Seafood market with fresh local catch and a cozy outdoor patio surrounded by hydrangeas creates a relaxed vibe. Casual, clean space offers gluten-free options and a warm, inviting atmosphere. Back patio seating provides a quiet spot away from street activity.
Freshness stands out with the lobster roll containing no unnecessary ingredients. It offers a clean, tasty bite that energizes and satisfies seafood cravings.
Offers only local seafood like black sea bass, porgy, ling, bluefin, fluke, and kelp grown on Long Island. Known for fresh lobster rolls and a focus on regional catches.
"The seafood here is so fresh and local, you can taste it."
"I thought the lobster roll was the best I had."
"This market serves only fresh, local seafood."
Good to know
The restaurant is BYOB, so you can bring your own wine or beer.
They focus on local seafood, ensuring freshness and quality.
The restaurant offers a great selection of gluten-free options.
Seafood market with fresh, minimally processed seafood and a wide variety of fish and prepared dishes. Atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with a calm, relaxing surrounding and friendly people. Offers both market shopping and dining options, standing out for its exceptional freshness and quality.
Lobster rolls come freshly prepared with lettuce on a perfectly toasted baguette instead of a typical roll. Portions are decent-sized and often served with fries or chips at a good price.
Offers a cute little fish market with reasonable prices and a restaurant serving seafood like lobster rolls on perfectly toasted baguettes.
Good to know
Blue Water Fish offers a wide variety of fresh seafood and a menu for dining in or taking out.
There is plenty of free parking across the street.
Expect higher prices for premium seafood selections compared to supermarkets.
Seafood market with an attached casual dining area featuring outdoor seating surrounded by nice flowers. Atmosphere is clean and relaxed, offering fresh local catch and a variety of seafood dishes. Prices vary but generally reflect the quality and freshness of the seafood available.
Lobster rolls come insanely well prepared with a focus on fresh, flavorful lobster. They stand out as outstanding and consistently delicious among other seafood options.
Fresh seafood sits at the front with a restaurant in the back. Three types of crabcakes use lump crabmeat. New owners focus on customer service and quality.
Good to know
Outdoor seating is available in the back of the restaurant.
Prices are reasonable for the quality of seafood offered.
Ample parking is available for customers.
Seafood market offers fresh fish and shellfish displayed on ice with a large selection. Outdoor seating by the waterfront provides beautiful views and a relaxing atmosphere. The raw bar and take-out counter add casual dining options with authentic seafood flavors.
Meaty lobster rolls come fresh and plentiful, with a well priced menu offering. Staff actively suggest the lobster roll, highlighting its popularity alongside a phenomenal raw bar.
Seafood market offers a large selection with a fish market atmosphere. Prices run higher than many others, sometimes by 5 to 10 dollars a pound.
Good to know
Expect to wait over 30 minutes to place your order during peak hours.
They opened a take-out counter for hot food recently.
Prices are higher than average, with some items up to $10 more per pound.
Seafood market combines authentic seaside charm with fresh fish displays and expanded indoor and outdoor seating. Atmosphere stays laid-back and clean with plenty of picnic tables for casual dining. It attracts those seeking fresh, high-quality seafood without crowds or wait times.
Chunks of lobster fill the roll, mixed with mayo and celery for texture. The warm lobster roll is very filling and pairs well with seafood sides like shrimp and crab.
Seafood market and takeout offers fresh options with no wait. Locals trust it as an excellent fish market and a solid choice for quality seafood.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended on weekends to avoid long wait times.
Expect higher prices than average for fresh seafood options.
Parking can be tricky, so arrive early to secure a spot.
Takeaway-only seafood market with a cute cottage design and mom-and-pop feel. Atmosphere is authentic and inviting, reflecting a family-run tradition spanning generations. Known for fresh lobster rolls and smoked fish spread, it operates on a cash-only basis with no seating available.
Lobster rolls come super fresh, prepared the same morning. They offer a two for $30 deal that many find affordable and a great value. The rolls are consistently described as phenomenal and delicious.
Family-run market offers fresh local fish with some of the freshest tuna available. Seafood selection reflects generations of experience in selling quality fish.
Good to know
Bennett Shellfish is takeout only and accepts cash only.
There is no seating area available at Bennett Shellfish.
The lobster rolls are priced at a fraction of the tourist spots in Montauk.
Seafood market with fresh, locally sourced seafood and outdoor seating by a canal creates a comfortable, community vibe filled with smiles. Lobster rolls stand out as a popular choice, drawing consistent praise for quality and value.
Lobster rolls come with lots of fresh lobster meat and generous portions, including a double ‘Naked’ roll option. They cost around $19.99 and often come with fries and a pickle on the side.
Offers a wide variety of fresh, local seafood including halibut, clams, and salmon. Stays open later than most markets and features outstanding lobster rolls.
Good to know
The lobster roll is priced at $19.99, which is reasonable for fresh seafood.
Outdoor seating is available, providing a casual dining experience.
The market opens later than 5pm, making it convenient for evening visits.
Seafood market offers fresh fish selection and shrimp tacos in a clean, cozy space with indoor tables and a shaded garden patio. Lobster rolls are packed with super tender lobster, making every bite rich and satisfying. Warm, family-friendly vibe adds to the homey experience.
Rolls come packed with high-quality, super tender lobster. Seafood fills the lobster roll to the brim without skimping.
Fresh seafood stands out with delicious fish and shrimp tacos. The market stays clean and well-organized with indoor tables and a patio for dining.
Good to know
The Bay Ridge Fishbar is BYOB, allowing guests to bring their own drinks.
Customers can choose the fish, which is freshly displayed and can be cooked on the spot.
The pricing at Bay Ridge Fishbar is incredibly fair for the quality.
Large covered market blends historic architecture with modern food culture. Fresh lobster rolls from multiple vendors stand out among diverse, creative stalls. Outdoor heated booths offer cozy spots to enjoy a vibrant, bustling atmosphere.
Fresh lobster shines in the lobster rolls here, making them a standout choice. Multiple vendors serve these rolls with quality seafood and a variety of preparations.
Offers a wide range of unique and creative food vendors that attract food lovers and curious wanderers alike. Serves as a vibrant spot to explore diverse culinary options and enjoy memorable food experiences.
Good to know
Happy hour offers half price on oysters and beers/wine.
Chelsea Market hosts various events, including cooking classes and pop-up shops.
Expect a 20-minute queue outside every restaurant during peak hours.
Seafood restaurant offers coastal vibe with open kitchen and bar seating inside, plus extensive outdoor tables. Atmosphere feels cozy and exclusive, blending small-town charm with a hip, happening energy. Outdoor area suits warm afternoons despite urban noises and mixed scents nearby.
Generous servings of fresh lobster fill a toasted brioche bun with just a touch of seasoning. The lobster roll comes with fries or salad and offers a buttery, authentic taste at reasonable prices.
Fresh seafood stands out with good quality fish and a grill option. Few fish markets exist nearby, making this a notable choice.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 12 PM to 6 PM, with drink specials starting at 4 PM.
Oysters are $2 each during happy hour, which is a great deal.
Reservations are needed due to limited seating and high demand.
Seafood restaurant combines cozy atmosphere with an attached fresh seafood market offering both raw and prepared options. The space fills with a loud, lively vibe that challenges quiet conversation, attracting mostly couples and an older crowd. Clean and neat interior supports a casual dining experience with standout fresh seafood dishes.
Lobster rolls come with very fresh lobster and are served in a huge portion. The bread can be overwhelming and dry, sometimes masking the lobster's flavor.
Fresh seafood options fill the market with wild salmon and other catches. Helpful workers provide courteous service in a simple setting attached to a quaint restaurant.
Good to know
There is ample parking available in the paved lot out front.
The restaurant maintains a high standard of cleanliness.
Expect to wait as there are no reservations accepted.
Seafood market with fresh fish selection and outdoor seating offers a casual, dog-friendly atmosphere. The place draws people looking for quality lobster rolls and local canned wine. It balances a relaxed vibe with a focus on fresh, affordable seafood options.
A toasty, buttery roll holds a generous amount of succulent lobster meat, including claws. The lobster roll comes with fries and coleslaw, making it a complete and satisfying meal.
Seafood stands out for its super fresh quality and variety. The market supports both take-out and meal preparation with items like fish broth and seafood for dishes such as Cioppino.
Good to know
The seafood market offers a variety of fresh fish and snacks.
Take-out service is available for those on the go.
Prices are generally moderate, making it accessible for most budgets.
Seafood bar with lobster station, sushi bar, and oyster bar creates a lively, bustling atmosphere. Crowds gather around bar seating, making it energetic but sometimes crowded. Outdoor seating with heaters offers a warmer option amid the fresh seafood vibe.
Lobster rolls come with lots of meat served on buttery toast. They taste fresh and flavorful and often stand out compared to other lobster dishes.
Fresh and wide variety of seafood defines the market's offerings. The atmosphere includes outdoor seating in the market area, enhancing the dining experience.
Good to know
Happy hour runs from 6pm to 7pm, offering half-off oysters from Monday to Friday.
The lobster sandwich costs $30, while the lobster roll is $23.
Seating can be limited during peak hours, so be prepared to stand.
Supermarket combines linear layout with animatronic entertainment to create a lively, family-friendly atmosphere. Interactive displays and ample samples engage shoppers, while the rural market theme adds a unique touch. The experience feels like a continuous adventure through fresh produce, baked goods, and specialty items.
Lobster rolls have a rich flavor and come at an affordable price. Some batches can have a fishy smell indicating spoilage, so freshness varies.
Offers a family-friendly atmosphere with a wide selection of groceries. Stands out as a great market for everyday shopping needs.
Good to know
BBQ is available on weekends.
Expect crowds on weeknights and weekends.
Weekly specials on shrimp and steaks are available.
Casual seafood restaurant with laid-back atmosphere and no-frills decor featuring plastic plates and cups. Outdoor seating adds to the kid-friendly, relaxed vibe. Distinctive shark mouth feature and well-decorated spaces create a unique, timeless feel.
Hot lobster roll comes packed with juicy lobster in a buttery roll. It tastes delicious and feels totally worth it.
Large servings come in an old-fashioned fish market setting with a nice selection of fresh seafood. The market works well for takeout and offers good local seafood options.
Good to know
Happy hour features half-price oysters and cocktail shrimp.
Expect a $20 surcharge for transferring food to smaller containers.
Outdoor seating may lack shade during lunch hours.
Seafood restaurant combines fresh catch market with casual, family-friendly atmosphere featuring cozy, dim lighting. Seating blends with retail space, creating an open, lively environment that can get noisy during peak hours. Known for exceptionally fresh seafood and a welcoming vibe.
Hot lobster rolls come buttery and packed with meat, offering a flavorful and appetizing experience. They pair well with great fries and can also be served cold if preferred.
Fresh seafood stands out in both the retail market and the dining area. The market keeps everything very clean and offers superb quality fish and prepared dishes.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended for groups of 6 or more to ensure seating.
The $20 shrimp special includes two sides and multiple preparation options.
The seafood market offers fresh fish that can be cooked at home.