Small bagel shop buzzes with modern kiosks and a friendly vibe. Bagels shine with perfect texture and a standout scallion smear. Outdoor seating welcomes dogs, making it a cute spot for casual dining.
Bagels here stand out for their exceptional quality and perfect texture. The scallion smear on a lox everything bagel is a notable highlight.
"I thought Olmo had the best bagels in New Haven."
"I had the greatest egg sandwich I ever tasted."
"These bagels are chewy, crispy, flavorful, and life-changing."
Good to know
Parking can be challenging, especially during peak morning hours.
Ordering ahead is advised due to high demand in the mornings.
The establishment has outdoor seating only, so dress accordingly for the weather.
Purple decor sets a cozy atmosphere with fresh coffee scents. Bagels arrive warm and fresh, topped with just enough cream cheese. Regulars enjoy personalized greetings, making it a friendly spot near transit for quick stops.
Bagels come out naturally warm and fresh with a reasonable amount of cream cheese applied. Options like sesame and everything bagels are served without toasting and pair well with coffee.
Good to know
Tiffany's Place opens at 5am, perfect for early risers.
Expect a variety of coffee flavors brewed into hot and iced options.
Prices for drinks and treats are very reasonable for a local shop.
Fresh sourdough bagels boast a thin eggshell crust and chewy texture rivaling NYC's best. Croissants are flaky with unique flavors. Friendly owners add welcoming charm in a small, takeout-only spot where treats sell out fast.
Bagels have a thin, eggshell-like crust and a great chew. The raisin sourdough bagel offers a slight hint of cinnamon, and the overall quality rivals top NYC bagels.
Good to know
The bakery is takeout only, with street parking available.
Expect long lines, especially in the morning when they open.
Arrive early for warm, fresh-out-of-the-oven treats.
Shop offers a warm, welcoming vibe with retro décor and classic tunes. Bagels shine with unique flavors like black truffle and pepperoni pizza, staying soft and fresh daily. Limited dine-in seats create a relaxed pace perfect for savoring these special treats.
Bagels come in unique flavors like black truffle, pepperoni pizza, and cinnamon roll. The texture stays super soft and fresh daily, with limited-run character bagels adding a fun twist.
Good to know
Parking can be challenging during rush hour, lunch, and weekends, with metered parking available.
Britt & Co. Bagels does not have posted hours and operates based on how busy it is, so calling ahead is advised.
It can get busy during peak hours, but orders come out quickly and accurately.
Bright, clean spot with a friendly vibe offers over 20 bagel varieties like jalapeño cheese and French toast. Bagels are fresh, crunchy, and chewy with bold flavors. Sandwiches shine with bacon, egg, and cheese and tender chicken cutlets in a casual setting.
Bagels come out fresh early every morning, with a crunchy and chewy texture. Plenty of flavor options include spicy jalapeño and classic everything, all delivering consistent quality and bold taste.
Good to know
There is plenty of parking available at The Cranbury Plaza.
The Bagel Spot offers vegan cream cheese options.
Expect a line on weekends, but it moves quickly.
Fresh bagels boast a crispy outside and chewy inside, capturing authentic New York style. Friendly staff deliver orders right to your car in a small, informal parking lot setting. Prices are high, reflecting the premium quality and limited seating.
Bagels have a crispy outside and a perfectly chewy inside. Staff are kind and generous, often bringing bagels and spreads directly to your car.
Good to know
Reservations are required at least a week in advance for orders.
The bagels are made fresh daily and sell out quickly.
A minimum purchase of three bagels is required for orders.
Bright, clean space with a friendly vibe from regulars. Bagels have a crispy exterior and soft inside, with a standout veggie cream cheese option. Sandwiches like the perfect tuna melt earn consistent praise.
Bagels come with a crispy exterior and a soft, chewy interior. The lox and cream cheese bagel is packed with lox and tastes fresh, reminding of childhood memories.
Good to know
Joseph's Bagel & Grill closes at 1 PM on Sundays.
Prices are reasonable, and they offer free bagels on certain occasions.
They have a lox bagel on the menu.
Spacious coffee shop offers a cozy atmosphere with soft jazz music. Bagels are fresh and tasty, featuring cheddar options like bacon, egg, and cheese. Friendly staff ensure quick fixes and a welcoming environment for all visitors.
Bagels come out fresh and delicious with solid options like egg & cheese and bacon, egg, and cheese on cheddar. Staff correct mistakes quickly, ensuring the right cream cheese on your bagel.
Good to know
Parking is easy with a lot right out front.
The shop is very clean and well-maintained.
Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.
Classic bakery offers wide variety of fresh cakes, breads, and pastries. Bagels shine with wonderful texture and flavor, paired well with mini cannoli and cheese Danish. Clean, inviting atmosphere and a small deli add to the charm.
Breads and bagels stand out with their wonderful texture and flavor. Mini cannoli, cookies, and cheese Danish complement the delicious bagels well.
Good to know
Ambrosia Bakery closes earlier than the posted times on some days.
The sourdough bread sells out quickly, so call ahead or go early to reserve it.
They have a nice variety of cakes and biscuits available.
Old school bakery offers freshly made bagels with a crunchy outside and soft inside texture. Variety includes onion, rainbow, and pumpernickel. Lively, busy atmosphere with long lines shows its popularity.
Bagels come out toasted to perfection with a crunchy outside and soft inside texture. The selection includes onion, rainbow, egg, everything, and pumpernickel varieties, all fresh and chewy.
Good to know
Expect to wait during busy times, especially later in the day.
Calling ahead is advised to avoid long wait times.
Fresh bagels are made while you wait, ensuring quality.
Bakery offers fresh sourdough bagels toasted to perfection and priced around six dollars. Cozy, cramped space opens to a pleasant courtyard for eating and drinking. Known for high-quality pastries, it draws a steady crowd seeking top baked goods.
Bagels come out toasted and fresh, with a solid sourdough base. Prices run around six dollars for a single bagel, matching the quality of their English muffins and other baked goods.
Good to know
The bakery is closed on Sunday and Monday.
There is no inside seating available.
Online pre-orders are easy and convenient.
Small spot with pink picnic tables offers fresh, soft bagels daily and well-made pizza. Casual, friendly vibe feels like a New York corner store near the beach. Quick service suits outdoor eating or takeout.
Fresh bagels appear daily with a soft texture that stands out during breakfast service. The bagels consistently look appealing on display and pair well with the pizza offerings.
Good to know
Slices cost only $2.50, making it an affordable option for a quick meal.
The food is prepared quickly, usually within 20 minutes.
They offer delivery services for convenience.
Bakery buzzes with a warm vibe and offers fresh bagels that taste great and keep locals coming back. Prices stay low, making it perfect for a quick breakfast. Drive-thru adds easy access while simple seating invites a casual stop.
Fresh bagels come out every time, with a delicious taste that keeps people coming back for decades. Prices stay great, making it a solid spot for a quick and satisfying breakfast.
Good to know
Parking during the early morning rush could be hard.
The grill closes at 4 pm, which is earlier than expected.
Everything is made fresh daily, ensuring quality.
Small coffee shop feels like a neighborhood living room with high tin ceilings and warm, cozy vibe. Bagels offer vegan butter and pair well with a lavender latte. Friendly regulars and owners create a lowkey community space.
Bagels come with four vegan milk options and vegan butter. The berry cream cheese bagel pairs well with a lavender latte.
Good to know
Kaiyden's is dog-friendly and offers treats for dogs.
They have four vegan milk options and vegan butter for bagels.
House-made syrups are available, offering unique flavors.
Small coffee shop shines with everything bagels that are soft yet crispy, perfect for breakfast sandwiches like bacon, egg, and cheese. Cozy, well-lit space offers outdoor seating and a warm vibe. Prices are higher but match the quality and location.
Soft yet crispy texture defines the everything bagel used for breakfast sandwiches. Options include bacon, egg, and cheese and a newer chorizo, egg, and cheese variant.
Good to know
Breakfast is available all day, which is a major advantage.
The menu offers a huge variety of food and desserts.
There is plenty of parking available.
Bagel shop offers fresh homemade bagels in unique flavors like pumpernickel and rainbow. Loud music creates a lively atmosphere despite the run-down look. Prices stay reasonable, making it a great spot for quality breakfast with many cream cheese options.
Freshly made bagels come in a great variety including pumpernickel, whole wheat everything, and rainbow options. Cream cheese and bagel sandwiches with fillings like chicken salad and sausage egg cheese add to the delicious selection.
Good to know
The products at Village Bagels are of high quality.
There is no seating available in the restaurant.
Village Bagels has its own parking lot, which is a significant advantage.
Small cafe offers a quiet atmosphere with fresh, high-quality ingredients. Breakfast bagels like sausage egg and cheese come with home fries and coffee. Clean, organized space creates a peaceful neighborhood vibe perfect for a calm meal.
Breakfast bagels feature sausage egg and cheese or ham egg and cheese on an everything bagel. These come with home fries and coffee for a filling meal.
Good to know
Parking is street parking only.
The menu offers a variety of hot and cold items.
Prices are reasonable for the quality of food.
Open 24 hours with a fast drive-thru, this donut shop serves fresh fluffy donuts and toasted bagels with tasty spreads like scallion cheese. Sandwiches and croissants offer generous portions and solid flavors in a clean, friendly spot perfect for breakfast or snacks.
Toasted bagels come out hot with a variety of spreads like scallion cheese and classic cream cheese. Options include savory choices like a turkey sausage, egg, and cheese on cinnamon raisin and fresh onion bagels.
Good to know
Donut Delight is open 24 hours, making it convenient for late-night cravings.
The drive-thru line moves quickly, even during busy hours.
Arrive early to find parking and avoid long lines that can extend onto the street.
Industrial design meets Jaws-themed art for a quirky, spooky vibe. Bagels and chocolate chip banana muffins pair perfectly with coffee. Cozy couches invite work or chill time, all set to a playlist of all bangers that keeps energy high.
Bagels come in a small selection alongside other baked goods like chocolate chip banana muffins. They pair well with coffee and appear as part of breakfast options including empanadas.
Good to know
Expect 10-15 minute wait times during busy weekends.
There is plenty of parking available.
The bathrooms at Perkatory Coffee Roasters are clean.
Donut shop offers outdoor seating with picnic tables in a chill vibe. Bagels come with eggs and avocado for a filling breakfast. Donuts are consistently solid, perfect for quick bites with coffee.
Everything bagels come with eggs and avocado for a filling breakfast sandwich. Quick stops often include bagels with toppings paired with coffee.
Good to know
Reservations are recommended due to limited seating inside.
The cafe can customize sandwiches to accommodate dietary preferences.
Be cautious of gluten cross-contamination if you have food allergies.
Small shop offers crispy bagels with soft insides, true to Jewish style. Top-quality breakfast sandwiches make mornings tasty but space is tight. Easy parking helps quick visits, though cash only keeps it simple.
Bagels have a crispy outside and a soft inside, reflecting traditional Jewish style. Varieties like egg everything and French toast offer subtle flavors that pair well with spreads.
Good to know
This place is strictly takeout with no seating available.
I needed to go early because they sell out fast.
It is inconvenient that the shop currently only accepts cash.
Cozy spot with fresh cinnamon rolls and a warm vibe. Bagels are toasted perfectly, crispy outside and soft inside. Friendly service and outdoor tables make it great for relaxing on warm days.
Bagels come fresh and toasted perfectly, crispy outside and soft inside. Options include an everything bagel with cream cheese and a unique eggplant parmesan on an everything bagel.
Good to know
The cafe is located on Wooster Street, between Sally’s Apizza and Frank Pepe’s Apizza.
Outdoor seating is limited to only two tables.
The cafe does not accept credit cards; cash is required.
Small shop offers jalapeno cheddar bagels and bacon egg sandwiches with fresh spreads. Cozy 10-foot breakfast bar seats four, creating an intimate vibe. Locally roasted coffee fills the air, making it a quiet spot with no wait times but limited hours.
Bagels come in unique flavors like jalapeno cheddar and cranberry orange, with a wide selection of spreads. Breakfast sandwiches with bacon, egg, and cheese on everything bagels are cooked to perfection and very popular.
Good to know
They frequently run out of bagels and cream cheese, especially early in the day.
The online hours are often inaccurate; check before visiting.
Expect high prices, with breakfast items costing around $10.
Classic deli space shines with fresh bagels and a local vibe that welcomes all. Best breakfast sandwiches pair well with a cash-only policy that keeps things simple. Prices vary but quality and tradition remain spotless and strong.
Freshness stands out with bagels baked perfectly to soothe taste buds. A plain bagel with tuna salad costs $9.86 plus tax, which feels high for a simple option.
Good to know
The deli only accepts cash payments; an ATM is available inside.
Prices for sandwiches may be higher than expected, starting around $5.50.
The deli is known for its cleanliness and is popular among locals.
Warm, rich smells of fresh bagels fill the air in a busy deli with a great variety of bagels like plain and everything. Long lines show how popular the breakfast and lunch menu is, blending tasty food with a lively atmosphere.
Freshness stands out with warm, rich smells of bagels on arrival. A great variety includes plain, raisin, and everything bagels, often paired with cream cheese smears or loaded with toppings like lox and capers.
Good to know
Expect long lines, especially on weekends.
Lenny's Bagels offers a full deli and breakfast menu.
Watch out for unwashed vegetables in your order.
Industrial coffee roaster fills the exposed brick space with rich aroma, creating a lively café vibe. Bagels are extremely salty and served untoasted, with a gluten-free option available. Outdoor seating faces a historic green under string lights, adding a cozy small town feel.
Bagels come with an extremely salty flavor and are served untoasted. The gluten-free bagel option exists but may not pair well with avocado toast.
Good to know
Cilantro Specialty Foods offers whole bean fresh roasted coffee for purchase.
Seating is limited, so expect to find few tables available indoors.
The cafe features a selection of imported cheeses and gourmet items.
Spacious coffee shop offers massive windows with views of historic architecture, creating a calm, quiet atmosphere perfect for work or study. Fresh New York style cinnamon raisin bagels arrive daily, toasted with cream cheese for a tasty treat. Seating ranges from comfy couches to private tables, all with plenty of outlets.
Fresh New York style cinnamon raisin bagels arrive daily, often toasted with cream cheese. Bagels here stand out for their tasty assortment and quality, though some spots serve stale bread.
Good to know
Fepo Cafe is open from 7 AM to 4 PM on weekdays and from 8 AM to 4 PM on weekends.
They offer delivery through DoorDash.
Fepo Cafe has a varied selection of food and beverages.
Small shop offers a casual, warm atmosphere with ample seating and a fresh, yeasty aroma. Bagels feature a dense, chewy interior and nutty sesame seeds on a golden-brown crust. Supports advance ordering for quick visits and group gatherings.
Fresh batches come out of the oven with a warm, yeasty aroma. Bagels have a dense, chewy interior and a golden-brown exterior with profound wheaty flavor and nutty sesame seeds.
Good to know
Advance ordering is available with a dedicated pickup area.
Street parking is metered around the location.
Gift cards may not work if the system is down; consider this before purchasing.