Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Waukesha

Sandwich spots

You want a sandwich that is made properly and doesn't cut corners.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Cafe De Arts Roasters image 1
Cafe De Arts Roasters image 2
Cafe De Arts Roasters image 3
View all

Colorful cafe with Mediterranean decor and African artifacts creates a warm, cozy atmosphere. Comfortable seating includes a dog-friendly patio with outdoor space. The vibe is welcoming and relaxed, attracting those who appreciate unique design and community feel.

Creativity shines in the food, with staff willing to customize dishes. The food and coffee consistently impress, paired with pastries that complement the menu well.

Breakfast sandwiches feature light, fluffy eggs and come with a leafy, fruity salad dressed well. Options include Mediterranean, chicken pesto, veggie, and tuna sandwiches, all fresh and flavorful with good value.

People are saying

"The coffee here is served with kindness and a smile."

"I found the food and coffee to be delicious."

"I found the sandwich and coffee to be delicious."

Good to know

1

They offer gluten-free options on the menu.

2

The coffee is always fresh as they roast beans on-site.

3

The cafe has plenty of seating and no long waits.

02
Louโ€™s Lucky Penny - Pub & Grub image 1

Small bar with cozy interior and a spacious outdoor patio featuring large TVs. Atmosphere shifts from friendly and local to loud and energetic in the main bar area. Offers pool table, dart boards, and slot machines for entertainment.

Wings stand out as a highlight with consistently great food across the menu. The food pairs well with good bourbon and comes with excellent service.

Steak sandwich and tenderloin sandwich stand out for their flavor and value. The sauced chopped chicken sandwich also ranks as a favorite, alongside solid chicken sandwiches served with fries.

People are saying

"The bar food here, especially the wings, is outstanding and delicious."

"The food here is great and delicious."

"I thought their wings were big and delicious."

Good to know

1

They have a wing special on Tuesdays and Fridays.

2

Happy hour is available on weekdays, but specific offerings may vary.

3

The bar is known for its cleanliness and friendly atmosphere.

03
Jack's Cafe image 1
American restaurant

Quaint historic building combines antique decor with outdoor seating in a small community setting. Atmosphere feels rustic and homey but can get loud and crowded, making conversation difficult. Location is off the beaten path, offering a hidden, charming experience.

Soup, salads, and sandwiches make up the menu, all unique and very tasty. The food leans toward the healthy side and pairs well with the quaint atmosphere.

Unique sandwiches stand out here, with options like the turkey pesto and chicken salad sandwich that many find delicious. The menu focuses on soup and sandwiches, offering a tasty, sandwich-centered experience.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are delicious, especially the turkey pesto."

"The food here is unique and delicious; I loved the homemade soups."

"The food here is unique and really tasty."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to limited seating.

2

The cafe closes at 2pm, so plan your visit accordingly.

3

Parking is available on-site but can fill up quickly.

04
The Station Pub & Grill image 1

Cozy corner bar with friendly, welcoming atmosphere and an up north vibe. Outdoor space includes horseshoes and 18-hole soccer golf for extra entertainment. Known for excellent fish fry and grilled wings, it draws a lively crowd especially on weekend nights.

Food here is fresh and homemade, with a focus on fish fry and BBQ specials. Prices stay reasonable while the quality remains consistently good.

Smoked pulled pork sandwiches come with a vinegar-based coleslaw featuring chopped celery and peppers. Specials include smoked turkey with au jus and a classic Reuben. Sandwich prices range from $10 to $18.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be excellent and great."

"The fish fry here is amazing and perfectly prepared."

"I had the best pulled pork sandwich, it was smoked perfectly."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a Friday fish fry with multiple fish species available.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait for a table and another 45 minutes for food on busy nights.

3

Handicapped access is limited, with only high-top tables available.

05
Tropical Smoothie Cafe image 1

Juice shop offers a chill, tropical vibe with a clean, friendly atmosphere. It features healthy, customizable options and a drive-thru for convenience. The place maintains a lively yet relaxed energy with good music playing.

Food comes out fresh and hot with perfectly prepared portions. Service is quick and the flavors stay consistently excellent and satisfying.

Panini sandwich stands out as a solid choice. Other sandwiches and wraps vary, with some falling below expectations and a notable 41-minute wait for service.

People are saying

"I thought the smoothies here tasted amazing and were the best."

"The food and smoothies here are always great and fresh."

"I found the smoothies to be delicious and filling."

Good to know

1

This location has a drive-thru for convenient ordering.

2

The restaurant is consistently clean and well-maintained.

3

You can customize your smoothie and food to meet your preferences.

06
John's Drive-In image 1
Fast food restaurant

Traditional drive-in with outdoor picnic tables and a nostalgic old-time vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere. Families gather around play areas for kids while enjoying classic fast food. The setting feels well cared for and offers a simple, satisfying experience.

Food comes out quickly and stays hot and fresh. The menu offers tasty options with a side of refreshing root beer.

Chicken sandwiches come in several varieties like classic and parm, both with solid flavor. Pulled pork sandwiches have very little meat and sandwiches overall tend to be small in size.

People are saying

"I thought the root beer floats were the best I had anywhere."

"I found the root beer float to be amazing and worth returning for."

"I loved the chicken parm sandwich."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and seating is first-come, first-served.

2

The drive-in is open year-round, even in winter.

3

No dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.

07
The Neighbors Bar & Grille image 1

Bar and grill with many TVs showing various sports and a loud atmosphere caused by high ceilings and hard surfaces. Outdoor patio offers a breathtaking view and casual seating. The vibe feels friendly and welcoming, with a strong locals presence.

Food consistently delivers great flavor and excellent quality. Meals and desserts regularly hit the spot with satisfying taste.

Grilled sandwiches like the prime rib and reuben stand out with solid flavors. The club sandwich impresses, while the panco crusted cod sandwich comes out soggy and bland.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was outstanding."

"The bar's food menu was excellent and unexpected."

"The grilled sandwiches here are perfectly done."

Good to know

1

Parking can be a challenge during busier times due to limited spaces.

2

The pasta special costs $24, which some may find overpriced.

3

The restaurant has a full bar menu with a variety of drinks.

08
Backstreet Pub image 1
Bar & grill

Sports bar atmosphere with open bar area and multiple TVs creates a lively setting. Loud, fun crowd gathers especially on fry nights, with pool tables covered for extra seating. Known for excellent fish fry and homemade potato pancakes, it offers a welcoming, local vibe that feels like family.

Food here stands out for its amazing quality and consistent fantastic taste. Service supports the experience with attentive staff who check in regularly, even when busy.

The sandwich features a Backstreet BLT with only two small pieces of bacon. It lacks solidity and feels underwhelming compared to even simple homemade sandwiches.

People are saying

"You have to try their Friday fish fry; it's the tastiest in the area."

"The food here is amazing."

"I thought the sandwiches here tasted very good."

Good to know

1

Tuesday night Bingo starts at 7pm; arrive early for good seats.

2

Taco Tuesday features $2 tacos and runs all day.

3

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

09
Dady-Oh's Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Historic building with Americana decor and Christian themes creates a cozy, nostalgic atmosphere. Seating is ample, and partial kitchen views add to the experience. The vibe feels warm and welcoming, with a quiet yet lively energy.

Food features delicious home cooked meals with great taste and good value. Service complements the enjoyable dining experience.

Cold and very fresh club sandwich stands out. The roast beef sandwich tastes delicious.

People are saying

"The food here is fresh and delicious."

"I always had a great breakfast here."

"I loved my roast beef sandwich; it was so fresh."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only, which is not mentioned anywhere.

2

Expect long wait times for food even when the restaurant is not busy.

3

Prices are reasonable, with a typical meal costing around $33 for two.

10
Rosati's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers a homey atmosphere with thin crust pizza that is full of toppings and crispy outside. Delivery often takes longer than expected, sometimes over an hour. Sub sandwiches and wings receive positive remarks for size and flavor.

Food quality is generally good with prompt preparation under the new owner. Some find the food delicious, while others note issues with customer service and food consistency.

Cheef Sandwiches stand out with their flavor, paired well with Zeppoliโ€™s. The Italian beef sandwich offers a solid taste, and sub sandwiches come in large portions.

People are saying

"I found the pizza to be delicious and awesome."

"The new owner really cares about the sandwich they serve."

"I thought the food here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Delivery usually takes over an hour, so plan accordingly.

2

Check the hours online before ordering, as they may be incorrect.

3

Prices are considered good compared to other pizza places.

11
Cousins Subs image 1
Sandwich shop

Drive-through service supports quick meal pickups with consistent taste and quality. Clean and welcoming environment uses eco-friendly packaging and offers fresh bread and hot fries. Unique menu items include cheese curds and a pretzel bun option.

Food comes out fresh and made to order every time. Staff prepare meals exactly as requested, keeping everything clean and fresh.

Sandwiches come out hot and fresh, often matching the classic taste from the 1970s. Some sandwiches have extra jalapenos, which can be quite strong, but overall the flavor and freshness hit the mark.

People are saying

"The food here is good, and the staff is friendly."

"This sandwich was hot and delicious, just like I remembered."

"The drive-thru employee was super friendly and cheered me up."

Good to know

1

Online orders at Cousins Subs take 20 to 40 minutes to be ready.

2

Pre-ordering online may lead to long wait times.

3

The drive-through is available for convenient service.

Discover more

Waukesha, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...