Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Wisconsin

Bagels

Made for those who consider a dense, chewy bagel the only acceptable way to start the morning.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01

Sourdough bakery uses organic ingredients and a fire-burning oven for fresh, clean bread. Bagels are locally sourced and come in many tasty varieties. Atmosphere feels peaceful with a strong focus on sustainable practices.

Fresh, locally-sourced breads and bagels stand out here. The bagels come in multiple varieties and taste consistently amazing and tasty.

People are saying

"I found the sourdough bread to be so delicious and fresh."

"I found the organic ingredients to be clean and fresh."

"I found the bagels here to be delicious and fantastic."

Good to know

1

Placing an order and arranging pickup is very easy.

2

They use high-quality organic ingredients in their sourdough bread.

3

Online ordering is available for pickup or delivery.

02
Safadi Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Space blends traditional Palestinian decor with artisanal bagels in zaatar and matcha flavors. Calm, welcoming vibe shines through sunlight streaming and good music. Cream cheese with salt and pepper adds a simple, tasty touch.

Artisanal bagels come with zaatar and matcha flavors. Cream cheese with salt and pepper adds a simple but effective touch.

People are saying

"The coffee shop's atmosphere is beautiful, cozy, and calming."

"Their specialty drinks are so unique, I wanted to try them all."

"The zaatar bagel with labne is delicious."

Good to know

1

Safadi Coffee closes at 9pm.

2

The menu features unique Palestinian-themed items.

3

The establishment is family-friendly and accommodating to children.

03
Hen's Deli image 1

Small space with a retro vibe and eclectic global music offers a cozy spot. Bagels are fresh and chewy with unique flavors like pickle bagels and vegan cream cheese. Sidewalk seating provides great people-watching and the decor includes VHS tapes and board games for a friendly feel.

Bagels come fresh and hot with a chewy texture and soft inside. Options include everything, rosemary, and pickle bagels, paired with generous cream cheese and many vegan choices.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwich here was the best I've ever had."

"I found the bagels here to be the best in Milwaukee."

"I thought this was the best deli in the city."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but it's best to arrive early due to limited seating.

2

Expect a wait time during peak lunch hours, especially on weekdays.

3

They offer a variety of vegetarian options on the menu.

04
Allie Boy’s Bagelry & Luncheonette | East Side image 1

Enjoy real New York style bagels with fresh, flavorful options like Asiago and the Count. Stylish decor sets a cool vibe while imaginative specials and vegan options add variety. Busy spot means early visits help avoid sellouts.

Bagels stand out for their excellent quality and variety, including options like Asiago and the Count with a runny egg. The Bagel Lox and Cream Cheese gets special attention with custom preparation.

People are saying

"I had the best breakfast sandwich with a BEC and hash brown."

"I found the bagels here to be the best I had ever had."

"I found the matzah ball soup so satisfying on a chilly day."

Good to know

1

The bagelry is closed on Mondays, which may affect weekend plans.

2

Street parking is available at both locations for easy access.

3

The menu features a variety of bagels and sandwiches, with generous portions.

05
Roast Coffee Company image 1

Small coffee shop with cream-city limestone walls offers a cozy vibe and ample outlets for work. Bagels like the egg bacon cheese and radio Milwaukee shine fresh and hot. Rotating local art and great music make it a chill spot for meetings or solo time.

Bagels come out hot and fresh, especially the egg bacon cheese bagel and the radio Milwaukee bagel with dill cream cheese. Sandwiches are spectacular and pair well with coffee for a solid combo.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was the best I've ever had."

"It's a great work-friendly spot for studying or getting work done."

"I enjoyed their spectacular bagel sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Roast Coffee offers a pop-up kiosk at various events throughout the year.

2

The coffee bar is a popular feature at weddings and special events.

3

Roast provides cold brew kegs for events, perfect for large gatherings.

06
Ruby's Bagels on North Avenue image 1

Bright, clean decor and old building charm create a cozy, inviting space. Bagels like Rosemary Sea Salt and Guilty Guava show true craftsmanship. Despite limited seating, steady crowds prove its popularity.

Bagels come fresh daily with care and craftsmanship in every bite. Options like the Rosemary Sea Salt and Guilty Guava bagels stand out for their flavor and quality.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the best I ever had."

"I thought the breakfast sandwich was the best I ever had."

"I thought the bagel texture was absolutely perfect."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of 15-20 minutes for your order.

2

The bagels are made fresh daily, but they can sell out quickly.

3

Seating is limited, so plan to take your order to go during busy hours.

07
Sprocket Cafe image 1

Small cafe offers fresh bagel sandwiches with toasted egg and vegetarian options, often topped with cucumber. Cozy, eclectic vibe shines through vintage photos and old gameboards on the walls. Quick, friendly service complements the unique setting overlooking a pocket park.

Bagel sandwiches come with toasted egg and a vegetarian option. Adding cucumber to the egg bagel sandwich is common. Service is quick and friendly.

People are saying

"I found the coffee shop's atmosphere to be absolutely amazing and super cool."

"I found the bagel sandwiches to be delicious and appealing."

"It's a cozy place to relax and chat with friends."

Good to know

1

Expect to spend between $10 and $20 for a meal at the cafe.

2

There is an extra charge for cream cheese with bagels.

3

Flavoring in lattes incurs an additional cost.

08
Avenue Coffeehouse image 1

Small coffee shop offers rosemary bagel with cheddar jalapeno cream cheese and tasty avocado toast. Cozy indoor seating and a charming outdoor patio create a welcoming atmosphere. Unique touches like an axolotl fish tank and classic tunes add to the peaceful, cottage-like vibe.

Rosemary bagel stands out with cheddar jalapeno cream cheese. Bagels come alongside avocado toast and a few other options.

People are saying

"I thought their latte was the best I ever tried."

"This cafe's staff is super friendly and welcoming."

"I had the best bagel I ever had."

Good to know

1

They offer delightful drink specials and delicious toasts at the end of the week.

2

They now have a punch card program for free coffee or pastries.

3

There are lots of parking options available nearby.

09
Ruby’s Bagels at Zócalo image 1

Lively food truck park offers a strong community vibe and fresh New York style bagels with a crisp exterior and fluffy interior. Vegan options and generous cream cheese portions attract early risers. The rosemary bagel and high-quality lox make for a standout flavor combo.

New York style bagels have a crisp exterior and fluffy interior. The lox and cream cheese topping is high quality and pairs well. The rosemary bagel stands out as a favorite flavor. Bagel sandwiches and coffee complement the fresh bagels nicely.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be the best I've ever had."

"I found their coffee to be the closest to NYC coffee I have encountered."

"This food, the breakfast sandwich, had fresh eggs and melted cheese."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arrive early for the best selection.

2

Expect a wait time of less than five minutes for fresh bagels.

3

Vegan options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

10
Valentine Coffee Roasters Third Ward image 1

Brick walls and tall wood ceilings create a warm atmosphere perfect for work or breaks. The lox bagel shines with fresh, simple flavors. Breakfast options include customizable egg sandwiches and burritos, making it a cozy spot for any morning.

The lox bagel stands out with its fresh flavor and simple preparation. The breakfast menu includes egg sandwiches and burritos, with options to customize like adding egg to the bagel.

People are saying

"The baristas here are super friendly and make excellent coffee."

"I thought the breakfast sandwiches here were delicious."

"The lox bagel with egg is one of the best I had."

Good to know

1

They offer free coffee with any purchase.

2

The cafe allows small dogs inside.

3

They provide gluten-free and vegan options on the menu.

11
Biggby Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Spacious coffee shop offers a quiet atmosphere and half booths with outlets ideal for work or study. Bagels arrive fresh and hot, with the turkey havarti everything bagel as a standout. Busy times bring long lines at the small drive-thru lane.

Bagels come out fresh and hot with options like the turkey havarti everything bagel standing out. Some orders miss extra cream cheese or advertised vegan options, causing confusion at times.

People are saying

"I found the coffee here to be excellent and delicious."

"I love their breakfast sandwiches, they're always piping hot."

"The bagels here have the nicest staff ever."

Good to know

1

Biggby Coffee features a drive-thru and a large interior area for seating.

2

During busy hours, expect long lines at the drive-thru due to limited space.

3

Parking can be limited during peak times, especially with drive-thru traffic.

12
Bruegger's Bagels image 1

Bagel shop serves freshly made bagels with a chewy texture and unique sandwiches like brisket and jalapeño egg. Seating includes both indoor and outdoor options, though indoor may close sometimes. Known for busy weekends and some of the best bagels in town.

Bagels come out freshly made each day with a nice, chewy texture and plenty of options for schmears. Bagel sandwiches include unique choices like brisket and egg with jalapeño flavor.

People are saying

"These bagels are freshly made and always delicious."

"I found the bagels and sandwiches to be enjoyable."

"I found the food to be always fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bruegger's Bagels can get pretty busy on Saturday and Sunday.

2

Expect longer wait times during peak hours on weekends.

3

There were five tables outside, with three having chairs.

13
Einstein Bros. Bagels image 1

Spacious bagel shop offers cheddar jalapeño and Nova lox bagels with rich flavors. Drive-through and pickup only create a calm, cozy atmosphere despite lively staff chatter. Prices are higher but match the quality focus and friendly vibe.

Bagels come in cheddar jalapeño and Nova lox varieties with solid, delicious flavors. Hot egg and bagel sandwiches pair well with coffee or tea for a hearty breakfast.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels were delicious."

"I found the sandwich to be ridiculously good."

"The Drive Thru is so convenient and fast."

Good to know

1

Drive-thru and pickup options are available; indoor seating is currently closed.

2

Expect to pay around $8-9 for a single bagel sandwich.

3

Mobile ordering is easy and convenient for quick service.

14
Best Place Coffee & Spirits image 1

Historic charm shines with leaded glass windows and a quaint courtyard. Bagels are perfectly toasted but cream cheese service varies. Quiet, dog-friendly patio and wifi make it great for work or reading.

Bagels come out perfectly toasted and enjoyable. Cream cheese spreading and toasting by staff can be inconsistent.

People are saying

"The coffee staff here is so sweet and friendly."

"The staff here is so friendly and knowledgeable about PBR history."

"I loved the coffee and the lattes were delicious."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop offers a full menu of drinks and food options.

2

Expect longer wait times during busy hours, especially for iced drinks.

3

The shop is an easy walk from the county courthouse.

15
Coffeeville Company image 1

Repurposed train depot design creates a unique vibe with video windows showing virtual trains. Bagels smell great, especially the Mechanic Bagel, and cost about $5.99 with cream cheese. Enjoy live music and cozy seating both indoors and outdoors.

Bagels have a good smell and taste. The Mechanic Bagel stands out, and a plain bagel with cream cheese costs about $5.99.

People are saying

"The baristas here are so friendly and always greet you with a smile."

"The train station theme here is really cool."

"I thought the bagels were good."

Good to know

1

Expect to pay around $12 for a sandwich without sides.

2

Live music performances happen at noon on select days.

3

The coffee shop offers a variety of fresh-made sandwiches, soups, and pastries.

Discover more

Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...