout.
Delivery costs $5.99, which is confirmed at checkout.
Catering services are available for events with a variety of options.
Italian spot serves Jersey-style pizza with a sweet tomato base and quick cooking. Thin crust is crispy and airy with a classic tomato pie taste. Friendly vibe fills the packed space, though seating is tight and outdoor tables show wear.
Thin crust pizza comes out crispy and airy with a little char. It holds classic tomato pie style with perfect cheese and sauce balance.
Good to know
The dine-in seating is limited, especially during peak hours.
Expect long wait times during the dinner rush due to popularity.
The restaurant uses a conveyor oven, ensuring quick pizza preparation.
Bright, minimalistic space offers a laid-back vibe with a killer soundtrack that energizes the atmosphere. Dining area feels inviting and comfortable, perfect for families and date nights. Pizza boasts a light, thin crust topped with fresh, high-quality ingredients for crisp, flavorful pies.
Pizza features a delicious, light, and thin crust topped with fresh ingredients that keep it crisp and flavorful.
Good to know
The pizzeria only serves whole pies, not by the slice.
Stracciatella Saturdays feature special menu items available only on that day.
Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.
Kosher dining shines with a family-friendly atmosphere and a quiet, casual vibe. Pizza boasts a crispy thin crust topped with vibrant cheese and sauce, perfect with jalapeños. Space feels clean and welcoming, making every visit pleasant.
Crispy, ultra-thin crust defines the pizza here, paired with vibrant cheese and sauce. Asking for it well done and adding jalapeños boosts the flavor.
Good to know
The restaurant is family-friendly with options for kids.
Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.
Prices are generally high, but portions are generous.
Cozy spot blends fresh pizza with rich coffee for a unique vibe. Thin crust pizzas shine with a crispy crust cut into six square slices. Friendly energy makes dining in or takeout a pleasure.
Small pizzas come with a crispy thin crust cut into six square slices. The grandma’s pie stands out with its perfectly crispy but not dry crust. All thin crust slices taste delicious and well made.
Good to know
The shop is small and located inside a cafe and donut shop.
It is better suited for takeout due to its size and location.
They have an extensive menu with sandwiches on fresh focaccia bread, salads, and pizzas.
Cozy spot offers crispy thin crust pizza with savory sauce and fresh toppings. Unique Manhattan Special soda pairs well with delicious garlic knots. Clean, well-lit space with reasonable prices makes it a great casual choice.
Thin crust pizza features a savory sauce and generous cheese. Both plain and specialty pies showcase a tasty crust.
Good to know
The prices are very reasonable for the amount of food received.
Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted, but cash is preferred.
Expect a busy atmosphere, especially during peak hours.
Thin crust pizza is crisp to perfection with unique sauce flavors and fresh ingredients. Atmosphere shifts from quiet for deep talks to loud music that challenges conversation. Cleanliness is consistently sparkling, making it a great spot for both food and ambiance.
Crisp to perfection, the thin crust holds up well without flopping. It cooks evenly and tastes very good.
Good to know
The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness throughout the dining area.
Round Pie Pizza Company offers a variety of unique pizza options.
Expect higher prices for specialty toppings during holidays.
Brick oven creates a cozy ambiance inside with a clean, renovated space. Thin crust pizzas offer a crisp texture and balanced flavors. Outdoor seating and a beautiful backyard provide a relaxed spot for family gatherings.
Thin crust pizzas come with a nice crisp texture and a well balanced cheese to sauce ratio. Options like the Margarita and large cheese pies arrive cooked just right for delivery.
Good to know
Amadeo Pizzeria is a BYOB establishment, so bring your favorite drinks.
The pizzeria offers a convenient parking lot across the street.
Expect generous portions for the price you pay.
Space blends speakeasy vibes with a cozy back dining area and soft lighting. Thin crust pizzas, like the chicken Romano, offer a perfect bite with a salty crust. Guests enjoy bringing their own drinks, adding to the relaxed, personal feel.
All pies feature a thin crust with enough body for a great bite. The chicken Romano pizza has a nicely salted crust that stands out. The pizza quality matches NYC-style thin crust standards.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended on Fridays and Saturdays due to high demand.
The restaurant is BYOB, so bring your favorite drinks.
They offer gluten-free options and are celiac friendly.
Spacious seating suits large groups in a family-owned spot with a welcoming vibe. Thin crust pizza shines with NY style crispness and fresh, high-quality ingredients. Soft music adds to the casual, comfortable atmosphere.
Thin crust pizza features a NY style thin crust with a crisp bottom and good chew. It cooks perfectly and delivers full flavor throughout.
Good to know
Signing up for rewards gives a 15% discount on orders.
The restaurant is suitable for large groups needing to be fed.
Ordering for pickup is quick and efficient.
Cozy spot offers crispy thin crust pizza with a perfect sauce-cheese balance. Friendly staff add to the fun atmosphere. Prices stay affordable, making it a great choice for tasty, budget-friendly meals.
Thin crust pizza comes out crispy and cooked to perfection. Staff serve it with a friendly vibe, making it a solid choice for delicious thin crust.
Good to know
Pasta night special is available on Tuesdays.
They charge more if you use a credit card.
The menu offers a large variety of breakfast and lunch options.
Small space blends old-world charm with a lively vibe, often noisy and crowded. Thin crust pizzas feature crispy crust and fresh mozzarella with homemade meatballs. Atmosphere feels fun and cozy, drawing a devoted crowd despite limited seating.
Thin crust pizzas come with a crispy crust and a balanced amount of toppings. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, and homemade meatballs with authentic herbs add rich flavor to the delicious thin crust pies.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended as the restaurant books up fast.
Expect a 2-hour wait for pickup during peak hours.
Parking on South Avenue can be difficult and chaotic.
Small tavern offers ultra-thin crust pizza with crisp texture and many toppings. Cozy, lively vibe filled with nostalgic 70s charm and museum-quality Lionel trains. Cash-only bar serves distinctive ales and ciders for a full experience.
Ultra-thin crust stands out with its bar style and large selection of toppings. The pizza is consistently delicious and known for its crisp texture.
Good to know
Kinchley's Tavern only accepts cash payments.
There is an ATM on site at Kinchley's Tavern.
Expect a line out the door during peak hours.
Renovated space blends beach bar vibe with live jazz and sports elements. Thin crust pizzas shine, especially the Lobster Pie. Atmosphere shifts from family-friendly early evening to a loud, grown-up party upstairs later.
Pizzas come with a perfect thin crust that holds up well. The Lobster Pie stands out among the thin crust options.
Good to know
Live music happens every Friday night, creating a lively atmosphere.
The menu includes pizza, wings, pasta, salads, and blackened tuna.
Prices at Val's Tavern are reasonable, making it budget-friendly.
Small spot serves classic thin crust pizza with a delicious taste. Staff create a family-like vibe in a cozy, quiet setting. Prices stay affordable and service is fast despite an older interior.
Offers classic thin crust pizza with a delicious taste that stands out.
Good to know
The lunch special costs $10 and includes 2 slices of cheese, 4 garlic knots, and a can of soda.
Expect fast delivery; food is typically ready in 15 minutes.
Prices at Gaby's Pizza & Grill differ from those listed online.
Spacious seating fits 30-40 guests in a clean, welcoming spot where customers bring their own alcohol. Thin crust pizzas shine with extra crispy crust and bold flavors like buffalo style. Perfect for those who love flavorful pies and a friendly atmosphere.
Extra crispy crust stands out on the thin crust buffalo pizza. The thin crust pizzas are consistently delicious and a favorite choice in the office.
Good to know
The restaurant allows customers to bring their own alcohol.
With 12 of us ordering entrées and specials, we spent about $250 total.
BYOB and such a great experience!
Classic style pizza spot with thin crust pizza that cracks when folded and a very good tomato sauce. Wooden curved benches create a relaxed atmosphere but limited seating makes it better for small groups. Space feels cramped due to few tables.
Thin crust pizza offers a nice crunch underneath while still folding properly. The crust is thin enough to crack when folded, making both margherita and plain versions stand out.
Good to know
Recent price increases could affect how often customers return.
Hygiene practices at Roma Pizzeria may raise concerns during a pandemic.
Expect large portions; the chicken Parm includes a salad and pasta.
Small pizza spot offers crispy thin crust pizzas with rich flavor. Intimate seating and a modern design create a cozy vibe. Open kitchen and order screens add a lively energy for a quick, casual meal.
The pizza features an incredibly thin crust with a crispy bottom that stands out. It delivers good flavor and a delicious taste throughout.
Good to know
Expect a 60-minute wait for take-out orders during peak hours.
The restaurant has only two tables for dine-in, seating up to four people each.
Pizzas usually take 35-40 minutes after ordering, but delivery is faster.
Cozy spot buzzes with friendly chats and Sinatra tunes. Thin crust pizza offers a perfectly balanced bite with fresh toppings. Garlic knots stand out as a must-try. Busy with diners and takeout, it feels like a family gathering every visit.
Pizza features a super thin crust that balances well with delicious toppings. Crust thickness hits just the right spot for a satisfying bite.
Good to know
The price for a slice of cheese pizza is around $3.
The pizza costs approximately $35 for a full order.
Expect a busy environment, especially during lunch and dinner times.
Enjoy crispy thin crust pizzas with rich cheese and tangy sauce in a nostalgic atmosphere that feels like a 70s parlor. The place is clean and simple, offering a calm, homey vibe. Cash-only policy is eased by an on-site ATM for convenience.
Thin crust pizzas have a crispy, cookie-like texture with a light, airy feel. They come with a generous amount of cheese and a well-seasoned tomato sauce that balances the flavor perfectly.
Good to know
Joe’s Famous Pizza only accepts cash, so bring cash or use the ATM on-site.
There is an ATM on the premises for cash withdrawals.
Joe’s Famous Pizza is closed on Mondays.
Offers crispy thin crust pizza with Brooklyn and Manhattan styles topped with fresh mozzarella and oregano. Serves large portions at reasonable prices in an old school setting. Perfect for casual dining with a wide variety of slices and fresh sauce.
Crispy without being burnt, the thin crust pizza features Brooklyn Style Sicilian and Manhattan pie options topped with provolone, mozzarella, and oregano.
Good to know
The large slice of plain cheese pizza costs $3.00.
Delivery from Bella Pizza is not too expensive.
Portions at Bella Pizza are very large.