Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Historic Mitchell Street

Food

A meal that captures the character of the neighborhood instead of just serving the same generic options found everywhere else.

Based on 604 Opinions
+601
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Taqueria Los Gallos image 1
Taqueria Los Gallos image 2
Taqueria Los Gallos image 3
View all
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant serves authentic dishes with vibrant flavors. Friendly, family-owned vibe draws a diverse crowd including families and after-work singles. Space is tight, perfect for a quick lunch with good music and fair prices.

Food features vibrant flavors and authentic Mexican dishes with consistently excellent quality.

People are saying

"The tacos here are the best I've ever had."

"I found the food to be delicious and vibrant."

"The spicy salsa here is great."

Good to know

1

Prices are subject to change, so confirm before ordering.

2

The establishment may close earlier than advertised hours.

3

It's better to order takeout due to limited seating.

02
La Guelaguetza image 1
Mexican restaurant

Taco truck serves authentic Mexican flavors with al pastor tacos and birria quesadillas. Open late until 2AM, it offers excellent prices for tasty, affordable food. Cash-only and watch your order for accuracy.

Food offers tasty Mexican dishes that are both good and affordable. Checking your order is important due to occasional issues with accuracy.

People are saying

"I thought the al pastor tacos here were the best Mexican food."

"The food here is delicious and tasty."

"I loved the birria quesadilla with the handmade tortilla."

Good to know

1

Bring cash as only cash payments are accepted.

2

The truck is open until 2AM for late-night taco cravings.

3

Prices are excellent for the quality of food offered.

03
Margaritaโ€™s Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small spot shines with quick Mexican dishes and a 10 for $10 wing special. Pizza and calzones offer fresh flavors but don't impress as much. Takeout is best since dining in is not recommended.

Mexican food stands out as the real gem here, with dishes prepared very quickly. Pizza does not impress as much, and dining in is not recommended.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was really tasty and delicious."

"I thought the pizza here was extremely delicious."

Good to know

1

They offer a 10 for $10 wing special with bone-in wings.

2

This is definitely a takeout spot.

3

They have a small bar if you want to eat there.

04
Carnitas Machetes image 1
Mexican restaurant

Mexican restaurant buzzes with loud music and mariachi performances. Carnitas and handmade tortillas shine as authentic dishes. Vibrant vibe suits lively crowds, not families.

Delicious carnitas and authentic Mexican dishes stand out here. The food often surpasses the service and offers a taste similar to traditional homemade meals.

People are saying

"I found the carnitas to be the best I had ever had."

"I found the food here to be delicious and full of flavor."

"You have to try the handmade tortillas; they're delicious."

Good to know

1

They are only open on weekends.

2

The restaurant is busy in the morning, and there is sometimes a wait.

3

You can order and choose carnitas to go if you're in a hurry.

05
El Tlaxcalteca Restaurant image 1
Mexican restaurant

Small, cozy spot with authentic decor and a casual atmosphere that feels like Mexico. Birria tacos stand out for their great flavor and come with free chips and salsa. Family friendly and set in a lively neighborhood.

Food here is authentic Mexican with a focus on birria that delivers consistently great flavor and quality every time.

People are saying

"The food here is packed with flavor and never disappoints."

"The birria here is amazing, especially the quesabirria tacos."

"The salsa here is fresh, chunky, and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult to find due to shared lot with Mercado del Rey.

2

The restaurant offers a variety of authentic Mexican dishes.

3

They provide takeout options for those who prefer to eat at home.

06
La Michoacana Premium image 1
Ice cream shop

Spacious ice cream shop serves unique flavors and vegan-friendly options in a clean, inviting space. Affordable meals like elotes cost about $20 and often leave leftovers. Families and groups enjoy quality food in a comfortable atmosphere.

Food includes delicious ice cream, elotes, and other tasty dishes. Meals cost about $20 and often leave plenty of leftovers.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was the best in town."

"I enjoyed the delicious ice cream and food."

Good to know

1

La Michoacana Premium offers a wide variety of unique ice cream flavors.

2

The establishment is vegan-friendly with a selection of whole fruits.

3

There is no formal menu, making it hard to decide on orders.

07
La Carreta Vieja image 1
Mexican restaurant

Spacious Mexican spot shines with authentic seafood and top-rated tacos. Lively lounge vibe pairs well with well-crafted margaritas. Neighborhood adds edge, but generous portions keep guests coming back.

Offers authentic Mexican food with dishes that are consistently well prepared and delicious. The mojarra a la diabla stands out for those who enjoy spicy flavors.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and well prepared."

"I found the tacos here to be the best Mexican food in Milwaukee."

"I found the seafood here delicious and authentic."

Good to know

1

Expect generous portions; a meal can be under $20 including tip.

2

The area around the restaurant may feel unsafe at times.

3

The restaurant is known for its seafood options.

08
El Rey FoodMart image 1
Mexican grocery store

Mexican grocery store features authentic Mexican ingredients and Puerto Rican products with a busy, clean atmosphere and security. Food options include ready-to-eat Spanish dishes served hot and tasty, offering a calm dining experience despite higher prices. Meat prices remain competitive.

Offers a great variety of food including Spanish dishes and ready to eat, just heat options. Food arrives hot and delicious with consistent quality and a calm dining experience.

People are saying

"The food here is always good and delicious."

"I found the grocery store prices to be great."

"I thought the Mexican Food tamales here were the best ever."

Good to know

1

El Rey FoodMart offers a great selection of authentic Mexican ingredients and staples.

2

Many groceries are overpriced compared to other local stores.

3

Milk costs almost $5 at El Rey FoodMart, significantly higher than at other stores.

09
KFC image 1
Chicken restaurant

Chicken is golden brown and crispy with seasoned fries. Staff serves food hot and fresh within 2 minutes. Space stays very clean with friendly workers and a fast, safe drive-thru.

Food comes out hot and fresh with excellent quality. Staff prepares orders quickly, usually within 2 minutes.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"The drive-thru staff are super friendly and fast."

"The American food, especially the chicken, was golden brown and crispy."

Good to know

1

The establishment is clean and the workers are friendly.

2

Drive-thru service is quick and efficient.

3

Expect meal prices to be higher than average.

Discover more

Historic Mitchell Street, Milwaukee

Area guide
Loading Map...