Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Waukesha

American food spots

A classic, hearty meal provides the comfort of a familiar, well-prepared plate.

Based on 665 Opinions
+662
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Club 400 Bar and Grill image 1
Club 400 Bar and Grill image 2
Club 400 Bar and Grill image 3
View all

Building dates back to the 1800s with historic memorabilia and a nostalgic bar area downstairs. Atmosphere is lively and friendly, featuring private event spaces with full bars and catering options. Wings and burgers stand out as top local food offerings.

Food comes out super fast and is phenomenal with reasonable prices. Staff checks in to ensure satisfaction, and drinks are served cold alongside great meals.

Chicken wings stand out with their consistent quality and classic taste. Burgers and Reuben sandwiches also deliver strong flavors that fit well with traditional American food.

People are saying

"The food here is great, especially the wings."

"The owner educated us on the history and beauty of this historical site."

"The American Food here feels like home, thanks to the friendly owners."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night happens every Friday at 9pm with no cover charge.

2

Xtreme bar bingo takes place every Wednesday at 7pm; arrive early for a good seat.

3

Music trivia is hosted every Tuesday at 8pm; teams can have up to six players.

02
Mayor's Restaurant image 1

Historic building blends casual atmosphere with modern touches and spacious layout. Music plays somewhat loud, creating a lively vibe. Popular spot fills early, attracting a crowd that appreciates affordable quality and a welcoming environment.

Food comes out piping hot with huge portions and reasonable prices. Service matches the quality, making meals consistently enjoyable.

Spare ribs come in a fair portion with fries. Cajun chicken pasta features a flavorful sauce and two soft breadsticks. Ribeye steak cooks to perfection. Hash browns add a classic touch.

People are saying

"The glazed salmon here is delicious and perfectly cooked."

"The food here is excellent, fresh, and flavorful."

"The American food portions here are huge, you'll have leftovers."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on Fridays.

2

Parking is limited; arrive early to secure a spot.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of allergy-friendly menu options.

03
Dave's Family Restaurant image 1

Small, crowded space with old school diner design and tight booths creates a hometown feel. Atmosphere stays busy and warm, reflecting a classic diner vibe. Seating options include counter, tables, and booths, enhancing the traditional experience.

Food comes fresh and cooked to order with good quality and great prices. Watching employees prepare breakfast right in front adds to the experience.

New York strip steak comes in generous portions and pairs well with eggs. Classic American dishes like hamburgers and fries, hash browns, and grilled cheese are solid choices here.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was hot and fresh."

"I thought the breakfast food was great."

"The American Food here, especially the steak and eggs, is amazing."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a wide selection of breakfast items and great specials.

2

Reservations are recommended for large groups, especially on weekends.

3

Expect affordable prices, particularly for seniors.

04
The Station Pub & Grill image 1

Cozy corner bar with friendly, welcoming atmosphere and an up north vibe. Outdoor space includes horseshoes and 18-hole soccer golf for extra entertainment. Known for excellent fish fry and grilled wings, it draws a lively crowd especially on weekend nights.

Food here is fresh and homemade, with a focus on fish fry and BBQ specials. Prices stay reasonable while the quality remains consistently good.

Pulled pork sandwiches and Reuben sandwiches stand out with smoked barbecue flavors and au jus on the side. The menu also features beer battered cod, coleslaw, and potato pancakes with apple sauce, plus solid cheeseburgers and wraps.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be excellent and great."

"The fish fry here is amazing and perfectly prepared."

"I tried the American Food, and the grilled wings tasted perfect."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a Friday fish fry with multiple fish species available.

2

Expect a 45-minute wait for a table and another 45 minutes for food on busy nights.

3

Handicapped access is limited, with only high-top tables available.

05
The Neighbors Bar & Grille image 1

Bar and grill with many TVs showing various sports and a loud atmosphere caused by high ceilings and hard surfaces. Outdoor patio offers a breathtaking view and casual seating. The vibe feels friendly and welcoming, with a strong locals presence.

Food consistently delivers great flavor and excellent quality. Meals and desserts regularly hit the spot with satisfying taste.

Prime rib sandwich, homemade clam chowder, and fried chicken stand out as solid American food choices. The reuben, fish fry with blue gill, club sandwich, and garlic Parmesan chicken wings also offer variety.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was outstanding."

"The bar's food menu was excellent and unexpected."

"I loved their fish fry and potato pancakes."

Good to know

1

Parking can be a challenge during busier times due to limited spaces.

2

The pasta special costs $24, which some may find overpriced.

3

The restaurant has a full bar menu with a variety of drinks.

06
The Red Rooster image 1
Bar & grill

Bar and grill offers a laid back and friendly atmosphere with a large seating area and outdoor patio. The interior features an old school style with a cool black environment and understated elegance. It tends to be loud and busy, making it a popular spot that often has wait times for seating.

Food here stands out for its great quality and excellent taste. Consistently paired with good service, the meals impress with their flavor and presentation.

Prime rib sandwich stands out with shaved meat and rich flavor. Burgers, chicken wings, and a patty melt with haystack onions offer solid American classics. Campfire mac and cheese adds a comforting twist.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be fantastic and perfectly cooked."

"I thought the fish fry was great and the walleye particularly good."

"The American food, like the prime rib sandwich, is delicious."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available for visitors.

2

Expect at least a 30-minute wait time for a table during peak hours.

3

Call ahead to reserve if dining with five or more people.

07
Golden Chicken image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food spot with carry-out only service and a family vibe during busy times. The space shows signs of wear, including a leaking roof with buckets inside. Known for excellent fried chicken and ribs, it offers affordable prices despite some recent increases.

Food arrives exactly on time and tastes consistently top notch. The menu offers very good and tasty dishes with reliable quality every visit.

Fried chicken stands out with its crispy on the bone texture and a recipe that beats grocery deli or fast food versions. Meals come with a basket of fries, a roll, and a small container of coleslaw.

People are saying

"The food here is always delicious and piping hot."

"I thought the fried chicken here was some of the best I've had."

"I thought the fried chicken here was some of the best American food I've had."

Good to know

1

Golden Chicken offers carry out only; there is no seating available.

2

Expect a quick service experience with minimal wait times for carryout.

3

The food is ready exactly on time and served hot.

08
The Crossings Restaurant image 1

Bright, clean diner with a cozy, inviting atmosphere and an eating counter. Regulars enjoy daily specials and homestyle pancakes cooked perfectly with real buttermilk. The space includes big games adding a casual, friendly vibe.

Food here is consistently amazing with freshly prepared dishes and good portions that satisfy hunger. The meals come with friendly service and a beautiful atmosphere.

Hash browns come out done just right. Biscuits and gravy serve more like a soup and cold dish.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, truly delicious."

"The staff here always greets you with smiles during breakfast."

"The American Food here, especially the omelets, really rocked."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a variety of breakfast selections.

2

Daily specials provide unique menu options.

3

Prices are reasonable, with a Diet Coke priced at $4.

09
George Webb Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

American diner with clean, cozy ambiance and cool decor offers a diverse menu featuring thin burgers and classic breakfast items. Atmosphere stays lively and inviting, suitable for both intimate dinners and group gatherings. Staff and service stand out for respect and friendliness.

Food arrives fresh and crispy, served quickly with fantastic service. The dishes are consistently delicious and well-prepared.

Hash browns come out crispy and well-seasoned. The biscuits and gravy with sausage offer a rich, hearty flavor that stands out.

People are saying

"The food here is always fresh and hot."

"My breakfast was excellent and delicious."

"I loved the hash browns and biscuits and gravy."

Good to know

1

The price at George Webb Restaurant is very reasonable for the quality offered.

2

The menu offers a diverse range of options catering to various tastes and dietary preferences.

3

Expect clean facilities, including impressively maintained bathrooms.

10
Sunset Family Restaurant image 1
Family restaurant

Old-school Midwestern diner with outdated interiors and a big open room creates a friendly, family atmosphere. Noise levels vary but generally suit families with children. Seating is comfortable and the space feels clean despite its age.

Food offers consistent quality with scrumptious flavors and accommodates special requests well. Wait staff complements the experience with friendly service.

Menu includes a huge variety of dishes like sandwiches, multi-course dinners, and Greek-American specialties. Biscuits and gravy stand out as really good, with buttery eggs and freshly made fried chicken also featured.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast here to be good and tasty."

"The American food here is great, especially the huge portions."

"I thought the food here was amazing and affordable."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers large portions at affordable prices.

2

Expect limited parking availability during peak hours.

3

The restaurant closes at 3 pm daily.

11
Fuzzy's Southside Pub & Grill image 1

Small town bar vibe blends with retro diner style in a clean, well-lit space. Atmosphere stays friendly and relaxed, with people enjoying sports and bar games without loud noise. Known for great burgers and fish fry, it offers a casual spot with a familiar, unpretentious feel.

Food offers a huge variety with plenty of portions that are very filling. Quality stays consistent with good taste and value for the price.

Hamburgers stand out with options like the 'Everything but the Kitchen Sink' and cheeseburgers topped with a huge stack of onion strings. Brisket nachos, clam chowder, waffle fries, and patty melts also feature on the menu.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and very filling."

"I thought the burgers here were great and delicious."

"I loved the burgers and fries here; they were excellent."

Good to know

1

Parking at Fuzzy's Southside Pub & Grill is plentiful and not an issue.

2

The beer price is great at $5 for a pint of craft beer on a Friday night.

3

The menu has a fantastic variety from breakfast to lunch to dinner.

12
Backstreet Pub image 1
Bar & grill

Sports bar atmosphere with open bar area and multiple TVs creates a lively setting. Loud, fun crowd gathers especially on fry nights, with pool tables covered for extra seating. Known for excellent fish fry and homemade potato pancakes, it offers a welcoming, local vibe that feels like family.

Food here stands out for its amazing quality and consistent fantastic taste. Service supports the experience with attentive staff who check in regularly, even when busy.

Creamy Clam Chowder and amazing coleslaw stand out. Wings, pizza, Philly cheesesteak, grilled cheese, and a BLT sandwich round out the classic American options.

People are saying

"You have to try their Friday fish fry; it's the tastiest in the area."

"The food here is amazing."

"Their fish fry is a solid American food choice with crispy, light breading."

Good to know

1

Tuesday night Bingo starts at 7pm; arrive early for good seats.

2

Taco Tuesday features $2 tacos and runs all day.

3

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

13
Mainstream Bar and Grill image 1

Small interior with tight seating and a nostalgic 80s theme creates a cozy yet lively setting. Loud live music and bar chatter fill the space, making it energetic but sometimes challenging for quiet conversation. Outdoor patio offers a quieter alternative with enjoyable live entertainment.

Food features great taste and consistent quality with a focus on bar food that is both delicious and reasonably priced. Takeout options are available for those who want to enjoy the flavors at home.

Hamburgers stand out as a highlight, often described as amazing and the best in the area. The menu also features scallop nachos with strong value and tasty flavors, alongside funnel cake fries served with multiple dipping sauces.

People are saying

"I thought their burgers might be the best in Waukesha."

"The food, especially the burgers, was so flavorful and cooked perfectly."

"I thought the American food, especially the hamburgers, were amazing."

Good to know

1

Karaoke night happens every Wednesday evening with no cover charge.

2

Live music is featured every Saturday night starting at 9 PM.

3

Wing night on Thursdays offers .75 wings, a great deal for visitors.

14
Jet's Pizza image 1
Pizza delivery

Detroit-style pizza with crunchy, flaky crust defines the menu, offering thick, greasy comfort food that fills and satisfies. Bright, clean take-away setup supports fast service and well-priced deals, making it a practical choice for quick meals.

Food here is thick and greasy comfort style. Meals often arrive cold and late.

Detroit style pizza stands out with its thick crust and corner slices. The Jet 10 and Greek salad offer a solid introduction to this regional American food.

People are saying

"I thought the Detroit style pizza was crunchy and tasty."

"The food here is so greasy and satisfying."

"I loved the Detroit style pizza; it's different and great."

Good to know

1

Jet's Pizza is primarily a take-away joint with no dine-in options.

2

The lunch deal offers two slices and a soda at a great price.

3

Expect quick service; pizzas are usually ready when promised.

15
John's Drive-In image 1
Fast food restaurant

Traditional drive-in with outdoor picnic tables and a nostalgic old-time vibe creates a welcoming atmosphere. Families gather around play areas for kids while enjoying classic fast food. The setting feels well cared for and offers a simple, satisfying experience.

Food comes out quickly and stays hot and fresh. The menu offers tasty options with a side of refreshing root beer.

Pulled pork sandwiches and nacho dogs stand out on the menu. Classic sides like onion rings and root beer floats complement the American food offerings well.

People are saying

"I thought the root beer floats were the best I had anywhere."

"I loved the fish fry; it was the best I had ever had."

"I found the root beer float to be amazing and worth returning for."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and seating is first-come, first-served.

2

The drive-in is open year-round, even in winter.

3

No dogs are allowed in the outdoor seating area.

Discover more

Waukesha, Wisconsin

Area guide
Loading Map...