Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Mortadella sandwiches in New York

A thick, layered mortadella sandwich is the only thing that will satisfy a serious hunger.

Based on 813 Opinions
+810
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Pizzazz image 1
Pizzazz image 2
Pizzazz image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Small pizza shop offers handcrafted pizzas with fresh ingredients and a stone spinning oven for even cooking. Mortadella shines in artisanal sandwiches with burrata and pistachio pesto, and also on flavorful pizzas. Sandwiches like mortadella and prosciutto pair well with personal pies, perfect for sharing.

Mortadella sandwiches feature artisanal quality with burrata and pistachio pesto on perfect dough. The mortadella pizza also stands out for its exceptional flavor.

Mortadella and Prosciutto sandwiches stand out as favorites, with the mortadella described as artisanal and delicious. Sandwiches pair well with personal pies that serve as sharable appetizers.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The pizzas here are delicious, with a crispy crust and fresh ingredients."

"I thought the mortadella sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

There isn’t any indoor seating available at this pizza spot.

2

The entire process from placing the order to leaving takes only 5 minutes.

3

The restaurant imports almost all of their ingredients from Italy for quality.

02
Pace's Italian Market 2 image 1

Grocery store offers imported Italian products with an amazing selection of meats and cheeses including rare items like Guinciale. Atmosphere feels dark and uninviting with outdated decor, but the shop maintains a friendly vibe and provides samples during visits.

Sandwiches feature mortadella paired with smoked mozzarella or porchetta for rich, savory flavors.

Fresh ingredients make the sandwiches stand out with simple, delicious flavors. Options like mortadella and porchetta get strong recommendations and work well for picnics or to-go meals.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches were absolutely delicious and deliciously made with fresh ingredients."

"The Italian food selection here is outstanding, especially the Genoa salami."

"I was surprised by all the other quality Italian ingredients they sold, like Mortadella."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a variety of imported Italian products including pastas, cheeses, and cured meats.

2

Customers can sample products before purchasing, enhancing the shopping experience.

3

Expect to spend some time browsing as the shop is not a quick stop.

03
Anthony's Paninoteca image 1

Small sandwich shop with monochrome decor and marble checker floors creates a crisp, upscale atmosphere. Warm, friendly vibe fills the space with aromas of roasted meats and fresh bread. Primarily takeout with limited seating, it blends old-school style and modern touches.

Meats like mortadella and salami come layered with precision and balance alongside provolone. The prosciutto and mortadella hero stands out as a solid choice.

Huge portions and fresh, non-processed ingredients define the sandwiches here. The bread stands out, and each sandwich shows top notch attention to detail with amazing combinations.

People are saying

"I thought their sandwiches were amazing and really well done."

"The bread here is amazing, with great ingredients and super fresh."

"The mortadella sandwich was one of the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Sandwiches cost around $20, reflecting the quality of ingredients used.

2

Daily specials are available, with a different one each day.

3

Wednesday is pastrami day, featuring a special pastrami sandwich.

04
Panineria NYC image 1
Italian restaurant

Small Italian eatery offers cozy atmosphere with indoor and shaded outdoor seating. Sandwiches shine with fresh ingredients like mortadella in the Super Mario and Caprese options. Affordable wine and sangria add to the relaxed vibe, perfect for casual dining.

Super Mario sandwich features mozzarella, mortadella, prosciutto, salami, and arugula on toasty ciabatta. Mortadella pairs well with burrata and prosciutto in various sandwiches.

Italian sandwiches stand out with fresh ingredients and balanced flavors. The Caprese sandwich is a highlight, consistently delivering a delicious experience.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are fantastic, especially the burrata one."

"The pasta here is delicious and incredibly fresh."

"I loved the mortadella sandwiches with burrata and pistachios."

Good to know

1

Happy hour offers $5 glasses of wine.

2

The fall menu includes 50% off wine.

3

You can enjoy a healthy lunch for under $20 with coffee.

05
Crossroads Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Narrow hallway entrance leads to a space with trippy murals and eclectic furniture that feels like a cavernous retreat. Atmosphere blends warmth and energy, fostering a vibrant community hub with indoor and outdoor seating. Amenities include a vinyl DJ station, board games, and a sunny courtyard, creating a unique spot for connection and creativity.

Mortadella appears in a sandwich and an Egg & Cheese Focaccia. Both feature rich, savory flavors that stand out.

Croissant sandwiches use high-quality ingredients for a simple yet elevated taste. The egg & cheese sandwich stands out as a masterpiece. The Curry Chicken sandwich balances spicy, savory, and sweet flavors well.

People are saying

"The coffee here is amazing and gave me a great boost."

"I thought this sandwich was possibly the best I had in Brooklyn."

"I considered the Mortadella sandwich the best in all of NYC."

Good to know

1

The cafe is a great option for remote work with plenty of space and outlets.

2

The cafe hosts live performances a few times a week; check the schedule.

3

They host holistic events at their extension space, Alchemia Studios.

06
Crispy Heaven bakery and restaurant image 1

Small space with rustic decor and cramped seating creates an intimate setting. Warm, cozy atmosphere feels like a communal kitchen with European charm. Outdoor seating adds a relaxed option when weather permits.

Mortadella appears in several sandwiches, often paired with gouda or burrata on various breads like sesame buns and baguettes. These sandwiches keep it simple but deliver solid, consistent flavors.

Egg and tuna sandwiches stand out with rich flavors and fresh ingredients. The grass-fed short rib sandwich on a crisp baguette offers a hearty, satisfying meal.

People are saying

"The bread here is so fresh, warm, and delicious."

"I found the sandwiches here to be the best in Soho."

"I loved the mortadella and gouda sandwich on a sesame bun."

Good to know

1

Crispy Heaven just started doing dinners on Thursdays.

2

The establishment has a hidden no laptop policy not mentioned until after you’ve ordered.

3

You need to order before picking a table at the restaurant.

07
Best Sicily Bottega image 1

Small Sicilian deli and café blends authentic Italian products with freshly made sandwiches and pastries. Outdoor seating complements a quaint interior filled with decorative objects that evoke Southern Italy. Atmosphere feels like a slice of Sicily, offering a genuine Italian market and café experience.

Mortadella appears in sandwiches and focaccia with Fresh Mozzarella, Pistacchio, and Red peppers. The focaccia with mortadella and pistacchio stands out for its flavor combination.

Italian sandwiches feature Mortadella, Red peppers, and Fresh Mozzarella made with real Italian ingredients. They are light but filling and pair well with pastries like Bombolini.

People are saying

"I had the best coffee and espresso outside of Italy."

"I found the sandwiches here to be top-tier and delicious."

"You have to try the focaccia with mortadella and pistacchio."

Good to know

1

There is no restroom available for customers.

2

The establishment is open Monday to Friday from 8am to 8pm.

3

The cafe uses real Sicilian products for authenticity.

08
Titi's Empanadas - Williamsburg image 1
Latin American restaurant

Small space designed for quick service offers freshly made empanadas with a wide variety of Latin pastries and sauces. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with frequent Spanish spoken creating a community vibe. Spot stands out for unique plantain-based empanadas and a friendly, relaxed environment.

Freshly sliced mortadella shines in a crispy sandwich paired with cheese. The fatty meat balances well with tomato and vinaigrette acidity for a standout flavor.

Freshly sliced mortadella shines in the crispy sandwich, balanced by tomato and vinaigrette acidity. The Cuban sandwich and media noche empanada also stand out with rich, satisfying flavors.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and perfectly crisp."

"I tried the best empanadas and sandwiches here."

"The mortadella sandwich was the highlight of my visit."

Good to know

1

They have an evening Happy Hour with free mini empanadas with drinks.

2

The restaurant offers baked, fried, and a variety of other great baked goods and dishes.

3

There are many gluten-free choices available.

09
Vallata image 1
Italian restaurant

Open kitchen and lovely decor create a comfortable vibe with muted volume that supports easy conversation. The space feels inviting and relaxed, suitable for gatherings with family and friends. Music selection stands out as a distinctive feature enhancing the atmosphere.

Mortadella comes with a pistachio crunch, black garlic aioli, and arugula on house-made focaccia. The sandwich also includes creamy stracciatella and pistachio pesto for extra flavor.

Sandwiches feature creative, well balanced flavors with ingredients like Mortadella, Stracciatella, and Pistachio pesto on fantastic bread. Options include Italian styles and vegetarian choices, all made to come together cohesively for a flavorful lunch.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here have delicious food, especially the pizza and pasta."

"The sandwiches here are creative, flavorful, and made on fantastic bread."

"The Mortadella sandwich with pistachio pesto and black garlic aioli is delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant offers a pasta and wine special for $30 on weeknights.

2

Reservations are accepted on short notice for same-day dining.

3

The menu changes daily, ensuring fresh options each visit.

10
Luna La Mer image 1
Coffee shop

Tiny space feels airy and bright with thoughtful layout and creative floral touches. Atmosphere stays warm and cozy, inviting a chill, local vibe. Food offerings include gluten-free focaccia sandwiches and fresh pastries, highlighting attention to detail and quality.

Homemade salt-dusted focaccia holds mortadella, milky burrata, and fresh arugula. Pistachio kale pesto and a drop of oil add deep flavor to the sandwich.

Gluten-free biscuits star in the breakfast sandwich served only on weekends. The focaccia sandwich with mortadella stands out for its rich flavor and high quality execution.

People are saying

"I had a fantastic gluten-free focaccia sandwich and cappuccino."

"I can't go there and not get that gluten-free mortadella focaccia sandwich."

"The mortadella sandwich on homemade focaccia was unbelievable."

Good to know

1

The short rib focaccia sandwich is available only on Fridays, Saturdays, and Sundays.

2

Luna La Mer offers gluten-free, vegan, and regular menu options.

3

Catering services are available for events and gatherings.

11
All'Antico Vinaio image 1
Italian restaurant

Small space with rectangular bread sandwiches creates a genuine Tuscan vibe. Atmosphere feels welcoming and cozy, with limited seating mostly at counters and stools. Busy and lively, especially before midday, offering exceptional Italian flavors.

Mortadella comes with pistachio cream and stracciatella, creating a rich, creamy combo. It pairs well with Italian cold cuts and fresh bread, making sandwiches like the Paradiso stand out.

Fresh ingredients create incredible sandwiches with options that include gluten-free and dairy-free choices. The sandwiches stand out as some of the best ever had in multiple cities.

People are saying

"You have to try their Italian food; the sandwiches are amazing."

"I thought this sandwich was the best I ever had."

"The mortadella with pistachio cream and stracciatella was brilliant."

Good to know

1

Get to the restaurant early to avoid long lines during lunch rush hour.

2

Expect long wait times on weekends; arrive before 1pm for a shorter wait.

3

The sandwiches are large enough to share, making them ideal for families.

12
La Cantine image 1
French restaurant

Small space with chic 70s modern decor and warm ambiance. Outdoor seating shines on sunny days, paired with great playlists that enhance the vibe. Popular spot for fresh sandwiches and lively people watching, though waits can be long during peak times.

Sandwiches feature pistachio mortadella paired with plum jam for a unique flavor combo.

Sandwiches stand out with fresh chicken cutlet and house-made pickled ramp ranch. The curry tuna salad and cauliflower cutlet sandwiches also offer unique flavors. Breakfast options include a biscuit bacon, egg, and cheese sandwich that is messy but tasty.

People are saying

"I thought the breakfast sandwich with hot honey, onion, and egg was delicious."

"I loved the chilled red wine."

"The mortadella sandwich here is out of this world."

Good to know

1

It is a first come, first served situation with the tables.

2

Cantine gets extremely busy, especially during peak hours.

3

You order and pay at the counter.

13
Casa Toscana Bryant Park image 1

Outdoor seating by the park creates a European café vibe with a warm, cozy atmosphere enhanced by background music and nearby trees. The spot offers easy-to-use kiosks for convenient ordering and serves authentic Italian pastries and coffee in a peaceful, charming setting ideal for relaxing or people watching.

The mortadella sandwich features a burrata and pistachio combo that stands out. It offers a fresh take on classic flavors with creamy and nutty accents.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients like prosciutto, burrata, and arugula. Options include a truffle prosciutto focaccia and a miso glazed salmon sandwich with detailed presentation.

People are saying

"I loved the prosciutto truffle and burrata sandwich."

"I found the espresso here to be 100% authentic and smooth."

"The mortadella, burrata, and pistachio sandwich is so delicious and comforting."

Good to know

1

The kitchen closes at 8 PM, so plan your visit accordingly.

2

Only wireless payment methods are accepted; no credit card insertion available.

3

Expect to pay around $50 for two sandwiches and two coffee drinks.

14
The Lions Bar & Grill image 1

Bar and grill with cramped bar area and open windows creates a lively, vibrant atmosphere filled with old school energy. Crowds gather especially on weekends, drawn by the fun vibe and engaging banter. The space feels like an extension of home, blending indoor booths and outdoor sidewalk tables.

Mortadella sandwich features blue cheese, lettuce, and pickled peppers. It comes simple but delivers strong, delicious flavors.

Mortadella sandwich stands out with its blue cheese, lettuce, and pickled peppers. It comes cold and offers a simple but very good flavor combination.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be juicy and delicious."

"The fried mozzarella sticks were crispy, gooey, and piping hot."

"I found the mortadella sandwich to be amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted; it's first come, first served.

2

Expect long wait times, especially on weekends; plan to wait up to two hours.

3

The burger costs $19, and fries are an additional $4.

15
Zoller's image 1
Restaurant

Bright, airy space with glass kitchen window offers a casual, cozy atmosphere where people can relax or grab a quick bite. Seating is spacious and comfortable, encouraging lingering or reading. Specialty sandwiches and luxury grocery items add a unique touch beyond typical sandwich shops.

Thinly sliced mortadella piled high creates a standout sandwich. The combination with a cardamom knot earns a perfect rating.

Huge sandwiches come on fresh baked bread with high-quality ingredients like mortadella, roast beef, and mozzarella. Options include a Mort sandwich, a terrace turkey, and a BEC with perfectly cooked eggs and bacon that balances crunch.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are creative, hearty, and made with quality ingredients."

"The Italian subs here are huge, stuffed with a pound of meat and cheese."

"I had the best mortadella sandwich in NYC."

Good to know

1

The turkey and bacon sandwich costs $15 and is on the small side.

2

Delivery incurs a $7.50 service fee, so plan accordingly.

3

Zoller's offers a kid's menu with reasonable prices.

16
Spitfire Cheese & Sundry image 1

Cafe combines spacious seating with natural light and thoughtful details like bite-size cheeses and a dog-themed charcuterie board. Atmosphere stays cozy and inviting with pleasant music and a warm vibe. Regulars enjoy outdoor seating and a mix of craft cheeses alongside sandwiches and bakery items.

Toasted flaky bread and spicy mustard stand out with the mortadella. The sandwich has a slight underlying sweetness and could use more mustard for balance.

Sandwiches come hot and tasty with a New York style twist. They offer affordable, delicious options that work well for a quick meal or a picnic.

People are saying

"I loved the coffee and the vibes here."

"I thought the tuna melt sandwich was the best I had ever had."

"I thought the Mortadella sandwich was the best I had ever had."

Good to know

1

The shop opens early for lattes and croissants.

2

As of 5/8/24, the shop has a limited selection and areas under construction.

3

There is no bathroom available.

17
Da Capo Aperitivo e Caffè image 1

Cozy neighborhood cafe with an enclosed patio area and a European vibe featuring natural light and vegetation. Welcoming atmosphere suits gatherings and relaxed work sessions, despite some street noise. Offers ample seating including a back room that feels like an indoor garden.

Mortadella paninis stand out with their authentic Italian flavor and rich, savory taste. Options include combinations like mortadella and prosciutto, served in well-crafted sandwiches.

Delicious sandwiches like the caprese and mortadella stand out. Options come with quick service and pair well with coffee drinks like cold brew.

People are saying

"The coffee here is delicious and expertly prepared."

"I found the focaccia sandwiches here to be amazing."

"I thought the mortadella panini was one of the best I'd ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Da Capo can accommodate large guest lists for private events.

2

The café does not have wifi, requiring customers to use their own hotspot.

3

As of November 2023, Da Capo has no current liquor license.

18
Panineria UES image 1
Sandwich shop

Sandwich shop offers a cozy, intimate space with authentic Italian vibes and small seating areas including a cute outdoor table. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, resembling a little nook in Italy. Energy stays relaxed, suited for quick bites or sharing meals with friends.

Mortadella comes in thin layers with a few small provolone triangles and olive oil on soft, airy ciabatta. The sandwich tastes fresh and like Italian bologna but the mortadella quality is not the best.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients with meat sliced to order. Options include Italian classics like the Portofino and meatball sandwiches, plus build-your-own choices with mozzarella, pesto, and roasted peppers on baguette.

People are saying

"I ate some of the best sandwiches I have ever had."

"It's a small, cozy spot with a great vibe."

"I found the Mortadella sandwich to be delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

They offer genuine Italian products, freshly made paninis, and classic sandwiches.

2

The menu is affordable for each patron.

3

This is a family-owned business since 2014.

19
Win Son Bakery image 1

Bakery combines inviting interiors with lively atmosphere and plentiful seating including bar and outdoor tables. The space attracts many working alone on laptops, creating a steady, focused energy. Decor balances trendy yet authentic vibes without pretension.

Mortadella shines in several sandwiches, especially on scallion pancakes and with pickled peppers. The egg and peppers milk bun with mortadella stands out as a flavorful option.

Scallion pancake sandwiches stand out with their crispy texture and flavorful wrap. Breakfast sandwiches also impress with their rich taste and satisfying build.

People are saying

"I loved the light crisp and moist center of the scallion pancakes."

"I found the mochi donut to be exceptionally good."

"The mortadella sandwich was so delicious and tasty."

Good to know

1

Expect a long line on weekends.

2

Food takes about 25 minutes to prepare.

3

Sandwiches start being served after 3:30 PM.

20
Brooklyn Hero Shop image 1
Sandwich shop

European-style Italian delicatessen design creates an authentic and warm atmosphere filled with good smells and a friendly vibe. Outdoor seating offers people and dog watching, enhancing the relaxed neighborhood feel. Music and conversation contribute to an awesome New Yorker vibe that sets it apart from typical sandwich shops.

Mortadella appears in sandwiches with sporesatta, arugula, olive oil, and balsamic on a crisp roll. It features alongside items like speck and burrata, and appears in a Cubano panini and a roasted turkey hero.

Sandwiches feature soft, delightful bread and come in varieties like fried chicken, meatball, Philly, and Italian. Creations are perfectly balanced and stand out from ordinary deli sandwiches with fresh, delicious ingredients.

People are saying

"I found the sandwiches here delicious and amazing."

"The American Food here is great, and the staff is super friendly."

"I declared that mortadella was forever; it was perfect."

Good to know

1

You need to order at the cashier.

2

The Nashville chicken sandwich costs $14.15.

3

The shop has a large menu with something for everyone.

21
Travelers Poets & Friends image 1
Italian restaurant

Warm, inviting space blends upscale Italian decor with a cozy, intimate vibe. Offers outdoor seating and an attached Italian market with fresh pasta and sauces. Atmosphere feels like sharing drinks and meals in a friend's home.

Mortadella appears in sandwiches with pistachios and burrata on focaccia. The mortadella is served in generous portions and stands out as a key ingredient.

Sandwiches feature organic bread and high-quality ingredients like mortadella piled high on focaccia. The chicken parm sandwich combines gooey cheese and tomato sauce with juicy chicken on a crunchy baguette.

People are saying

"I devoured the pasta; it was the best I'd had this side of Italy."

"I loved the mortadella sandwich piled high on focaccia."

"I loved the mortadella sandwich piled high on focaccia."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drinks are $10 aperols from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

A 4 piece band plays live music on Sundays.

3

The establishment is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

22
Brown Bag Sandwich Co image 1

Small sandwich shop with a cozy bodega vibe and vintage decor creates a nostalgic atmosphere. The space feels busy and chaotic with limited seating, encouraging takeout or eating outside. Friendly energy and chopped cheese popularity draw steady crowds despite long waits.

Mortadella comes with pistachios and black peppercorns, crisped edges add a bacon-like crunch. Muffuletta sandwiches pack chopped mortadella evenly with olives, balanced by dijon mustard that cuts the fat.

Sandwiches come with world class bread and fresh, quality ingredients. The Italian sandwich and Hot Roast Beef stand out for their flavor and care in preparation.

People are saying

"The chopped cheese sandwich is excellent, a true chef's kiss."

"The bread here is super fresh and of high quality."

"The mortadella here is packed with pistachios and crisped edges."

Good to know

1

There are monthly specials and a secret menu to try.

2

The price of the chicken caesar wrap is $20.

3

Plan accordingly for the wait time of around 15-20 minutes.

23
Salty Lunch Lady's Little Luncheonette image 1

Restaurant offers a vintage decor with teal paint, tile, and unique hanging lamps from former Yugoslavia. Atmosphere feels welcoming and kid-friendly with a self-service setup and seating inside and outside. Sandwiches and desserts are thoughtfully crafted and highly praised for flavor and quality.

Mortadella here varies a lot. One sandwich features nicely warmed, crispy bread, tender Italian sausage, and curly escarole. Another has day-old bread, low-grade mortadella, and limp lettuce.

Sandwiches come fresh and look simple but are actually very elevated. The bologna sandwich made with mortadella stands out as a best-ever choice, while the Gooey Gratin Sandwich offers a cheesy, crunchy bite with a lemon drizzle twist.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best in town."

"I thought the desserts were delicious."

"I thought the mortadella sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-30 minute wait for orders during peak hours.

2

Customers should arrive early as supplies run out quickly.

3

Sandwiches are priced at $15, and portions are small.

24
ALIDORO image 1
Sandwich shop

Cozy sandwich shop with dim lighting and industrial charm creates a rustic, stylish vibe. Large wooden tables and open space invite casual dining or quick takeout. Crowds form quickly, often filled with energetic, urban clientele.

Mortadella appears as a sweeter meat option, often paired with prosciutto. It features in sandwiches like the Romeo on semolina bread, offering a solid flavor profile.

Italian sandwiches stand out with focaccia bread and rich flavors like fresh cheddar and truffle cream. Portions are generous and the sandwiches offer a flavor explosion that redefines taste.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here have super fresh meats and great bread."

"This lunch spot has unbelievable sandwiches with amazing variety and taste."

"I'm planning to return to try the other sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during lunch hours, especially on weekdays.

2

Prices are high, with sandwiches costing around $16 to $20.

3

Order ahead if you have a limited lunch time to avoid long lines.

25
Sullivan Street Bakery and Pizza image 1

Small bakery with cozy, casual atmosphere and outdoor seating on a pleasant terrace. Music plays loudly in the morning, creating a lively but sometimes overwhelming vibe. Bread stands out for being preservative-free and highly regarded.

Mortadella sandwiches come fresh and light. The La Mortadela sandwich is popular but now served in a smaller portion costing $14 for half.

Brioche bread stands out with a slightly salty taste that complements the egg and avocado sandwich well. Sandwich options range from savory to sweet, including a decent roast beef that is better served warm.

People are saying

"The pastries here are beautiful and delicious."

"I found the bread here to be one of New York's best."

"I loved the mortadella sandwich; it was so fresh and light."

Good to know

1

The establishment closes at 8 PM.

2

The pick-up process for the order is quick and smooth.

3

They offer unique sweet and savory baked items.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...