Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Fresh seafood

Fresh seafood that tastes like it came straight from the water rather than being masked by heavy, overpowering seasonings.

Based on 776 Opinions
+773
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Atlantis Prime image 1
Atlantis Prime image 2
Atlantis Prime image 3
View all
Steak house

Steakhouse offers an elegant atmosphere with a cozy, inviting interior and a spacious layout including a small patio set back from foot traffic. The vibe balances upbeat yet refined energy, suitable for both casual dinners and special occasions. Guests enjoy a warm, sophisticated setting enhanced by carefully curated music and thoughtful details.

Steaks like the porterhouse for two and ribeye stand out. Sides include mac and cheese and a seafood platter.

Seafood risotto stands out with its beautiful preparation and is packed with fresh seafood. The dish is cooked perfectly to highlight the seafood flavors.

People are saying

"The service at these dinner spots is attentive and welcoming."

"The fresh seafood here is packed with flavor and cooked perfectly."

"The American Food porterhouse is cooked perfectly and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant offers a complimentary glass of wine with every meal.

3

Prices are reasonable considering the quality of the meals.

02
Express Seafood Que Rica Comida! image 1

Small seafood restaurant with a homie feeling and clean, well-lit space that resembles a neighborhood deli. Atmosphere stays calm and relaxing with a blue and white color scheme and great music. Mostly takeout-focused but offers a welcoming vibe that makes it a hidden gem for fresh, tasty seafood.

Lobster bisque and New England clam chowder stand out with rich flavors. The menu also features Manhattan clam chowder and shrimp soup, offering a variety of classic American seafood soups.

Fresh seafood comes grilled or fried with great flavor. Preparation matches your preferences for customized dishes.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and flavorful."

"The lobster bisque and clam chowder are amazing."

"I found the fresh seafood to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available, offering great value for meals.

2

The restaurant is known for its clean environment.

3

Prices are very affordable, making it budget-friendly.

03
Sunset fish & lobster market & grill image 1

Seafood market and grill with casual, laid-back vibe and seating that overlooks water. Offers fresh, high-quality seafood with options for sit-down or takeout. Setup resembles a deli with sidewalk tables and umbrellas providing a relaxed atmosphere to watch waves.

Lobster rolls stand out for their freshness and flavor, offered both hot and cold. Other American dishes include crab cakes, Grouper Piccata, and New England clam chowder, all served in a casual waterfront setting.

Fresh seafood features prominently with dishes like the lobster roll standing out. This spot serves consistently delicious seafood that draws repeat visits.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the lobster roll, is the best I've ever had."

"The fresh seafood here is unmatched and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers both sit-down dining and takeout options.

2

You can buy fresh fish to take home from the market.

3

It's located just 200 yards from the beach, making it easily walkable.

04
Capโ€™t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 1

Seafood shines with bold Cajun flavors and fresh ingredients in a spacious, clean setting. Lobster rolls feature generous chunks on toasted buns, perfect with a $20 lunch deal. Strong Cajun spice aroma adds a lively vibe to the dining experience.

Seafood dishes feature bold Cajun flavors and fresh ingredients. The lobster roll comes with a perfectly toasted bun and generous lobster chunks, paired with a $20 lunch deal including soda.

Fresh seafood comes with bold Cajun flavor and good overall taste.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be so fresh and tasty."

"The American Food, especially the seafood boil, was delicious and well seasoned."

"The fresh seafood here is so flavorful and delicious."

Good to know

1

Oyster special on Tuesdays costs $1.50 each.

2

Lunch specials are available from 12pm to 3pm.

3

Happy hour features discounted oysters on Tuesdays.

05
Seabass Taverna image 1
Greek restaurant

Mediterranean restaurant with Greek-style dรฉcor featuring rustic wood and vibrant blue and white colors creates a warm, inviting atmosphere with soft background music and dim lighting. Guests enjoy a quiet, cozy vibe suitable for intimate or lively gatherings, complemented by a friendly, professional team and occasional live music.

Crab cakes stand out as a highlight. Other notable dishes include three dips with fresh pita, clam chowder, penne vodka with shrimp, and hanger steak.

Fresh seafood arrives in generous portions and is cooked to perfection. The menu includes amazing calamari, a variety of appetizers, and a paella rich with seafood, all offering great value.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be delicious and fresh."

"The American Food here, especially the clam chowder, is delicious."

"The fresh seafood here is delicious and perfectly cooked."

Good to know

1

The kitchen is open until 10 PM on Christmas.

2

The restaurant has a special for $22 per person for an hour of house wine or select cocktails.

3

The $49 Endless menu includes 2 cocktails, coffee, and tea.

06
Catch Oyster Bar image 1
Oyster bar restaurant

Small space with quirky decor and a hole-in-the-wall vibe creates a cozy, buzzing atmosphere. Friendly crowd enjoys fresh oysters and strong cocktails amid lively, sometimes loud music. Local favorite known for excellent seafood and an exceptional raw bar.

Lobster rolls feature big, buttery chunks of lobster, including claw meat, served warm and perfectly cooked. Clam chowder stands out as rich and highly praised, while coleslaw complements the seafood dishes well.

Very fresh seafood stands out here, offering excellent quality despite the usual high cost on the island. The spot pairs well with drinks for a solid seafood experience.

People are saying

"I found the oysters to be super fresh and out of this world."

"I had a top-tier American Food lobster roll with big, buttery chunks."

"I enjoyed the excellent and very fresh seafood."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for busy nights, especially during Lobsterfest.

2

Expect a wait time during peak hours due to the restaurant's small size.

3

The raw bar menu details the type and origin of oysters available.

07
The Shell Seafood Kitchen & Bar image 1

Seafood restaurant offers spacious outdoor patio with comfortable seating and vibrant ambience. Interior features inviting decor and a clean, cozy atmosphere. The place fills with lively energy, especially during evenings, attracting diners who enjoy well-prepared seafood and crafted cocktails.

Seafood shines with crab cakes and shrimp appetizers. The menu also features a lobster roll and a solid pecan pie alongside a crisp Caesar salad.

Seafood dishes feature fresh seafood with strong flavors. The seafood soup stands out, packed with a variety of fresh ingredients.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and perfectly cooked."

"The American Food, especially the seafood, was cooked to perfection."

"The fresh seafood here is amazingly fresh and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4-6 PM daily with great deals on drinks and appetizers.

2

The happy hour menu is available from 3 to 6 PM Tuesday to Saturday.

3

The Paella special is available Monday to Wednesday and includes a bottle of wine.

08
Blue Water Fish image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market with fresh, minimally processed seafood and a wide variety of fish and prepared dishes. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with a calm, relaxing surrounding and friendly people. Offers both market shopping and dining options, standing out for its exceptional freshness and quality.

Seafood shines with lobster bisque and lobster roll sandwich served on a toasted baguette. The New England Clam Chowder is sweet, creamy, and loaded with clams and potatoes. Hamburgers, crab cakes, and fish and chips also feature prominently.

Offers a wide variety of fresh seafood at reasonable prices. Serves seafood for dining in or takeout with consistently delicious quality.

People are saying

"I found the seafood here to be top notch and very fresh."

"I found the fresh seafood here to be delicious and very fresh."

"I found the best lobster roll here."

Good to know

1

Blue Water Fish offers a wide variety of fresh seafood and a menu for dining in or taking out.

2

There is plenty of free parking across the street.

3

Expect higher prices for premium seafood selections compared to supermarkets.

09
Cap't Loui Seafood boil image 1
Seafood restaurant

Spacious seafood restaurant with wide high ceilings and sturdy wooden tables creates a clean, warm atmosphere. Bright lighting and open front street view set a lively, homey vibe. Guests enjoy flavorful seafood boils and casual, comfortable seating with leather seats.

Signature dishes highlight Cajun seasoning with flavorful seafood like lobster rolls and crispy shrimp po' boys. Generous portions of Cajun fries come with a spicy sauce that stands out.

Fresh seafood comes with bold Cajun flavors and generous portions. The seafood tastes fresh and stands out in the dishes.

People are saying

"I found the seafood boil here to be one of the yummiest I ever had."

"The Cajun fries here are amazing and have a great lemon pepper flavor."

"The fresh seafood here is flavorful and tastes amazing."

Good to know

1

They have BOGO lobster on Thursday.

2

Cap't Loui Seafood boil offers dollar oysters on Tuesday.

3

The food comes out within 15 minutes of ordering.

10
Bay Ridge Fish Market image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market with fresh fish selection and small, cozy seating including a shaded garden patio. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, with a friendly, family-oriented vibe. Space is clean but cramped, offering a genuine, homey seafood experience.

Clam chowder and crab cakes stand out with rich flavors and fresh ingredients. The menu also features beer battered shrimp, scallops, and fresh grilled fish like flounder and cod.

Fresh seafood arrives daily with a wide selection of fish and shellfish. The market offers quality catches that satisfy cravings for ocean-fresh flavors.

People are saying

"The seafood here is fresh, buttery, and garlicky."

"The American Food here, especially the seafood, is gorgeous and fresh."

"I found the fresh seafood here to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.

2

Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.

3

The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.

11
Sea Bar image 1
Seafood restaurant

Elegant seafood restaurant with chic maritime decor and a contemporary, well-planned interior creates a warm and inviting atmosphere. Signature cocktails and a masterpiece bar enhance the experience, while the space accommodates both casual bar seating and private parties.

Lobster Roll comes fresh and tasty on a brioche bun. Crab cakes deliver a clear wow factor. Chilean Sea Bass pairs well with the warm lobster roll.

Seafood arrives super-fresh with simple, flavorful preparation highlighting authentic Greek-Mediterranean tastes. Dishes come beautifully presented and full of authentic flavors.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh and delicious."

"The fresh seafood here is expertly prepared and highlights natural flavor."

"The American Food here, especially the sea bass, is fresh and perfectly grilled."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a mandatory tip of 20% based on the number of guests seated at the table.

2

There is plenty of parking behind the restaurant.

3

The midday seafood menu is available until 3:30 p.m.

12
Big Blue Seafood & Grill image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers cozy, elegant atmosphere with exquisite interior decor and well-set tables. Music adds to the lively yet intimate vibe, creating a welcoming and comfortable space. Fresh, outstanding seafood complements inventive cocktails, making the experience distinctively refined.

Surf and turf features prominently with a notable New York strip steak served medium rare in large portions. The Crab Cakes stand out for their flavor and presentation.

Offers fresh seafood that tastes solid and simple. Serves it in a relaxed, no-frills environment without upscale prices.

People are saying

"The seafood here is so fresh, it's divine."

"The fresh seafood here tastes clean and delicious."

"The American Food here is great, Bajro makes it fun!"

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs until 7pm with great drink deals.

2

Reservations are recommended for dinner service, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of seafood and steak options.

13
Cap't Loui - Cajun Seafood Boil image 1

Seafood boil restaurant with spacious, clean interior and nautical decor creates a calm, laid-back atmosphere. Music plays softly, enhancing the family-friendly vibe with thoughtful touches like crayons for toddlers. Cocktails stand out with strong, creative drinks including adult Capri Suns and Caribbean blue cocktails.

Cajun sauce stands out with rich flavor, paired often with shrimp, crab, and fries. Creamy clam chowder and lobster rolls add variety, while Jambalaya soup offers a hearty touch.

Fresh seafood stands out here with consistently good quality. The dishes deliver delicious flavors that satisfy cravings for seafood.

People are saying

"The seafood boil here is seasoned perfectly and tastes amazing."

"The American food here is so flavorful and fresh."

"I found the seafood here to be so fresh and divine."

Good to know

1

Go on Tuesdays for $1 oysters all day.

2

It takes less than 20 minutes for the food to come.

3

The restaurant closes at 10:15 PM.

14
Lighthouse Seafood image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market offers fresh fish and shellfish displayed on ice with a large selection. Outdoor seating by the waterfront provides beautiful views and a relaxing atmosphere. The raw bar and take-out counter add casual dining options with authentic seafood flavors.

Lobster rolls come fresh and plentiful, often recommended by the staff. Seafood options include oysters, shrimp, and clams alongside the lobster roll.

Offers an excellent selection of super fresh seafood with all types available. The seafood consistently impresses with its freshness.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh and delicious."

"I found the fresh seafood selection and quality to be great."

"The American Food, especially the seafood, was top notch."

Good to know

1

Expect to wait over 30 minutes to place your order during peak hours.

2

They opened a take-out counter for hot food recently.

3

Prices are higher than average, with some items up to $10 more per pound.

15
Southold Fish Market image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market combines authentic seaside charm with fresh fish displays and expanded indoor and outdoor seating. Atmosphere stays laid-back and clean with plenty of picnic tables for casual dining. It attracts those seeking fresh, high-quality seafood without crowds or wait times.

Lobster rolls come packed with big chunks of lobster, mayo, and celery, often served warm and very filling. Other dishes include blackened swordfish sandwiches, tuna clubs, fried seafood, clam chowder, and a coleslaw with a hint of pineapple.

Fresh seafood is available here with a wonderful selection on display. The quality of the seafood stands out clearly.

People are saying

"The seafood here is incredibly fresh and delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the lobster roll, is packed with chunks of lobster."

"The fresh seafood here is wonderful and offered a great variety."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends to avoid long wait times.

2

Expect higher prices than average for fresh seafood options.

3

Parking can be tricky, so arrive early to secure a spot.

16
Greenpoint Fish & Lobster Co. image 1

Seafood restaurant offers coastal vibe with open kitchen and bar seating inside, plus extensive outdoor tables. Atmosphere feels cozy and exclusive, blending small-town charm with a hip, happening energy. Outdoor area suits warm afternoons despite urban noises and mixed scents nearby.

Lobster rolls stand out with fresh lobster, a toasted brioche bun, and just a touch of seasoning. Clam chowder is clear and balanced, not creamy or salty, while oysters add to the authentic American seafood experience.

Fresh seafood arrives daily with a wide selection of fish and shellfish. The grill serves a lovely spread of seafood dishes that highlight the market's quality.

People are saying

"The lobster roll and oysters here are the best I've ever had."

"The American Food lobster rolls are loaded with lobster meat."

"I found the fresh seafood here to be super fresh."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 12 PM to 6 PM, with drink specials starting at 4 PM.

2

Oysters are $2 each during happy hour, which is a great deal.

3

Reservations are needed due to limited seating and high demand.

17
Smithereens image 1
American restaurant

Subterranean space with boat-themed decor and open kitchen creates a moody, cozy atmosphere reminiscent of the New England coastline. The vibe is intimate and hip, suited for quiet dinners or date nights, with a focus on creative seafood dishes and a standout dirty martini.

The lobster roll stands out with a hot dog bun cooked over Japanese charcoal, adding smokiness and char. The buckwheat pancake offers a delicate texture that pairs well with the seafood-focused menu.

Seafood here is consistently very fresh with a great mix of flavors that stand out.

People are saying

"The seafood here is super fresh and creatively prepared."

"I thought the American Food, specifically the lobster roll, was amazing."

"The fresh seafood here is incredibly delicious and beautifully presented."

Good to know

1

Reservations are likely to become hard to come by soon.

2

The restaurant is located in a subterranean space that is not wheelchair friendly.

3

The portions at Smithereens are on the smaller side.

18
Shipwreck Seafood Boutique image 1

Small, cozy seafood market with open windows and outdoor seating creates a fresh, upscale feel. The atmosphere is welcoming and clean, with good music adding to the positive vibe. Regulars enjoy fresh, high-quality seafood in a boutique neighborhood setting.

Seafood sandwiches like lobster rolls and po' boys stand out. Plates include crab cakes, shrimp, oysters, and a salmon burger with fries.

Fresh seafood arrives daily with a vast selection including succulent shrimp and perfectly grilled fish. Options are available to take home for convenience.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always delicious and fresh."

"The American Food, especially the seafood sandwiches, is delicious and fresh."

"I found the seafood here to be the freshest I could find."

Good to know

1

The shop accepts credit cards and mobile payments.

2

Parking is available on the street, but can be limited during peak hours.

3

Expect longer wait times during weekends due to higher foot traffic.

19
Aqua Boil image 1
Seafood restaurant

Interior design mimics a nautical boathouse with dimmed lighting creating a cozy atmosphere. Seafood is served in bags with disposable cutlery and gloves, making dining informal and interactive. Music plays at a lively volume, encouraging a vibrant energy throughout.

Seafood boils come with medium Cajun spice and sides like potatoes, corn, and sausage. Lobster rolls and mac and cheese starters stand out as delicious options. Cajun fries and shellfish are also available for delivery.

Fresh seafood arrives clearly labeled as fresh or frozen, with staff ready to explain the difference. Friendly service helps with ordering a variety of fresh seafood options.

People are saying

"I experienced the best seafood boil in the city."

"You have to try their seafood boil; it's messy, punchy, and totally satisfying."

"The fresh seafood here is packed with amazing Cajun flavor."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially between 6-8 PM.

2

Happy hour drinks are $6 all day from Monday to Thursday.

3

From Friday to Sunday, happy hour drinks are $6 before 7 PM.

20
The Mermaid Inn image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers a spacious and bright setting with a French flair and Parisian vibe. A large bar at the front creates lively banter, while a quiet back room provides a cozy and romantic atmosphere. The place fills up early, often requiring arrival before 4:30 to secure a table.

Fresh oysters and a lobster roll stand out here, with the lobster roll served alongside hot, crispy fries. The cheeseburger and linguine with clams in lemon sauce also deliver solid American flavors.

Fresh seafood stands out with its coastal charm and quality. Recommendations from local captains highlight its fresh offerings.

People are saying

"The service during Happy Hour is attentive and thoughtful."

"The American Food here, especially the lobster roll, is fresh and fantastic."

"The fresh seafood here is always fantastic and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 4:30-6:30pm with great food and drink deals.

2

Reservations are recommended for oyster happy hour to secure a spot.

3

The happy hour oysters are priced at $1.50 each.

21
Bigelow's New England Fried Clams image 1

Small seafood restaurant with old school charm and a cozy, nostalgic ambiance featuring vintage decor and a relaxing, friendly atmosphere. Offers both enclosed outdoor patio seating with heaters and indoor counter service. Known for fresh fried seafood and acclaimed New England clam chowder.

New England Clam Chowder comes in both red and white versions, with the red being a standout. Lobster rolls and seafood bisque also feature prominently, alongside crab sandwiches served with coleslaw and Ipswich clams over fries.

Fresh seafood arrives daily, including New England and Manhattan chowders. The menu features New England fried clams and other seafood dishes prepared with care.

People are saying

"The fried seafood, especially the clams, is the best I've ever had."

"The New England clam chowder is rich and flavorful."

"The fresh seafood here tastes like it was just reeled in."

Good to know

1

Bigelow's New England Fried Clams is the only place for whole belly clams in the NYC area.

2

Bigelow's has been around for over 80 years.

3

They now accept credit cards and digital wallets.

22
Maison Premiere image 1
Oyster bar restaurant

Oyster bar with candle-lit, intimate atmosphere and old school interiors creates a cozy, chic vibe. Garden patio offers beautiful outdoor seating, enhancing the experience. Absinthe fountain and vintage bartenders add to the immersive, New Orleans-inspired setting.

Seafood shines with lobster roll featuring perfectly buttered chunks full of flavor and chef selection of oysters. Dishes like crab toast stay light, fresh, and well-balanced.

Fresh seafood comes with expertly crafted drinks and light bites in a gorgeous setting.

People are saying

"I found the oysters here to be the freshest I've had."

"The American Food, especially the lobster roll, was fresh and delicious."

"I loved the fresh seafood, especially the oysters."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary as this place can get packed quickly.

2

Expect to wait up to 3 hours for a table without a reservation.

3

The kitchen closes at a specific time, so arrive early if you want to eat.

23
Claws Seafood Market image 1
Seafood market

Seafood market with fresh, locally sourced seafood and outdoor seating by a canal creates a comfortable, community vibe filled with smiles. Lobster rolls stand out as a popular choice, drawing consistent praise for quality and value.

Lobster rolls stand out with fresh, tasty lobster and generous portions, especially the double 'Naked' roll. The menu also features clam chowder and lobster bisque, plus sides like hush puppies and baked clams.

Super fresh seafood comes from a small Mom and Pop shop known for its quality. The market offers a chill patio vibe to enjoy the catch.

People are saying

"I found the lobster roll to be outstanding and delicious."

"Their American Food, especially the lobster rolls, were outstanding."

"I found the fresh seafood to be the best."

Good to know

1

The lobster roll is priced at $19.99, which is reasonable for fresh seafood.

2

Outdoor seating is available, providing a casual dining experience.

3

The market opens later than 5pm, making it convenient for evening visits.

24
Lobster Place image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood bar with lobster station, sushi bar, and oyster bar creates a lively, bustling atmosphere. Crowds gather around bar seating, making it energetic but sometimes crowded. Outdoor seating with heaters offers a warmer option amid the fresh seafood vibe.

Lobster rolls here feature lots of meat and come in a 6oz size. The spot also offers clam chowder and a raw bar with oysters and sushi at the counter.

A huge selection of fresh seafood fills the counters, offering a wide variety of options. The quality stays consistently high, making it a solid spot for deliciously fresh seafood.

People are saying

"I highly recommend the delicious lobster sandwich."

"I found the clam chowder rich, hot, and unbeatable."

"The American Food lobster roll here is packed with huge chunks of lobster."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs from 6pm to 7pm, offering half-off oysters from Monday to Friday.

2

The lobster sandwich costs $30, while the lobster roll is $23.

3

Seating can be limited during peak hours, so be prepared to stand.

25
Crab House Brooklyn image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant offers a cozy ambiance with R&B and hip hop music setting a lively tone. Guests enjoy a spectacular view of Coney Island from a rooftop outdoor area. The space features a beautiful fish tank and an inviting interior despite a less appealing entrance.

Offers an all-you-can-eat seafood experience with a wide selection including lobster, snow crab legs, oysters, and shrimp. Fried fish, chicken wings, crab rangoons, and lobster mac and cheese stand out as popular dishes.

Offers an all-you-can-eat buffet featuring a wide variety of fresh seafood. The selection allows for unlimited servings in a casual setting.

People are saying

"The seafood here is ridiculously fresh and well-seasoned."

"I loved the fresh fish and seafood here."

"I loved the all-you-can-eat fresh seafood buffet."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Thursdays and Fridays from 4-6pm for teachers with school ID.

2

Children celebrating birthdays eat free with four paying adults.

3

The average price is around $80 per person for the buffet.

26
New Wave Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant combines cozy atmosphere with an attached fresh seafood market offering both raw and prepared options. The space fills with a loud, lively vibe that challenges quiet conversation, attracting mostly couples and an older crowd. Clean and neat interior supports a casual dining experience with standout fresh seafood dishes.

New England clam chowder stands out with a rich, creamy texture. Lump crab cakes come large and genuine. The lobster roll is fresh and generously sized.

Many options of fresh seafood appear at the market side and fish market. Buying and eating fresh seafood happens regularly here, with prices reflecting its quality.

People are saying

"The seafood staff here is so friendly and helpful."

"The seafood at this market is always fresh and cooked perfectly."

"I found the fresh seafood here was really good."

Good to know

1

There is ample parking available in the paved lot out front.

2

The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.

3

Expect to wait as there are no reservations accepted.

27
Bennett Shellfish image 1
Seafood market

Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.

Lobster rolls stand out for their freshness and affordable pricing, often available as two for around $30 to $38. The rolls come ready to eat and pair well with smoked fish dip and chips.

Offers fresh seafood with a nice variety. Staff are friendly and helpful.

People are saying

"The seafood here is always so fresh, especially the oysters."

"The American Food here, especially the lobster rolls, is amazing."

"You'll find the freshest seafood here, like local clams and oysters."

Good to know

1

Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.

2

There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.

3

The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.

28
White Cap Fish Market & Seafood Restaurant image 1

Small seafood market and restaurant sits on the water with spacious outdoor seating under tents by the docks. Atmosphere feels cozy and rustic, with an old boat yard setting that adds character and a family-friendly vibe. Fresh seafood is available both for purchase and casual dining in an informal, relaxed environment.

Lobster roll comes packed with coleslaw and French fries. New England clam chowder tastes like thick mashed potatoes with cream and a sour note. Menu includes red snapper steak, baked clams, and broiled sea scallops.

Seafood comes straight from the ocean with a great assortment of crab cakes and chowders. Fresh options are available for both purchase and eating.

People are saying

"The seafood here is impeccably fresh, tasting like it came straight from the bay."

"I enjoyed the really fresh seafood they offered."

"I loved the American Food, especially the lobster roll."

Good to know

1

The kitchen opens at 11am; no hot food is available before then.

2

Bring your own beer as the restaurant does not serve alcohol.

3

Parking is available nearby but can be limited during busy times.

29
Atlantic Seafood image 1
Seafood restaurant

Casual seafood restaurant with laid-back atmosphere and no-frills decor featuring plastic plates and cups. Outdoor seating adds to the kid-friendly, relaxed vibe. Distinctive shark mouth feature and well-decorated spaces create a unique, timeless feel.

Lobster roll stands out with juicy lobster in a buttery roll, served hot. The seafood platter features shrimp, flounder, and scallops broiled in garlic butter, paired with broccoli and mac and cheese. Clam chowder is creamy and flavorful, while sliced brisket is soft and tender without sauce.

Casual spot with a menu focused on excellent fresh seafood. Also operates as a market offering a nice selection of fresh catches.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be fresh and amazing."

"I found the fresh seafood here to be delicious and good."

"I loved the hot lobster roll, it was packed with juicy lobster."

Good to know

1

Happy hour features half-price oysters and cocktail shrimp.

2

Expect a $20 surcharge for transferring food to smaller containers.

3

Outdoor seating may lack shade during lunch hours.

30
Aquarelle NYC image 1
Seafood restaurant

Seafood restaurant with elegant, cozy design and interiors resembling a sea vessel. Atmosphere includes live violin and DJ music, creating a vibrant yet intimate vibe. Features interactive dining with unique touches like axolotls and exclusive art displays.

Seafood shines with crab cakes, shrimp ceviche, and grilled branzino cooked to perfection. Mains include a ribeye steak and red snapper, both bold and well-balanced in flavor.

Fresh seafood shines in the seafood pasta and the seafood display at the back. The seafood tastes really fresh throughout.

People are saying

"The food here was delicious and really fresh."

"The American Food lobster roll was fresh, buttery, and gone way too fast."

"I found the seafood to be really fresh."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially on weekends.

2

Happy hour features $1.50 oysters and discounted cocktails, but only at the bar.

3

All sides are ordered separately and come at an additional cost.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...