Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Pizza and Seafood

A quick pizza slice satisfies the immediate hunger, but the evening calls for the distinct, briny taste of seafood.

Based on 567 Opinions
+564
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 1
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 2
L&B Spumoni Gardens image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Big space with comfortable seating and a mix of counter and table service creates a casual, lively vibe. Atmosphere is warm and friendly but can be very loud and sweltering without strong air conditioning. Popular for thick crust Sicilian pizza and a bustling, nostalgic feel.

Slices come in large portions with a rich, creamy texture typical of New York pizza. Only plain square or round slices are available, and they tend to be greasy, which can be managed with a napkin.

Seafood dishes feature fresh shrimp and baked clams that stand out for their flavor. Sicilian pizza and rigatoni with vodka sauce complement the seafood offerings well.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing, truly the best I've ever tasted."

"The Sicilian pizza had a thick crust and rich flavor."

"The pizza slices are large, rich, and filling."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

2

The restaurant charges $3.12 for a small bottle of water.

3

Only one vegetarian option is available on the menu.

02
Strictly Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Modern, clean space with contemporary design and a bright, inviting atmosphere. Guests watch pizzas being made fresh, adding to the engaging experience. The vibe stays relaxed and calm, making it comfortable for casual dining.

Slices offer a straightforward option for quick pizza. The buffalo chicken slice tastes average but fits the casual vibe.

Shrimp scampi appears often and pairs with other items like the grandma slice. The tuna fish salad pizza stands out as unique and surprising. Other seafood options include dishes combined with sausage and chicken.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and really good."

"I found the seafood here to be just too good."

"The pizza slices were still hot and fresh even late."

Good to know

1

Strictly Pizza stays open late when other pizza joints are closed.

2

They accept credit cards, which not all slice shops do.

3

The restaurant is very clean and well-maintained.

03
Vinny’s Gluten Free Kitchen image 1

Small Italian eatery with separate pizza ovens and gluten-free menu options offers a clean, welcoming space with open windows and doors. Atmosphere blends NYC pizza shop vibes with a casual, relaxed energy. Seating suits dine-in comfort amid a busy urban setting.

Slices feature a vegan ricotta kale topping that stands out. The pizza offers a gluten free option with a good balance of flavors.

Gluten-free fish and chips feature a tasty seasoned batter that stands out. The fish stays crispy and flavorful without gluten.

People are saying

"I finally had amazing gluten-free pizza that tasted like real pizza."

"I loved the gluten-free pizza slices; the base tasted just like regular crust."

"The seafood here, especially the fish and chips, has a tasty seasoned batter."

Good to know

1

They have a separate gluten-free menu, but it's not 100% safe for celiacs.

2

Expect cross-contamination as they share equipment with gluten items.

3

Celiacs should beware of potential cross-contamination.

04
Two Boots Pizza Upper West Side image 1

Funky pizza joint with colorful decor and a retro vibe creates a friendly, local atmosphere. Offers vegan and gluten-free options alongside unique Cajun-Italian pizza combinations. Small and cozy space with outdoor seating available.

Slices come in a good variety with options like vegan pizza and unique Cajun-Italian combos. They offer a funky selection that stands out for quick stops.

Shrimp features prominently on pizzas, especially the Bayou Beast which combines it with bold flavors. The seafood adds a distinct twist to the usual pizza options.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza was super delicious and tasty."

"The Bayou pizza's seafood had big Southern flavor."

"I found the pizza slices here to be fantastic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is open until midnight on Friday and Saturday.

2

Each slice is around $5, making it budget friendly.

3

A large pizza can feed up to 4 people.

05
F&F Pizzeria image 1
Pizza restaurant

Outdoor seating includes a garden-style backyard framed by grape vines, creating a relaxed and community-driven vibe. The space is well-lit and casual, with a mix of traditional and Sicilian pizza slices served. Energy stays friendly and local, especially in the chill outdoor area.

NY style pizza slices come by the slice here. The pizza slices offer a classic, straightforward option for a quick bite.

Clam pizza features fresh clams, mozzarella, Parmesan, and parsley with a squeeze of lemon. Other slices include toppings like Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, Pecorino Romano, and Calabrian chili.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The outdoor seating here is perfect for enjoying their delicious, crispy crust pizza."

"I loved the pizza slices with their excellent crispy crust and great flavor."

Good to know

1

Be prepared to wait if you visit during prime time.

2

A slice of pizza costs between 4 to 5 dollars.

3

The restaurant closes at 9 PM.

06
42nd Street Pizza and Restaurant image 1

Cozy pizza restaurant with an old 1980s diner vibe and Greek family-owned charm. Spacious, clean interior features blue chairs and round bar stools alongside a diner counter. Outdoor seating offers views of the Hudson River, creating a welcoming and warm atmosphere.

Slices come in large sizes compared to European standards and sell at a great price. Options include classic pizza slices alongside other items like gyros.

Shrimp pasta stands out with homemade sauce and fresh seafood. Linguine with seafood and shrimp calamari pasta offer delicious, well-balanced flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is surprisingly good and delicious."

"I found the shrimp pasta to be delicious and scraped it clean."

"I found the pizza slices to be excellent and a great price."

Good to know

1

You can choose a free dessert if you leave a review.

2

They charge many 'secret' fees that can add up to $15 extra on your bill.

3

The restaurant may autotip without mentioning it.

07
Cuts & Slices image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small space with late 80s and early 90s decor and free arcade games creates a lively, nostalgic vibe. Atmosphere feels exciting and non-judgmental despite crowding and limited seating. Lines form early due to unique pizza options like jerk chicken and oxtail slices.

Unique pizza slices feature toppings like oxtail, salmon/truffle, and lobster/crab. Variety includes many loaded options that taste delicious.

Unique pizzas feature oxtail, garlic shrimp, and curry shrimp toppings. The shrimp slice stands out for its flavor, while the black truffle shrimp and lobster Alfredo pizza lacks truffle taste.

People are saying

"I found the pizza here to be fantastic and delicious."

"The oxtail pizza is rich, tender, and flavorful."

"The oxtail pizza slices are excellent and memorable."

Good to know

1

Get there at least an hour before opening to avoid long lines.

2

Expect to wait up to 2 hours for a table during peak times.

3

The line on Thursday afternoons is about a 20-minute wait.

08
Krispy Pizza- Brooklyn, NY image 1

Neighborhood pizza spot offers a homey, no-frills setting with plenty of booths and seating. Atmosphere feels welcoming and relaxed, encouraging casual comfort and friendly interactions. Known for authentic, mouthwatering pizza with unique flavors not found elsewhere.

Slices show excellent flavor and freshness. The margarita slice has no flop action and packs a lot of taste. A simple trio with just sauces and cheese stands out as a delicious classic.

Seafood features grilled shrimp and a seafood combo that pairs well with pizza. Fridays often bring seafood soup alongside the main dishes.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best pizza in New York City."

"The pepperoni pizza slices with hot honey were delicious."

"You have to try the seafood combo with angel hair pasta."

Good to know

1

Customers should order in advance because the place is always busy.

2

You get 6 slices, knots, and 3 drinks for around $40.

3

The penne alla vodka pizza is only sold by the pie and not slices.

09
La Vita image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious pizza restaurant with plenty of seating and outdoor dining keeps a laid back and lively atmosphere. Music leans toward 80s disco, creating a unique vibe. Staff enthusiasm adds to the welcoming energy.

Large pizza slices come with generous toppings and a wide variety of options. The quality ranges from decent to acceptable by New York City standards.

Shrimp dishes come in great portion sizes with the shrimp pasta standing out. Linguine includes a generous amount of clams, but shrimp scampi offers only six shrimp, which feels light for the price.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was amazing and delicious."

"I thought the pizza slices here were the best in the neighborhood."

"The shrimp parmigiana here is delicious."

Good to know

1

This restaurant is one of the only places open late.

2

A slice of spinach pizza and a drink to eat in costs $8.

3

The cheese slice is only $2.75 plus tax, making it $3 total.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...